Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

O.T. I am a hypocrite

Posts

O.T. I am a hypocrite

#1

O.T. I am a hypocrite

John Pappas

>because I am normally opposed to O.T. Posts. Am looking into replacing a very old furnace, and would welcome any comments anyone may have to offer. Considering brands such as Lennox, Carrier, Trane, Rheem, and others. Will probably be a high efficiency model(I am in Denver( and include air conditioning. Any heads-up on what to insisist on, and what to avoid. Thanks (and forgive the O.T. post.)

John

Re: O.T. I am a hypocrite

#2

Re: O.T. I am a hypocrite

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

>I have an American Standard that is 2+ years old. Good solid built unit.

Howard

Re: O.T. I am a hypocrite

#3

Re: O.T. I am a hypocrite

Ted Wong

>If you are in a climate that doesn't get too terribly cold for long periods of time you may want to consider a heat pump.

Re: O.T. I am a hypocrite

#4

Re: O.T. I am a hypocrite

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>I have a Ruud gas furnace and also a heat pump. The heat pump cools in the summer and heats until the temps get down to 35, then the furnace kicks on. I told the furnace guy I didn't want hot and cold spells and after 5 years I am very pleased with the functionality of both units.

Ray

Re: O.T. I am a hypocrite

#5

My 2¢ will be utterly useless…

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach, FL

>…but that won't stop me from offering it.

In 1978, when we built our house in Illinois, I was enamored of the Lennox marque, and specified one for our house. Any complaints I have about it are more due to the HVAC guy who did the ductwork than the unit itself, as I seem to recall that the furnace (with A/C) functioned just fine the entire 21 years that we lived there. We did have a couple of service calls, but they were more of the nature of routine or expected maintenance rather than a reflection on the unit itself. This opinion is worthless because it describes a 30 year old installation.

In our current house, we have a Carrier, with which I am thoroughly pleased. It was installed by the late owner in '97 or '98 and runs great. I'm particularly impressed with the slow windup of the blower, as it's almost impossible to tell when it comes on, and runs very quietly in any event when it gets up to speed. It should be apparent that this unit is primarily A/C and is what we in Florida call reverse cycle, AKA heat pump, for heat. This opinion is worthless because we're in Florida and subject to a load of different circumstances (obviously) than yours.

Nevertheless…

Rod

Re: O.T. I am a hypocrite

#6

Re: O.T. So here's what you need...

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I have no idea what technical stuff you need, because I live in California.

What you need is a strong dealer, who has been in business for more than 45 minutes, and knows your area well. And who will be there, when something goes wrong in several months or years or decades.

Talk to your neighbors in town, particularly those with older homes, who have been through a replacement cycle. Find out who is happy, and why. Then talk to their service people, and schedule an unhurried installation, well before the snow flies...

We redid our system about 5 years ago, maybe more, and have been very happy with the Lennox we bought. But I had to go look to see what the brand was. I could have told you the name of the company, and the name of the person with whom we dealt, without looking.

Re: O.T. I am a hypocrite

#7

Re: O.T. I am a hypocrite

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Having worked in the HVAC installation for 20+ years as a second job, I will say you really won't see a whole lot of difference in the various brands as far as reliability or efficiency provided you purchase the high efficiency unit. I would get several quotes for the furnace and air - have a heat pump quoted at the same time. I would look at the prices (and references) more than the brand. That said I personally favor Heil units as they are quite easy to work on and parts are available from Sears (last I knew all sears units are Quaker Heil with Sears nameplate). I have a Heil unit in my house. I purchased a Payne furnace for my shop (97% efficient, direct vent) - bought it at a Surplus house with the air cabinet, air conditioning compressor, tubing and evaporator coil for a total of about $1600 - Has worked perfectly for about 3 years with no attention. I would currently look at a heat pump if you can get it with a conventional gas furnace - the electric coil type furnaces used with the early heat pumps were so expensive to operate when the temperature dropped below 40 deg. that the system actually cost more to operate than conventional units in most areas. Heat pumps are extremely efficient at temperatures above 40 deg so if you have a lot of days with these temperatures I would definitely purchase a heat pump. A couple of cautions: First ask for recommendations from past customers (and call them to verify) for any contractors you have quote the installation. Also find out - unless you do your own service work - if the installer services what they sell - may pay to find out what their normal service charge is and again see if they can furnish references. I maintained a top reputation by being honest with all my customers, I never left one unsatisfied - even if I lost money on the job. My reputation was more valuable to me than the few dollars I could gain by cutting corners or leaving a dissatisfied customer.

Re: O.T. I am a hypocrite

#8

Re: O.T. I am a hypocrite

Barry Irby

>John, I agree with the others that you should find a good reputable dealer and then pick his favorite brand. It is my understanding the there are a lot fewer furnace manufacturers than there are brand names out there. I have been told that several manufacturers make only one size unit and then trade units with other makers to get the variety of sizes they need. So the quality is indistinguishable. Rheem and Ruud are identical except for color. Carrier, Payne, Daynight and Bryant(?) are all the same company. American Standard owns Trane. This is not to say the units are completely identical, but there isn't a lot of fundamental difference.

Its also time to look at upgrading your installation, caulking/air sealing, and possibly windows. Reducing your demand might be more cost effective than spending on high efficiency units. Smarter to insulate first and then install a slightly undersized unit.

Re: O.T. I am a hypocrite

#9

Re: O.T. I am a hypocrite

Bill White

>Brands, as you can tell, are all over the posts. The company I work with sells Armstrong (div. of Lennox). Big kicker today is efficiency. SEER ratings are the relative measure of efficiency. Min. today is 13 SEER, and I think that a SEER rating of 16 is top.

As was said, SERVICE is the key to your satisfaction with any unit.

Caveat emptor as you buy.

Bill

Re: O.T. I am a hypocrite

#10

Re: O.T. I am a hypocrite *LINK*

Jim Dillon

>John,

Any of the brands you mentioned, if properly sized and installed, will likely give you good service. I went through this several years ago and am very pleased (so far 8-)) with the Trane heat pump in the MD/VA area. Our yearly electrical bill actually went DOWN even though we did not have AC before. Anyhow, the advice you've gotten is solid IMHO. Keep in mind that that the higher the SEER value, the greater the price and the longer the payback - if ever. A minimum SEER of 13 is now required by law. In your area, I would pay attention to the heating efficiency value (I forget the acronymn for it right now) but heat pumps can differ as far as their efficiency goes for heating. Below a certain point, however, the auxillary heat coil kicks in. Pick a good dealer, one who listens to your needs and is willing to supply references, and go for it. Depending on your natural gas prices, a dual heat pump and gas furnace might be an option. Here is a link to a great forum about all things HVAC related. Good luck.

Jim


HVAC-Talk Forum

Re: O.T. I am a hypocrite

#11

Re: O.T. I am a hypocrite

Marv

>How can there be an off topic post here in this Message board? It's open to most any subject, right?

Marv

Re: O.T. I am a hypocrite

#12

Thanks for your responses.

John Pappas

>

Re: O.T. I am a hypocrite

#13

Re: O.T. I am a hypocrite

Brian in Brighton

>John, We have a high effeciency furnace in my new house and it has a secondary set of pipes for bringing in fresh air. You might want to check into this as I do not understand it completely. We also only have a 2 inch PVC pipe for the outlet of the burned gas (no vertical roof stack since it goes out the wall)

Brian in Brighton

You're welcome to come visit it. Send me a private e-mail and I will give you directions.

Re: O.T. I am a hypocrite

#14

If you have access to lots of water or ground

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>If you have access to lots of water or ground around the house, consider a geothermal heat pump. I have one. It has worked with a single service call (water valve died) for 25 years. I heat 2200 sq ft for @ $120 per month. I also cook and heat water with eletric. No other utility bills or wood stoves are present. The newer units are even better than mine and also come with switchable A/C.

Lee

Re: O.T. I am a hypocrite

#15

Re: Brian that is a direct vent

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>The second pipe is normally used to bring in outside air for the combustion. This makes the furnace quite a bit more efficient. In the normal older furnaces the combustion air (everything that goes up the chimney less the fuel used) came from inside the structure. Remember that all the air going out of the house has to be replaced by outside air. If it is 10 Deg. outside - thats a lot of very cold air pulled in through the cracks around the windows, doors, foundation & floor etc. With the direct vent the outside air stays outside - the air needed to burn the fuel comes in through the intake piping. The burning takes place in a sealed chamber and vented out through the exhaust pipe. I have one in my shop. This type also eliminates the possibility of wood dust entering the combustion chamber - and possibly starting an unwanted fire outside the furnace.

Re: O.T. I am a hypocrite

#16

Re: O.T. I am a hypocrite

charlie self

>Forget Carrier. That's what I've got. About two months after the warranty expired, the A coil had to be replaced because of a factory screw-up. Requested break came under the heading of TS. They saved themselves a few hundred bucks that way, but eventually this unit will need replacing, which I'm reasonably sure brings in more than that in profit. But not from me.

Re: O.T. I am a hypocrite

#17

Re: I agree Lee

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>The few geothermal I have seen were very efficient. They do require enough water depth (in a lake or pond) that the ice does not reach the intake / outlet during the winter. The only gripes I've had with heat pumps were 1) the price and 2) the method in which the devices heat when the heat pump is no longer efficient. With Geothermal and deep water, #2 is no longer an issue. With the price of heating fuel - whether it be NG Propane, Fuel oil or Electric, Item #1 is less of an issue. The Geothermal also has an advantage in the air conditioning efficiency so costs will be reduced year around. This may make the additional cost of the system payback in a lot less years.