Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

FWW Bandsaw Test Questions

Posts

FWW Bandsaw Test Questions

#1

FWW Bandsaw Test Questions

Barry Irby

>I just scanned the 14" Bandsaw test in FWW. The author used a sled with weights to pull the test piece through the saws to "more scientifically" judge there resawing characteristics. (I was routing for the Delta since I have one.) Some of the saws cut the test block in less than a minute and the Delta took more than 5 minutes. Same blade, approximately equal horse power. Delta's alignment was "perfect" out of the box, others not so good. Also, the quality of the cut on the Delta rated lower. I have said many times I have a love hate relationship with my saw and I agree the blade couldn't be a lot harder to change, but I did not think it could be this bad.

OK, so what gives. Brand preference aside, how can this be? Given about the same HP, similar alignment, same blade, etc, why would one take five times longer and produce worse results? What other factors are at work (or not).

Re: FWW Bandsaw Test Questions

#2

Re: FWW Bandsaw Test Questions

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>What other factors are at work (or not).

Barry,

Two factors jumped out at me as I read the time of cut results:

1. Blade speed. Would have been a simple calculation that should have been shown in the chart and, recalling a similar test from a while back (Wood magazine?), makes a huge difference in cutting time.

2. Table finish. The test sled (or so it appears in the photograph) rides directly on the saw's table. Friction between the sled base and the table was not, apparently, taken into account.

Al

Re: FWW Bandsaw Test Questions

#3

Re: FWW Bandsaw Test Questions

Phil Thien

>Also, the density/grain of the wood that was being cut.

I think the test would be more scientific had he averaged five or ten cuts.

Re: FWW Bandsaw Test Questions

#4

Re: FWW Bandsaw Test Questions

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>For those not subscribing to FWW, could you give us more details on the test procedure? Five minutes to cut anything on any bandsaw tells me something is seriously wrong...

Thnx,

DC

Re: FWW Bandsaw Test Questions

#5

More Information

Barry Irby

>The article says he used a sled to resaw a hard maple blank 12" long and 10" wide and that he took off a 1/2" and an 1/8" piece. the sled mounts on the saw and has a weight that hangs down to pull the blank through the blade. He used a 5 lb. and 7 1/2 lb. weight.

The General, Grizzly GO475, and Laguna saws did well @ 57 sec, 59 and 60 sec respectively. The Jet also posted 57 seconds. The other saws in the tes all posted about 3 minutes, but the Delta posted 5 min and 36 seconds. This is with the five pound weight and a 1/2 3 tpi blade. The General and the Laguna posted "excellent" quality and the grizzly got a good rating on the cut. The Delta got a poor.

The 7 1/2 lb weight reduced the time about fifty percent across the board, but the Jet stalled. With a 10 pound weight they all stalled except the Rikon. Interestign that adding fifty percent to the weight more than doubled the speed of the cuts.

The sled appears to ride on two drawer slides and does not appear to rub on the table.

I have no way of knowing what the blade speeds of the various saws are and as far as I can tell it's not referenced in the article.

He Gives the Laguna a "Best Overall" and the Griz a "Best Value". The Laguna has a price of $1500 and the Griz is $795.

Still trying to figure out what makes some saws three times faster than most of the others and six time faster than the Delta.

Looking back, I may not have bought a Delta, but I paid about $600 for it and have added about $250 in upgrades. If I had had to come up with $1200 to $1500 for the saw at the time, I might not have ever gotten a bandsaw, even if it were a better saw.

Re: FWW Bandsaw Test Questions

#6

Re: FWW Bandsaw Test Questions

Falberg Saw Co

>You've obviously never worked with 18" Doug Fir timbers.

Re: FWW Bandsaw Test Questions

#7

Re: More Information

Falberg Saw Co

>There's an optimal feed rate for every cutting solution based on motor HP, pulley ratio, and material resistance (hardness, thickness, wetness, etc.) Without information on these specifics, it's impossible to compare machines. Here we are again: arguing which is better; apples or oranges. Cutting solutions are a complex task involving ALL of the above and you can add operator proficiency to the mix also. It's all painfully apparent when cutting big timber with my hand-held portable and you're listening carefully for the point where the motor is just starting to bog down and you have to back off the feed rate ever so slightly. Yes, you'd really like to put a 2 HP motor on it right then (and some have) but do you want to pick up and carry a 100 lb. saw . I'm working on a floor standing re-saw now and it definitely will have the HP to feed a 3/4" blade. Put another way: you can make big cuts on a small saw but it won't be as FAST as big cuts on a big (HP-wise) saw. As with blade choices; you have to weigh competing parameters and find the balance that suits your WW requirements to your budget. You get what you pay for; sometimes.

Re: FWW Bandsaw Test Questions

#8

Re: FWW Bandsaw Test Questions

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>True, but you can't cut those on a 14" bandsaw anyway...

DC

Re: FWW Bandsaw Test Questions

#9

Re: Drawer slides

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>Barry,

After you mentioned the drawer slides I took another look at the test setup. It appears that you are correct about the slides being used and that the table finish is not part of the equation. My oversight.

Al

Re: FWW Bandsaw Test Questions

#10

Seems to me...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>...that they had a bum blade on the Delta. Not having read the review I can't confirm this, but that seems the most likely cause.

Just for the heck of it, I went in the shop and resawed a piece of hard maple that is a hair under 10" wide but over 15" long with my souped-up Delta (3 HP, blade speed up to 3930 FPM). Without the weight and slide setup, just feeding the piece as the saw swallowed it (certainly less than 5 lb. pressure), I did the cut in 45 seconds. That's with a 1/2" Woodslicer with mileage on it, and no tuneup (I actually had to correct the fence for drift on the fly). The cut is excellent, no visible saw marks (once the drift was corrected for). And the motor was cool after the cut.

Looks like I won't be on the market for a new saw anytime soon...

DC

Re: FWW Bandsaw Test Questions

#11

Re: I thought I read ...

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>".that they had a bum blade on the Delta. Not having read the review I can't confirm this, but that seems the most likely cause."

Thought I read that they were using 'the same blade' in all of their tests. I took that to mean that they had blades made up for all the saws from the same base stock.

Then, you know what we say about making assumptions...

Re: FWW Bandsaw Test Questions

#12

Re: FWW Bandsaw Test Questions

Kelly Anderson

>There is a video on the FWW web site and he talks about the sled and shows it in use.