Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Another question for the Car Guys OT

Posts

Another question for the Car Guys OT

#1

Another question for the Car Guys OT

Barry Irby

>I have a 2003 Honda CRV. Often the key is hot when I take it out of the ignition. Not really hot, but unpleasantly warm. Somewhere along the way I noticed the Cruise control would be OFF and I would have to reach down to the button near the door and turn the master switch back on or it would not engage from the button on the steering wheel. I assumed I was hitting the master button with my knee as I got in and out. (I actually was not aware of bumping the button, but it could have happened and it was an easy "fix" to just turn it back on.) Soon after I got the car, there was a recall and the dealer replaced a "module" in the steering column. Took about five minutes. Also, the car goes through about a battery a year. They go bad and Honda replaces them, but no more since the car is over three years old.

The other day the SRS (Supplemental Restraint system) light came on. I looked it up in the manual and it said it affected the airbags and to take it to the dealer. I also noticed I did not have cruise control at all. The dealer pointed out I did not have a horn either and that apparently a wire that affects all three things had gone bad. The want about $121 for the wiring harness and a similar amount to install it. (Its on order)

I know the car is 4 years old and has 95,000 miles on it, but I am a little put out by this. I suspect there has been something wrong with the wire for a long time and that it accounts for the key getting hot and the cruise control being intermittent. I had mentioned the hot key to the dealer before, but their answer was "they do that".

What do you think? How can I tell if this is a known problem? Would looking at the wire tell me anything? How would I tell if it were a long term problem or just a wire the chaffed through and shorted.

Re: Another question for the Car Guys OT

#2

Re: Another question for the Car Guys OT

John McGaw

>I have no definite knowledge of your complaint but a quick online search suggests that Honda has had a rather bad record when it comes to ignition switches. And it is certain that the ignition key should not be heating as you have experienced. And one of the earlier recalls was for an ignition switch which could become so hot that wires would unsolder themselves in the switch. My suspicion is that you have had a bum switch from day one although proving it now may well be impossible unless you have documented complaints from during the warranty period. Did you ever complain to them officially about the key heat problem?

Re: Another question for the Car Guys OT

#3

Re: Another question for the Car Guys OT

Barry Irby

>No, I did not. It did not get really hot and I accepted the brush off. Just now putting these things together and not even sure they actually go together. Who would have thought that a single wire controls the Horn, Cruise Control and Air bag? They just replaced the main O2 sensor and the ELD modules. Electronic Load Distribution (?) also. That was a week ago.

Re: Another question for the Car Guys OT

#4

Re: Another question for the Car Guys OT

Scott Banbury

>Sonds like you should contact Honda of America and see if they'll make good on it since it sounds like an orgiginal manufacturing fault, even if not specifically recalled. I'd bet they've heard from some other owners as well and would like to avoid class action.

Re: Another question for the Car Guys OT

#5

Japanese Car Mfg Logic Is Very Simple

Howard In Toronto

>I was in the car leasing business for 13 years.

My reading was very varied - it helped that I was a car nut - my main diet was the dry-as-dust trade magazines....

Most Japanese car manufacturers operate according to a 30-year-old model.

Build the entry-level, cheapest car in the lineup SO BULLETPROOF RELIABLE, that as either financial flexibility increases or the need for more room looms, the positive experiences with the entry-level model should have generated significant long-term loyalty.

Honda is the KING of that logic.

Civics are very cheap to run, cheap to maintain and operate, and above all, very very reliable.

As you move up the economic or social ladder, you'll probably be inclined to replace that works-like-a-watch Civic with an Accord or Pilot or Odessy - all desirable objects as one's lifestyle evolves.

BUT - it's every generation's newest Civic that is built so reliably; it's the other models in Honda's lineup that are dcecidely less-so.

Why the lesson in Japanese management theory?

The CRV is based on the Civic.

But it historically has TONS of bad electricals.

I had clients with TONS of problems.

My wife runs a '98 CRV.

I just had to replace the window swith and motor.

?????????????????????????????????

My wife's vehicle has 90,000KM - roughly 55,000MI.

Unheard of in a Civic unless it's got BIIIG miles.

HTH

Howard

P.S. - this will probably be recieved as heresy but if you total up the total dollars spent on repairs and maintenance over a four-year term with 60,000MI on a General Motors or Ford vehicle vs the pricy maintenance schedule on a similar-class Honda or Toyota vehicle, you will probablyu spend pretty similar dollars.

The difference is perception - the inconvenience of the repairs vs the "training" of owners of Japanese cars to stick with the service schedule where the terchs can find things that would never be called recalls and fix them and simply tell you, "we found so-and-so and replaced it free of charge" leraving you with a nicer feeling re the Japanese cars.

BTW - the US-brand value proposition I theorized about above would never make a difference to me - I've driven Volvos, Honda products and now a KIA these last 32 years and there's no US-brand vbehicle i would want - except for a Vette....

Re: Another question for the Car Guys OT

#6

Re: Another question for the Car Guys OT

Stuart Hough

>Go to Honda's website and key in "TSB" on the search button. This should bring up a box where you can either enter your VIN or your make/model info. Then you'll have to read through the titles until you get to your problem. If I am not mistaken, all Manufacturers must make the Technical Service Bulletins (TSB) available to the consumer. TSBs are generated to educate the service people about problems that arise, so they can be worked on by the service departments before the problem becomes big enough to warrant a recall. When I bought my used Infiniti i30 I researched all the TSBs for it, and found that I needed to have 3 taken care of immediately due to safety concerns. It still cost me some money, due to the fact it was a pre-owned car, but I ended up with a sizeable discount on the parts, because Infiniti new I would look at them first for my next car. Good luck!

Re: Another question for the Car Guys OT

#7

Re: Another question for the Car Guys OT

Doug Reynolds in Seattle

>Barry: Look at the National Highway Safety Administration for official recalls, etc. http://www-odi.nhtsa.dot.gov/cars/problems/recalls/recallsearch.cfm

Re: Another question for the Car Guys OT

#8

Re: Not just Hondas...

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>One of my GMC pickups had a similar problem. $147 for the part, $75 to replace it. That was 6 or 8 years ago, and it hasn't needed it again.

Stuff wears out, and needs replacing. All of the time. It's seldom convenient. Thank goodness its not life threatening now.

Re: Another question for the Car Guys OT

#9

Re: Japanese Car Mfg Logic Is Very Simple

Mark in Michigan

>Interesting there is no foreign vehicle I would want except maybe a Ferrari or Porsche. I do have a Vette, although it is an 89 that shows its age but is still fun to drive. I think the negative perception of US vehicles was deserved 15-25 years ago, and the US automakers are reaping what they sowed, but is not deserved today. I bought a 2002 Yukon brand new and never had to have anything repaired. There was a recall for something on the back seat, but very minor. I now have a 2007 Yukon that has proved equally reliable, and I absolutely love this truck. I admit I am a homer, living in Michigan and all, but there are plenty of US-built vehicles just as reliable and economical as foreigh built.

PS. I have a buddy that had to have the front end of his Honda rebuilt at 35k miles.

Re: Another question for the Car Guys OT

#10

I agree

Dustmaker Mike

>I have had Ford trucks and Chevy trucks and cars for as long as I have been driving. (32 years now) I kept them until they started costing me money like this is broke and that is broke etc. I just got rid of a 1996 Explorer and a 1997 F150 the Explorer had ~300 thousdand miles on it and the F150 only had ~200 thousdand miles (I got rid of it because of no AC). The only things I replaced on either one because it was broke was the idler pully after ~290 thousdand miles. The batterys went dead after ten years I replaced the hoses and belts once on both of them, and then the air filters tires and brakes on a regular schedule (when I remembered they might need to be. A friend with a Honda and another with a Toyota both had problems from the 50 or 60 thousdand mile mark and got rid of their car and truck and went to an American made one. No problems after 100 thousdand miles. I guess in the Old Days like the 60s and 70s this may have had some merit but today I don't see it.

Re: Another question for the Car Guys OT

#11

Get it fixed

Brian in Brighton

>Glenn is incorrect is saying that things wear out. Wiring went bad probably because of bad placement and it created a short after digging thru the wire. For that many miles consider yourself lucky.

My 2000 F150 decided to have lacquer failure at 70K, and 42 months old. Ford told me to take this truck and shove it. Repair estimate to remove box, strip entire cab and repaint $6000. Ford basically did not care and saw that the mileage cause premature paint failure. It will be the last I ever own no matter how good the engine is. Tranny just replaced at 175K. Now I have rust on the roof above the window. It's on the outside, so Ford says........too bad! How about the stress fracture in the drivers door because the window is misaligned? Too bad for me.

My pal has had 3 Cadillacs, 2x STS, 1x CTS. All have had more problems than I can count. Not small. 32K with a head job. 72K for tranny. 96K for another tranny. All kinds of electrical and shock problems (at $800 each) You could not give me one of those pieces of garbage.