Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Thinking of a new notebook in a couple months....

Posts

Thinking of a new notebook in a couple months....

#1

Thinking of a new notebook in a couple months....

John in New Mexico

>Does anyone have experience with IBM's? I haven't been too happy with my HP, specifically the screen is having trouble at the hinge. Looking for a really durable one this time.

John

Re: Thinking of a new notebook in a couple months....

#2

Forgot the OT! (Dang it!)

John in New Mexico

>

Re: Thinking of a new notebook in a couple months....

#3

Re: Thinking of a new notebook in a couple months.

Chicago Bob

>John

I believe that all IBM labeled computers are now made in China by a Chinese owned company. Apparently IBM has exited from the PC hardware manufacturing business.

Having been a manufacturing & quality consultant (road warrior) in past lives, I have "owned" a number of laptops and desktop PC's. My best experience has been consistently with Dell PC's. I would rate my brand experience on reliability as follows:

B+ Dell (both laptop & desktop)

C HP (lap & desk), Toshiba (sp?), NEC, Apple, Sony (Lap & Desk)

D DEC, Gateway (BIOS problems), IBM Desktop

D- IBM Thinkpad (software & hardware issues)

F e SYSTEMS

I have yet to find a PC I would rate an "A", ie, good customer service and extremely robust HW.

With that said, I have used the same Dell Inspiron laptop for 6 years with only very minor issues. Last week I decided to replace it with a new Dell laptop because of the need for a faster multitaking processor. The old Dell laptop still works and is being moved to my woodshop for internet and causal CAD use. I have heard some very negative reports about the quality of Dell's customer support but have never had the need to use it since everything has always worked without any major issues.

Now appears to be a good time to buy any major brand because of back to school specials. My daughter is a MAC user but it seems that she is frequently having some type of hardware or software problem. I think she also "tinkers" with it a lot, which is probably the major source of her problems. My wife has an HP laptop and has a few "strange" software issues but the HW has reasonable reliability.

I would go to a Best Buy, Fry's, or CompUSA and test drive a number of systems before making an informed decission' A number of major malls also have small Dell booths/displays for test drives.

Good luck. By the way, I don't work for any of the computer companies these days and my recommendations are based on my highly biased and informed opinion.

Bob

Re: Thinking of a new notebook in a couple months....

#4

Re: Thinking of a new notebook in a couple months.

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

>John, my experience has been very positive over the last ten years with IBM Thinkpads. The present one is two years old and I have never had to call for service. With their three year warranties service has been outstanding as far as speed is concerned. With the sale of the Thinkpad line to Lenova I just don't have any personal experience to say what that has done to quality and service. However, if I was in the market today it would be another Thinkpad.

Howard

Re: Thinking of a new notebook in a couple months....

#5

I should also mention...

John in New Mexico

>That software is not an issue as I intend to either buy one with a blank hard drive or wipe it and install linux. If I do dual boot like on my current machine, it always seems to end up in Windows so Jean can play spider solitaire :)

John

Re: Thinking of a new notebook in a couple months....

#6

Re: Thinking of a new notebook in a couple months. *LINK*

Don Pierson

>I have had two Thinkpad over the last 10+ years and I am very happy with them, my new computer is a Gateway desktop. I looked at the Lenovo thinkpad and they didn't have all of the features I wanted. Here is a link to an article you might be interested in...


Thinkpad/Linux

Re: Thinking of a new notebook in a couple months....

#7

Re: I think I read...

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>that Lenovo is or will be soon offering their machines with Linux preinstalled. If you don't wish to RUN Windows, then you shouldn't have to PAY THEIR FEES. Sorry for the political commentary.

I've used, or my sons have used, Thinkpads since the early 90's. They've always worked at least as well as anything else around. My current employer has supplied me with a Dell laptop. It's not something on which I would spend my own cash, but it works, sorta.

Re: Thinking of a new notebook in a couple months....

#8

Ellis Walentine

A couple more bits of info

Ellis Walentine

>I recently had a less than sterling interaction with Dell customer support in regard to a malfunctioning Ethernet port. Essentially the operation was a success (by their reckoning) in that all their fancy online diagnostics and a trip to the repair contractor failed to turn up a problem, but the patient died (IMO) because the computer is still broken and I'm out $210 with no chance of a refund. I wasn't about to spring another $400 for a new motherboard just because that was the last thing they could think of. So I will continue using it without a functioning Ethernet port (the wireless port still works).

Other than that, I have been watching my son shop for a laptop and he got a super deal (~$1700) on a top of the line HP recently and he loves it. It has twice the hard drive space of the top Dell model, a 2.2GHz Cord2Duo processor (vs 1.6 for the Dell) 7200rpm drives (two of 'em) vs one 5600rpm drive for the Dell, more pixels, a higher resolution screen and a far superior video card -- all for only $100 more than the comparable Dell. Time will tell how it holds up.

The computers that have the highest scores for durability are the Panasonic Toughbooks. I've never even seen one, but they have waterproof keyboards and shockproof cases. Pretty pricey, though.

Good luck. Whatever you buy, something better and cheaper will come along in six months if not sooner.

Ellis

Re: Thinking of a new notebook in a couple months....

#9

Ellis, if you have a pcmcia port

Joanne Adler in Pt. Pleasant, PA

>in your laptop, for less than $50 you can get a pc card ethernet card for your laptop.

Re: Thinking of a new notebook in a couple months....

#10

Spider solitaire in Linux

wilbur

>Hi John,

TkGames is a Linux program that has Spider solitaire, as well as some other versions of solitaire, Yahtzee, Hangman, Connect 4, and others. (http://tkgames.sourceforge.net/)

If you like KDE, I think that KDEGames has a Spider solitaire game included.

If you're a Gnome user, Aisleriot, which is part of Gnome Games, has Spider as one of the 80 version of solitaire included. (http://live.gnome.org/Aisleriot)

Re: Thinking of a new notebook in a couple months....

#11

Re: Ellis, if you have a pcmcia port

Dave Arbuckle, Plano, TX

>USB<->Ethernet is also available, around $20. Maybe not as fast as the PC card?

Re: Thinking of a new notebook in a couple months....

#12

theres one program that has a ton of them....

John in New Mexico

>Not being a huge fan of the game, I'm a bit at a loss to tell the difference between all of them, but I'm told none of them are just like the windows one that allows you to choose how many suits to play with.

John

Re: Thinking of a new notebook in a couple months....

#13

A couple of mine will run network on usb too...

John in New Mexico

>Just need a port on the router. Windows XP seems ok with it as do two of my linux systems, but I have had others that won't do it.

Re: Thinking of a new notebook in a couple months....

#14

Thanks for all the input so far...

John in New Mexico

>I've got a couple new ideas to look into.

John

Re: Thinking of a new notebook in a couple months....

#15

Ellis Walentine

Yes I do, Joanne

Ellis Walentine

>... and I may have to get one of those cards, or a USB adapter as someone else suggested.

Thanks for your help.

Ellis

Re: Thinking of a new notebook in a couple months....

#16

Re: Thinking of a new notebook in a couple months.

Miles

>I have been looking for a Linux-friendly laptop too, and if you have the budget it seems that the Thinkpads are still amongst the best machines around, and they have a pretty good range of info available from various wikis and WC-like communities (thinkpads forum).

I am going to buy a secondhand R50p, about 3 years old now. Not the latest CPU, but will be plenty for me, and has a nice screen and is a robust design. Much cheaper than any of the current offerings - though a new T60p would be nice to have....

The Dell D820 is also a pretty nice machine. I don't know if the screen is as good as the Thinkpad, though.

I don't think you can pay $500 for a new, retail laptop and expect to get anything like high quality - it just doesn't stack up.

have fun looking - online forums are the best bet for getting informed answers, especially if you are going for Linux (good for you!)

best

Miles