Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

sharpening system

Posts

sharpening system

#1

sharpening system

Paul R

>ok so I have mastered water stones for sharpening my chisels and plans etc. What system would be best to do my planer blades and jointer blades. Something not too pricy and easy to operate

Any thoughts and or pics of what works for you

PAul

Re: sharpening system

#2

Re: sharpening system

john lucas

>I use the sandpaper on glass method for my Jointer knives. I simply made a jig to hold them out of wood and then slide them back in forth over each grit. I haven't tried my new planer blades yet. They are pretty tiny but I can probably rig up something.

Re: sharpening system

#3

Re: sharpening system

Thomas S Stockton

>It might not be the answer you want but the easiest most cost effective way to sharpen planer and joiner blades is to send them out to a good sharpening service. Getting a straight edge on a chisel or plane blade is easier than trying to get the same on a set of jointer blades especially if they are nicked. go down about 4 messeges to the one about Scott Whiting he has a good reputation or find some one local.

If you just want to touch them up between sharpenings I would just do them freehand on your waterstones this works pretty well and will do when you don't have a spare set around.

Tom

Re: sharpening system

#4

Re: sharpening system

Barry Irby

>Many years ago I bought a Delta grinder and an attachment for it with a sharpening attachment. It has clamp that holds the blade and slides left to right. There is also a screw or knob on it that advances the blade toward the wheel in tiny amounts. I adjust it to match the angle on the chisel or knife and then sharpen.

The left to right travel is way to little for a jointer or planer knife. I clamp a steel ruler in the device and slide the knife along the rule. I do all my knives at the same time so that they are all the same weight. If I get a nick in a knife, I swap them with knives form another set so that the nicks don't match up and I don't have to grind away that much steel. There is a white stone on the grinder that is about 120 grit. I can sharpen two sets of jointer knives (6 @ 6") or planer knives (4 @ 12 1/2") In about an hour including getting the grinder out and fiddling with the setup.

I have one of the older Dewalt planers that has the sharpenable knives. Been sharpening them for years and see no difference in the performance. I just grind them. No water stones, no Scary Sharp, just off the grinder and back on the machine.

I also have a diamond dresser I bought at Woodcraft that has two 1/4" square steel rods with diamond abrasive on them. One is rotated at a forty five to present the corner. I use it to touch up the jointer knives on the jointer.

I think you could do it without the attachment. Try clamping a straightedge on your grinder so that the wheel just touches the blade matching the bevel. Then put a piece of tape down the edge of the blade and grind away the thickness of the tape. It would be better if the straight edge were exactly parallel to the face of the stone and the stone were nicely dressed, but it does not really matter. If you slide the knife past the stone and only a corner is cutting, you get eh same results, just slower. Take tiny light cuts and swap out the knives to keep them and your fingers cool.

Re: sharpening system

#5

Re: sharpening system

Verne in NJ

>I've had a lot of success using the Makita sharpener/grinder. I get a beautiful edge on both my planer blades and jointer blades. I bought the machine for general grinding, and I'm quite happy with it.

However, unless I needed regular planer/jointer blade sharpening I don't think I'd buy a dedicated machine. I tried sharpening my jointer/planer blades only because I already had the machine, and the Makita was designed for that task.

Re: sharpening system

#6

Re: sharpening system

Bill White

>Ditto on the Makita. Simple and works for a bunch of jobs.

Bill

Re: sharpening system

#7

what works best

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Send them out to a competent sharpening shop. Misenheimer in Morristown TN does reliable work. I can not imagine why anyone would want to invest in something to sharpen these things when they need it so seldom. That fact that professional shops send these out should should be an indication that this is not a do it yourself activity.

Re: sharpening system

#8

yabut,

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I understand your point, Bill, but the last time I brought mine to a pro shop (Lietz - they do a very good job) it cost me $50 for a $30 set of blades. This has me re-evaluating my usual priorities.

Bruce

Re: sharpening system

#9

Re: yabut,

Thomas S Stockton

>Ouch. I pay around about $17 to have 2 12" long planer baldes sharpened. Check around for pricing. Scott Whitting mentioned a couple of shops in the post down below.

Tom

Re: sharpening system

#10

Re: sharpening system

Paul R

>When you say Makita are you talking about their wet wheel horz grinder .

http://www.mytoolstore.com/makita/mak08-09.html#9820-2

Sending out my blades to service is not an option too remote an aera where I live. I can do the jointer knives on the glass on sandpaper method but the planer knives are a little too long to do well with this.

Any comments

Paul

Re: sharpening system

#11

Re: sharpening system

Verne in Northeast NJ

>Yes. Another option is Highland Hardware's Makita Package. http://www.highlandwoodworking.com/index.asp?PageAction=VIEWPROD&ProdID=1460

They have a very nice instruction booklet for the Makita Grinder that's available for download - it's under the heading "Additional Information" on the URL above.

Re: sharpening system

#12

Simple answer: farm them out to a local service.

Forrest Addy

>Simple answer: farm them out to a local service. He has an expensive machine designed for sharpening machine knives with a CBN wheel and coolant - and it does a great job.

Yes, you can DIY planer and jointer knives. There are even budget motor driven sharpeners intended for sharpening of machine knives but they don't work all that well. To sharpen three knives to acceptable keenness on dubious equipment so they are parallel and of equal width within 0.003" is too much of a task for me and I've only been a machinist for 45 years.

Ask yourself: "Would I rather spend a full day doing a mediochre job sharpening a set of knives or work wood?"

I send mine out. I have three sets of knives for each machine and when I'm down to the last set I finally stir off my butt and haul them out to the local sharpening service along with a saw blade or three and maybe the dado set. Drop $100 to $150 and I'm done with it for a year or more.

If I pick my time well at the sharpening service I can parlay my visit with about an hour of chit-chat with fellow woodworkers of things and events. Shop talk with the pros is like gold for a retiree.

Re: sharpening system

#13

well said, and data to support the wisdom

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>my recent bill at Misenheimers to sharpen 1 set jointer knives, 4 spiral router bits, and 7 carbide saw blades including some replacement teeth, plus 2 new band saw blades was $108. and that included the chit chat Forest described. The tooling they use to manufacturer these cutters is also used to resharpen so one knows the tolerances are as good after resharpening as they were on a new cutter.

Re: sharpening system

#14

Re: I agree, Forest

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I have an old Boyar Schultz 6 X 12 surface grinder in decent shape. But I wouldn't go to the trouble to make and set up a jig to sharpen joiner or planer blades when my local sharpening service has everything already set up and for $15 - $20 will do a fabulous job with all knives within .001". I am not set up with water coolant, so have to mist my wheel & tools. The SG is real handy for plane blades, chisels, etc. as they are narrow and don't take a lot of setup time. I only have one planer that uses the regular knives now, my stationary 20" has a Byrd head & my 8" joiner (Grizzly) has the Griz carbide segmented head similar to the Byrd.