Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

gorilla glue

Posts

gorilla glue

#1

gorilla glue

alex

>Hi,

I would like your opinion abouut polyurethane glue. Is it strong and enough durable for hardwood lamination, as epoxy?

Thanks.

Alex

Re: gorilla glue

#2

Re: gorilla glue

Scott S.

>I have used it for making the rockers on a rocking chair that I made. It is made out of oak. Yeah I thought that it worked pretty good for it. No bounce back when I took it off of the jig. I used PLENTY of the glue though. IT IS VERY MESSY. Have not used the stuff since. Don't get any on your hands either.

My brother made a chest and used the glue for it. Not happy at all. The whole thing is coming apart. Guess it is up to you.. I would say go for it.

Re: gorilla glue

#3

Re: gorilla glue

Barry Irby

>I built a rose arbor that had eight redwood bent lamination's. Used Gorilla glue. Worked fine, but it is very messy and you have to be ready for it. Get your preparation done and be ready. I wet one side of each lamination. The foaming starts quickly. If you are not ready and don't get the clamps on quickly enough, the foaming actions tends to interfere with clamping.

I would suggest you make a practice run first. Not for the slow and methodical or faint of heart.

Epoxy is probably easier if you use the slow setting type to give you plenty of open time. They both need to set over night at least.

I think it is not possible to use either one without getting glue all over you. Your hands end up looking like the one on the Gorilla Glue bottle.

I would investigate type 111 Titebond.

Re: gorilla glue

#4

Re: gorilla glue

alex

>Hi,

So you do not recommend polyurethane because it's foaming. I should go with my G-2 Epoxy. I want just a strong bond that will last.

Thank.

Alex

Re: gorilla glue

#5

JL

Re: gorilla glue

JL

>FWW did a "test" on the various types of glues an issue or two ago. The polyurethane glue came out as about the poorest performer.

I'd try one of the Titebond glues such as Titebond III.

Re: gorilla glue

#6

Re: gorilla glue

Mike Circ

>Poly glues get a bad rap a lot and I don't know why. I suspect folks just aren't using it properly. I've used it a lot for occasions when I need a lot of open time. NEVER had an issue even in critial joints and after several years of use. That included a bent lamination for a demilune table in cherry which has a fairly tight radius.

First dampen one surface and spread the glue on the other. Key here is "damp" not sopping wet.

Second spread a thin uniform layer. You need less poly glue than with yellow types. Lines of glue are useless, you want a even paint-like coat.

Clamp as normal, good clamp pressure is key. Don't believe the gap filling properties. If the wood is not in good contact and clamped you will get grip only with the foamed out portion and that has almost no strength.

IMMEDIATELY clean off the glue with mineral spirits from anywhere you don't want it. Hands, benches and wood surfaces. Mineral spirits takes off the uncured and unfoamed glue just fine. It leaves NO residue that will effect finishes. (I like that). Again I don't get these "black fingers" comments, never had that issue as long as I clean up.

If you have the time, revisit the glueup after 10 or 15 minutes. You can clean off the first appearance of squeeze out with mineral spirits also. But once it really foams up, just leave it alone. The foam will make a crusty clump on top of the wood and can be cleanly and easily removed with a chisel or scraper. The tiny portions remaining after that work will be easily sanded off. And again, no effect on finish.

Do I use it for everything? no. But when I need the long open time it is my go-to glue. For the lamination, it also is slippery when wet so it helps facilitate the sliding of the layers when bending over the form.

Just my contrary experience

Mike

Re: gorilla glue

#7

Re: gorilla glue

Howard Acheson

>The best adhesive for bent laminations is urea formaldehyde. There are a number of brands but the easiest to find is DAP/Weldwood Plastic Resin. Here is one source: www.jamestowndistributors.com/userportal/show_product.do?pid=2432&familyName=Weldwood+Plastic+Resin+Glue

UF adhesives are what most commercial shops use for laminations. It has the best shear strength characteristics meaning the laminations won't slip past each other as happens with some other adhesives.

A reason not to use a poly glue is that as it sets and cures, it exerts pressure tending to force the surfaces apart. It must be very securely clamped to get a tight and strong joint.

Re: gorilla glue

#8

Re: gorilla glue

JKJ in East TN

>>Poly glues get a bad rap a lot and I don't know why.

>I suspect folks just aren't using it properly.

The FWW article described a test between the various glues with what appeared to be a careful consistency in material and process. This glue was the worst "performer" as rated by the strength of the bond. Did it hold two pieces of wood together? Yes. Did it hold as well as other types of glue? No.

JKJ

Re: gorilla glue

#9

Agree with Mike & Howard

Joe Burke

>Maybe that's playing both sides of the fence, but, I do agree with both of them.

I've had good luck with Gorilla glue used in certain situations. I had some problems with FWW's test, but we'll save that for another time. I find a very thin layer of glue works best. I typically spead it with a credit card, and I'll squeegee the vast majority off leaving just a glossy surface. I've used it with bent lams with success. I'd have to say that I'd trust it most with gentle curves as opposed to tight curves under a lot of stress.

It's very slick so things will slide past each other easily. Of course, that means they'll slide around also, so you'd have to plan for that.

Living in the humid south, I never wet anything when using G glue. It just foams more then. 9% MC, which is equillibrium for me, seems to be plenty of moisture.

I'll make a confession ..... I've used to press veneer. You can leave a very, very thin layer on the substrate and it'll press very well. No excessive bleed through and what does can be dealt with.

Now, having said all that, I just finished some bent lams this morning laid up with UF glue and that's the way to go. I used the powdered form mixed with water. It mixes well, has a long open time, isn't as slick as poly, and I had zero spring back on some very tight bends. Rock solid. I'll use UF from now on for bigger jobs, but if it's a small, one time shot, I wouldn't hesitate to use poly glue.

Re: gorilla glue

#10

Re: Agree with Mike & Howard

alex

>Hi,

The thing is I need something good for laminated Exotic wood like Purpleheart or Jatoba. Does epoxy should be better or I go with Poly?

Than you again to help me !

Alex

Re: gorilla glue

#11

Re: gorilla glue

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>I've used a fair bit of polyurethane glue, both Gorilla and other brands and was quite impressed by it. I followed the instructions well and am completely confident that my glue joints were prepared and clamped as they should have been.

Fast forward to now where I've had a few come-backs and every one of them has been a polyurethane glue failure. Now - did I do something wrong? Perhaps, but I doubt it. And even if I did do something wrong I followed basic shop practices and standards under which the glue should have performed. I know any decent alphatic resin type glue would have performed under those conditions.

I've since removed all polyurethane glue from my shop and consider it a failed experiment. Titebond, Elmers, Lee Valley and various other companies make decent adhesives and if you want to get into longer open times it's not a stretch to venture into the world of epoxies and plastic resins (Weldbond etc.) - all of which have proven methods and track records in harsh conditions.

Some may have luck with Gorilla glue and some of my projects that I used it on are still doing just fine. But I want a product I can trust and rely on, and polyurethane glue has proven it's not it.

I'd strongly suggest finding another way - risking your project isn't worth it.

Rob

Re: gorilla glue

#12

Re: Agree with Mike & Howard

Howard Acheson

>Poly adhesives are not a good choice with many exotic woods particularly those that contain a lot of natural oil. Check the Gorilla Glue site for it's use on various woods.

Re: gorilla glue

#13

Re: Agree with Mike & Howard

Joe Burke

>If you have questions along those lines .... tropicals ..... I'd stick with epoxy. There's no question that that will work.

Re: gorilla glue

#14

Re: gorilla glue

Joe Burke

>I'm curious as to the type of joint you had fail. Any edge to edge joints or laminations?

I admit to having changed my practices in the last 6 months. I haven't had any returns, but I don't want any either. I'm selective about where I use it to be sure.

Re: gorilla glue

#15

Re: gorilla glue

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>They were edge-to-edge joints, no laminations.

I tried to find a common denominator in my process or selection of materials, but was unable. The wood was benign for the most part (maple, birch etc.) and the applications were pretty stress free. Further, the joints never failed catastrophically - they just seemed to let go with resultant gaps showing - I assume caused by wood movement.

Don't get me wrong - these were not edge joints that had been mechanically constrained in any way - at all. All the wood was completely free to come and go (think cutting boards) as needed.

I'm sure there's a perfectly good reason for the failures and maybe the finger should be pointed squarely at me - but I don't think I should be expected to change a time honoured process (glue-ups) to accommodate a product that's proven to be inferior when the old stand-by's (alphatic resins etc.) make me look like a hero with the process I use.

There's no net gain for me using polyurethane glue - and so far it's been a net loss. When something doesn't work - I tend to stop doing it.

Rob

Re: gorilla glue

#16

Re: gorilla glue

Barry Irby

>I had some Gorilla Glue left over from a bent wood project and decided to use it up. Made myself a mail box post. Resawed some treated wood into about 1/4 thick pieces and glued up a 90 degree bend. About a 16" radius. Put a sort of T&G on the ends and added some straight 2X4. Laminated a 1/4 "skin" over both sides. So I have a 2" thick 3 1/2" wide "timber" with a ninety in it. I have been watching it weather. One of the outer lamination is slowly coming off. the glue seems to be foaming and filling the gap even after a couple of years. Maybe I should not have used treated wood. Maybe I should have painted it. Maybe I should take pictures and look at it more closely. HMMM.