Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

drum sander for thicknessing figured wood?

Posts

drum sander for thicknessing figured wood?

#1

drum sander for thicknessing figured wood?

Ken Platt

>Folks -

I know the subject of the problems in thicknessing figured wood comes up from time, I've tried all the usual tips, but I'm just getting tired of fighting the wood, and I'm wondering if a small drum sander would be a reasonable answer for me.

Most of these machines are pretty big, though, and I'm not sure the budget for this stretches to the $800 plus range. However, Performax/Jet has a benchtop model for about $500, which at least from appearances seems like a decent machine. I'm not planning on sanding wide panels, so the 10/20" capacity ought to do (I only have an 8" jointer). I know that Jet bought Performax, so I'm guessing that the Performax branded units (they look identical in pictures) are the older ones?

I'd be interested in the experiences of anyone who has this machine, and in hearing about other models of this sort or in this price range. The only other one I've found so far is the ShopFox W1740, which is a closed unit, max width 13", and seems to run in the mid-$600 range, so a bit pricier.

Tips on deals also welcome, as well as info on where you get your sandpaper for these. The pre-packaged rolls seem pretty pricey.

Many thanks from the tear-out zone -

Ken

Re: drum sander for thicknessing figured wood?

#2

Ellis Walentine

Couple things.... *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

>Small drum sanders are fine for putting a final surface on wood that has been thicknessed in a planer or by hand, but they can only remove a small amount of wood at a pass (less than 1/32" in some cases, depending on the width and density of the wood).

Regarding alternatives, you might want to have a look at Steel City's version of the Performax (yes, Jet kept the name) sander. It has greater capacity, faster feed speeds and more power, and it's in the same price range. [Disclaimer: Steel City is a major sponsor of WoodCentral, but that doesn't affect my recommendation that you give them a look.]

Ellis Walentine, Host


Steel City 16-32 Drum Sander

Re: drum sander for thicknessing figured wood?

#3

Re: drum sander for thicknessing figured wood?

Barry Irby

>I have a 16/32 Performax built in 1994 (Pre Jet) I bought used for $400. These machines seem to get the Love/Hate reaction from people. I like mine. Others will tell you they are the scourge of the Earth. I think I had very low or perhaps realistic expectations and I have not been disappointed. It does everything I thought it would and actually does it pretty well.

If your dream is to grind recalcitrant wood into submission quickly, forget it. There is nothing quick, fast, speedy or aggressive about this machine. OTOH, I tried to plane a piece of curly walnut root in my Dewalt lunchbox planer and it just demolished it and spit it out. (Really noisy and exciting). The Performax Sanded them all to the same thickness with a 36 grit belt and then sanded them down to 220. Sort of the Zen of sanding. Feed piece after piece time after time and try not to run your head through the machine out of boredom.

I have sanded many things that would have defied my planer. Including sanding panels where half the parts were cross grain. I have sawed veneer on my bandsaw (Don't get me going on that Child of unwed alien parents from some subhuman planet) and sanded it in the Performax. (I use double stick tape to stick the leading edge to a piece of melamine and have sanded veneer to 2/100 of an inch for lamp shades.)

I have a friend about forty miles away with one of the big wide belt sanders (Time Saver?). It was about $12,000 years ago I think. The Performax is not 10% the machine that is, but I sure love not having to make the drive to his shop. As a hobbyist, the Perfomax works for me.

I am still buying "factory" sand paper and have started cleaning it with Simple Green or vinegar. Very worthwhile.

Re: drum sander for thicknessing figured wood?

#4

Re: Couple things....

Ken Platt

>Thanks for the reply, Ellis. Actually, 1/32nd on a pass sounds pretty good. I've been trying to lower the head on my DeWalt planer about 1/8 turn for each pass, which if the dial is correct is 1/128th inch. And I'm still getting chunks yanked out.

The Steel City looks like a nice machine, but I don't think I can stretch to the $900 range for this sort of a semi-optional tool. The smaller Jet/performax at around $500, I can, I think, sell that to, um, well, you know.

Otherwise, I may need to look upon this as a chance to hone my hand planing skills.

Ken

Re: drum sander for thicknessing figured wood?

#5

Re: drum sander for thicknessing figured wood?

Robert R Clough - Thorncraft

>Now I've got to add my 2 cents, Ken. I have a Performax 16/32 which I use to "plane" wood. Now, I don't start at 4/4 rough expecting to get to 3/4, although I did do that - once - using 36 grit!!! Interesting - the wood looked as if it had been scraped by glaciers. I do take 3/4 to 1/2 and 1/2 to 1/4 and 1/4 to 1/8. Yes, it takes a fair amount of time but I have that, not the planer or money.

Generally I start with 80 g and then go to 100g, 120g and maybe, maybe 150g, the closer I get to the finished size. I am talking Maple, Cherry, Oak including some figured stock. The amount of stock I take off each pass is 1/64". I measure carefully and continually as I near the finish. Depending upon the dimension and amount of stock, this can take up to 4 hrs, but the wood is dimensioned to what I want. Then I can plane, scrape, sand, etc.

I hope this is of use.

Re: drum sander for thicknessing figured wood?

#6

Re: drum sander for thicknessing figured wood?

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>Ken,

I have the Performax 22-44, and love it, but like Barry, I had low expectations of it, too. It's not meant for thicknessing anything, and it is a very slow machine. Suprisingly, the sandpaper lasts a long time if you follow certain rules. Keep it clean- I simply use the crepe rubber cleaning blocks on mine. Secondly, clean any visible glue off a glued joint, as this will burn into the sandpaper and in return, into the work piece.

Just for giggles, I started sanding a 1/2" thick X 4" wide X 8" long piece of red oak just to see how long it would take, and to check the head setting in relation to the bed. Accuracy was spot on, and it took a little over an hr to sand that piece until it was only about the same thickness as a piece of poster board (1/64ths?) Of coarse, wider the panel, the longer it will take.

Ron in Iowa

Re: drum sander for thicknessing figured wood?

#7

Forgot to mention----

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>I was using 80 grit sandpaper- Your mileage may vary!

Ron in Iowa

Re: drum sander for thicknessing figured wood?

#8

You should consider a Shelix head.

John K in Hastings, MN

>The shearing action of these is much kinder to figured wood than regular planer blades. You can also try putting a back bevel on your blades.

But, if you plan to do a lot of this, think about one of the smaller wide belt sanders- less heating and clogging of paper if you're trying to take a lot off. They are available in as small as a 10/20.

Re: drum sander for thicknessing figured wood?

#9

Re: drum sander for thicknessing figured wood?

MikeW

>Hi Ken, I have and use the 10-20 everyday. I will eventually get a larger one again (had a dual drum once). If you can live with the mentioned limitations, they work as advertised.

Take care, Mike

Re: drum sander for thicknessing figured wood?

#10

Ellis Walentine

Optimistic stock removal

Ellis Walentine

>You're right, of course. At a 1/32" deep pass, your sander will probably slow to a crawl if not crap out entirely, or at least burn. We used to have an ancient 24" dual drum sander that weighed about 1500# and had twin 5HP motors for the two drums. 1/32 is about all it would handle comfortably.

If you save your pennies (maybe your C-notes, too), you can get an entry level wide belt thicknessing sander eventually. They have significantly better stock removal capabilities.

Meanwhile, by all means let your budget and your needs be your guide.

Ellis

Re: drum sander for thicknessing figured wood?

#11

Sandpaper source?

Ken Platt

>I hope i like it also, Mike. Since I ordered the 10-20 this afternoon, I guess I'm gonna need some sandpaper. Could you share your source? Do you get pre-cut, or cut your own? Thanks -

Ken

Re: drum sander for thicknessing figured wood?

#12

Re: Sandpaper source?

MikeW

>Sorry for getting back to this so slowly, Ken.

I usually hide over on the hand tool side of WC and had forgotten I posted over here.

I simply buy the pre-cut strips from Rockler or Woodcraft. Depending on your particular Rockler or Woodcraft, if you are part of a woodworking guild they may give you a 10% discount--mine does.

Keeping them clean makes them last, at least at the lower grits. I rarely have ever used above 100 grit, mostly 80.

Take care, Mike