Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Saw fence flatness...

Posts

Saw fence flatness...

#1

Saw fence flatness...

Mark Harrison - Brisbane, Australia

>I recently bought a Powermatic PM2000 saw and I now finally have the darn thing setup mostly how I like it. The top was way out of alignment with the arbor to start with and I have reset that correctly. I had to buy a Masterplate to get it right but I'm glad I did. There is still a variance if 1/100 of a mm from one end to another but that is probably close enough to blame the dial guage or the plate. I think it got this way because the top wasn't bolted down tight enough to start with.

Now I have another problem, or perhaps a non-problem. I attempted to align the fence and noticed the dial guage dipping and peaking all over the map. I put the straight edge on it and it was immediately obvious why that was. That's because it does peak and dip all over the map and we're not talking little bits all the time either. So I spent the afternoon in the loosening/packing/tightening cycle on the blasted fence. It's still a long way from perfect.

Am I being too obsessive/compulsive here? Is this par for the course for the plastic fence faces? The fence itself is not that flat either but the majority of the problem is the face.

Maybe I should just make a melamine or plastic laminated plywood face. It couldn't be any worse than what I have.

Re: Saw fence flatness...

#2

Am I being too obsessive/compulsive here? Yes

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Somewhere along the way try making something and if the saw works the saw set up is good enough. If the blade is way out of alignment it can burn, but it would seem that you no longer have that problem. A fence can be miles off and still work fine. My fenece (old sheet metal style) bows in at least 1/32 in the center but I have never had that be a limitation on anything I ever did with the saw.

Re: Saw fence flatness...

#3

Re: Saw fence flatness...

Rich Schneider

>It is interesting how machines vary. I bought a PM 2000 almost 2 years ago now and went through the same initial setup and mine was nearly perfect out of the crate (which was encouraging since I sold two nice older Unisaws I had to buy the PM 2000)....you always have to think about the numbers your dealing with...if your really talking about being out by 1/100th of a millimeter your probably beyond the limit of what you can accurately measure with the dial indicator you have...1/100th of a mm is about 4/10000 ths of an inch.

On another note does your saw's belt squeal a little when you first start the saw?? That's the only concern I've had so far with mine.

Re: Saw fence flatness...

#4

Re: Saw fence flatness...

Barry Irby

>One of the Editors of FWW got a letter about setting up a TS using a steel plate the writer had had milled so that it was flatter than a new saw blade. The writer explained that this way he could set the saw with 2/10000 rather than the usual 1/1000. What did he think? Shouldn't such a plate be mandatory with the saw? The Editor's answer? "It's woodworking."

I wish I had your saw. I will trade you even money. You pay the shipping both ways though.

Mine is a 37 year old Delta/Rockwell Contractors saw with a sheet metal fence. Until recently it never occurred to me that the table and the arbor COULD be out of alignment. The fence is visibly concave. I can tell there are several high and low spots because that's where the paint wore off. I set the fence parallel to the blade by eye. On a good day I fiddle with it until it stops burning the wood.

I'm with Bill on this. Make something. See how it performs. Don't sweat the stuff that is less than 1/100mm. It's not like it's written in stone or even welded in place. If it does not perform well you can go back and tune it some more.

There seems to be two or maybe three types of wood workers. Those that are obsessed about tuning and sharpening their tools and those that ignored as much of that as they can and work on the wood. The third type might be the ones that do both, but they either don't have a full time job supporting their woodworking habit or they are not getting much sleep. It never occurred to me the table of my tools should look shiny and new. Not rusty, but marked with age and use, some patina. I keep reading about tuning up my TS, but I never get around to it. It would be interesting to know if I am missing something. Please don't take offence, go enjoy your saw. Either keep turning it or saw some wood, whichever brings you the most pleasure.

Re: Saw fence flatness...

#5

Re: Saw fence flatness...

Joanne in Pt. Pleasant, PA

>Mark,

I've had a PM 64A Contractor Saw for some years. While it set up pretty smoothly and accurately out of the box, the fence is the least impressive feature, to be kind. Mine has that same wobbly white UHMW junk or whatever that white plastic stuff is. On my "To Do" list is to rip those pieces off and replace with oak or melamine or something flatter. I guess it should be on my "Roundtuit" list, since I never seem to get it done. Let us know what you do.

Re: Saw fence flatness...

#6

Re: Saw fence flatness...

Mark Harrison - Brisbane, Australia

>I don't have the belt squeal on startup. Perhaps it isn't quite tight enough?

1/100 of a mm is what my dial indicator says it can do. Whether that is its real capacity I couldn't say. I'm happy with the alignment of the mitre slot to the arbor. The Masterplate was a great help as I found it really hard to get consistent measurements with a saw blade.

The fence was dipping and peaking about 1/2 a mm which probably isn't much except that I found it hard to get a consistent measurement along the fence to know that it was parallel with the mitre slot. Something I didn't try would be to use the Masterplate against the fence to average out the variance.

I suspect that I am a little OCD about this, which is why I asked :-) I didn't get to do a rip with the fence once I stopped fussing. It was too late and I didn't want to annoy the neighbours any more than they had already put up with today :-)

I'm with Joanne wondering how good this UHMW fence material is. It seems to be too flexible and able to conform too easily to any underlying variations.

Re: Saw fence flatness...

#7

Re: Saw fence flatness...

George (Oxford, NC)

>I too have a PM64A, but mine is the pre-UHMW fence facing. Mine has laminate faced plywood. Every time I look at a new saw in the showrooms and feel the waves on the fence face I have to wonder why the manufacturers switched. Sure it may be slicker but you can deform it just by tightening the mounting screws a quarter turn too much. I much prefer my laminate facing and my suggestion would be to change yours. I have also heard of those that take the UMHW face off and plane it slightly and claim that this has helped.

George

Re: Saw fence flatness...

#8

Re: Saw fence flatness...

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Mark,

Well, it does seem to me that the owner should be satisfied with his purchase. It also seems that people have different expectations. I'd expect your saw to do excellent work as judged by everybody's standards. Plug it in and enjoy that wonderful tool.

George

Re: Saw fence flatness...

#9

Re: Saw fence flatness...

Robert Henderson

>They make UHMW adhesive backed film so you could get the slickness without (too much) compromise on the flatness.

Haven't used it myself, just know it's out there

Re: Saw fence flatness...

#10

Re: Am I being too obsessive/compulsive here? Yes

Tony - Memphis

>I gotta agree here. As a mechanical engineer, it's very rare that I measure much down to 1/100th of a mm. Even when I was in the performance car parts biz, we didn't get down that far very often. An indicator that will measure that is very sensitive and will respond to breathing or pulse (almost). A mm is around 0.040". I would be thrilled if any of my tools measure a tenth of a mm. The Master plate you speak of is only supposed to be with a few thou of an inch anyway. The reference plane you are using is probably not even toleranced to be closer than a few thou to nominal. I wouldn't measure with that fine of resolution. You'd probbaly croak if you started measuring things on my contractor's saw. Heck, the table dips several thou. I can move the fence a few thou just by pushing against it. It makes nice cuts though, and I can't see that it affects my work.

Anyway, the PM200 is on my wish list. Its been real tempting to order one, but the old Delta contractor saw is still kicking, so its hard to justify. Enjoy your new toy!

Tony

Re: Saw fence flatness...

#11

Re: Saw fence flatness...

john lucas

>Mark When I visited Steel City Tools headquarters he showed me a saw they sold that had the UHMW attached to the fence milled to it was perfectly flat. I don't know how important that is since I've been able to do some really nice work with my PM64 with Vega fence. My fence was slightly off 90 degrees to the table and wasn't hard to fix but I really don't know how flat it is.

Re: Saw fence flatness...

#12

nothing but bad experiences on uhmw faces

Ed Snow

>best to get some baltic birch with double formica faces on them.

Re: Saw fence flatness...

#13

Re: Yes - you are way - way to concerned.

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>First, I am a retired manufacturing / quality engineer with almost 40 years experience - purchasing, designing, debugging and working on precision assembly and test equipment for small electromechanical devices. I do have precision mics, calipers, indicators and a granite block in my shop. In most cases they are far to sensitive to use on woodworking equipment setup. With the temperature variation and environment of a wood shop they are not really accurate to .0004" (1/100 of a mm) anyway.

You are measuring (and concerned about) less than 1/2 thousands. I am sure any wood you cut will relax and move more than that when sawn. I have a .001 indicator I use when setting up my saws and tools. I wouldn't be concerned about a couple thousands in anything used to cut, plane or shape wood (except maybe arbor runout). The proof is in the pudding. Cut some wood, look at it and measure it, If the cut is free of burns and tooth marks (provided you are using a Forrest or similar blade), and the width is consistent - I wouldn't touch the saw. I have a Unisaw I purchased new 4 - 5 years ago. I checked the table top with an aluminum straight edge from LV - found it very acceptable. I then installed a new WW2 and using 1 tooth, checked the alignment with my indicator clamped to the stock Uni miter gage, It measured within .001 so I quit. After that I checked the Beis fence with the same indicator setup. I did have to adjust it some. I set it so the trailing edge is a thousands or three farther from the miter gage / blade. I have used it since then without any adjustments and am ecstatic with the performance. You will have far - far more tolerance in the wood, saw blade teeth grind, saw blade warp due to heat, etc than the issues you mention.

Re: Saw fence flatness...

#14

Just to clarify...

Mark Harrison - Brisbane, Australia

>The problem is that I am finding it hard to know if the fence is parallel enough (whatever that means) to the mitre slots. This is because the UHMW fence face has so many peaks and valleys it is hard to know where to measure on the fence.

The confusion (which is my fault) is I mentioned realigning the mitre slot to the saw arbor which I am satisfied with. The Masterplate is highly recommended. This is where I mentioned that I got it within 1/100 of a millimetre from one end of the plate to the other. That's plenty good enough, I would agree, as the difference might be the plate or the dial guage and, as others have said, this is woodworking after all.

I haven't been this obsessive before. It was just irritating to get a new saw and find it was so far out that it would have been potentially dangerous.

My tip for any new cabinet saw buyers is to check the tightness of the four bolts that hold the top to the base before you take it off the pallet. I'm pretty sure that was the major part of the problem in this case.

Re: Saw fence flatness...

#15

Re: Just to clarify...

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I would have serious doubts that it would have been dangerous. I have used some pretty beat up / misaligned saws in my younger days. I have actually clamped a 2 X 4 on one old beater saw for a fence and did fairly well with it. Unless you have the fence end away from you "towed in" toward the blade quite a bit (which could cause kickback, the worst you would see would have been burn or saw tooth marks and inaccurate miters. As to aligning the fence, if you have a flat piece of metal or a board that is flat and true in thickness, I would lay it against the fence and use it to indicate the parallelism to the miter slot. If your miter gage is tight in the slot, you can clamp an indicator to it and/ or use a board or metal rule to hold the indicator to the miter gage and indicate. I like to have the fence parallel to the blade - with the back end towed out just enough to compensate for any measurement errors. (.0008 to .003 or roughly 2 to 8 mm). This seems to work well for me and my rip cuts are quite accurate.

Re: Saw fence flatness...

#16

Re: Just to clarify...

Jim Dillon

>Mark,

To put things into perspective, a sheet of ordinary copy paper is roughly 4 thousands (0.004/0.1mm) of an inch. So, you are seeking precision of another order of magnitude, roughly 1/10 the thickness of that sheet of paper or 4 ten-thousands (0.0004/0.01mm) of an inch. I agree with the more experienced metal-workers and woodworkers that this degree of precision is not necessary for your final use.

Regarding your wavy UHMWPE fence face, I also agree with the other posters that it probably doesn't make a lot of difference for this reason: it is dangerous to slide a narrow (say less than 6in/15cm) board along the fence. So a longer "safer" board will average out the waves/dips you have and work fine. Along that line, I would use the suggestion by Larry to just clamp a nice "flat" board (MDF?) to the fence (to average out the waves/dips) and align your arbor/blade with that.

Having said all this, I guess it would still really bother me that I had paid a lot of good money for a new PM saw and the fence had waves/dips whatever in it - especially when other competitive fences do not. Maybe you got a lemon? Since it is a new saw, how about asking for another fence? I would try that first, before jury-rigging a replacement face (again, not really needed), or even buying a new fence. And maybe it is just a bad design. Just some thoughts.

Jim

Re: Saw fence flatness...

#17

Results are in

Mark Harrison - Brisbane, Australia

>I finally got to actually use the saw today, although only briefly.

I ended placing my Veritas straight edge (the aluminum version) against the fence which was elevated slightly by a block of wood so that I could register the dial guage against the edge. I placed the top of the straight edge against the face of the fence and used the measuring edge to measure from. I don't think these straight edges are guaranteed to have parallel edges but measurement with my Mitutoyo vernier calipers reveals that on this particular straight edge if there was a variance I couldn't measure it. I reckon that's close enough.

The results I had looked good enough so I proceeded to make a cut. The results are pretty good. I can see very faint cuts from the rear of the saw blade. I wouldn't call it a glue edge but one very light pass with a jointer plane would certainly clean it up. But then, I don't think I've ever seen a true glue edge straight off a saw. It's certainly a better result than I've been able to get before with any other saw or setup.

So it seems my OCD setup has paid off :-)

BTW, I am using an Infinity Tools rip blade for the test. This admittedly light test seems to suggest that this blade has a lot going for it. I bought a whole set of blades including the Dadonator set so I will report back when have done some more testing. I will be doing a fair bit of work over the next three weeks as I am having some quality shop time at home building a new work bench.