Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Trex Deck Screw questions (OT?)

Posts

Trex Deck Screw questions (OT?)

#1

Trex Deck Screw questions (OT?)

Barry Irby

>Some friends installed Trex (I think it was Trex) deck. I warned them to get the right screws. Told them the screws had to be suitable for treated wood (the joists) and the decking. They bought the screws from a Borg and they were marked "suitable for ACQ". Nothing about being rated for Trex. Every one of them made a mushroom or whatever you call it around the screw head. Sort of a big ugly donut of fibrous material sitting around the screws. UGLY. They seem to think these eruptions will "wear off". (?)

My question is, don't they make special screws for Trex or composite deck that don't do this? So they work well? Do you have to drill and countersink the holes first?

Re: Trex Deck Screw questions (OT?)

#2

Re: Trex Deck Screw questions (OT?)

Jason Roehl in Mulberry, IN

>Barry, I've seen screws in my McFeely's catalogs that are supposed to be appropriate for what you just described. As near as I can tell from the pictures, the head of the screw has a recess on the bottom of the shoulder so that the outside edge cuts into the Trex and the "mushroom" ends up under the head. One option for your neighbor that will improve the look slightly would be to take a hammer to all their little volcanoes to flatten them out. Then it almost looks like the screws are hidden.

Jason

Re: Trex Deck Screw questions (OT?)

#3

Yes, yes, and no

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>

Re: Trex Deck Screw questions (OT?)

#4

Re: Trex Deck Screw questions (OT?)

Chuck Lenz

>You are corrrect Barry, there is a screw made for Trex that pulls the mushroom back into the surface. The screw has a regular wood screw thread up to about the last inch close to the screw head. That last inch has machine screw threads that pull the material back down before the screw seats. They work very well.


img

Re: Trex Deck Screw questions (OT?)

#5

Re: Trex Deck Screw questions (OT?)

Jay St. Peter - Southern, MD

>I used the McFeelys stainless screws that are for composite decking. They have a different thread near the head that is supposed to suck the mushroom back down as the head comes down. They work, but it takes a lot of torque to drive them. I had quite a few cam out, even with the square drive. I had a pretty hard time driving them enough that the head was below the decking surface. So, I wound up drilling and countersinking them anyway. Could've saved a lot of time and money by just using standard SS deck screws, which I found I just had to countersink since they didn't have that odd threading near the head that caused the extra effort. I wasn't too happy after driving nearly 1000 of those things.

Jay

Re: Trex Deck Screw questions (OT?)

#6

Re: Trex Deck Screw questions (OT?)

Chuck Lenz

>They worked just fine for me Jay. I used square drive that I bought at Menards.

Re: Trex Deck Screw questions (OT?)

#7

Re: Trex Deck Screw questions (OT?)

Bill Howatt

>I used SS trim-head screws and than hammered the "mushroom" down. When dry it looks like no fasteners but the bumps become more obvious when deck is wet. Where I was able (deck higher off ground)I used metal strips for fastening underneath.

Camming out was a bit of a problem with the trim-head screws and near the end I started drilling some pilot holes but not countersinking since I wanted to do the mushroom/hammer trick.

Bill

Re: Trex Deck Screw questions (OT?)

#8

Re: Trex Deck Screw questions (OT?)

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot Idaho

>Hi Barry!

We used the screws that Chuck showed in his post. We put down well over 1000 sq/ft of Trex decking, and they worked well. We did not pre-drill, but we did use impact drivers (Makita). As the impact driver drove the screw in, you could see the excess material being drawn back in to the hole, to eliminate the mushroom effect. They are square drive, and I had no problem camming out with the impact drivers, although I did snap a head off every now and again. I highly recommend these screws!

As for your friends with the mushrooms, they can hammer them flat, and it will help.

Scott.

Re: Trex Deck Screw questions (OT?)

#9

Re: Trex Deck Screw ( Hi Scott )

Chuck Lenz

>Former resident of Idaho Falls, I sure miss the mountains.

Re: Trex Deck Screw questions (OT?)

#10

Re: Trex Deck Screw questions (OT?)

Kevin French, Antrim, NH

>We looked at Lowe's. They had a screw that had a cutter under the head. Their display look very smooth.

Re: Trex Deck Screw questions (OT?)

#11

Re: The right tool for the job ...

Jay St. Peter - Southern, MD

>The right driver probably helps a lot. When I drove the screws with my cordless (12V Festool), it worked pretty well. But, the final push took a lot out of it and each charged battery would only drive about 15 screws. So, I used a 110V Makita drywall gun. I think it drove the screws waaay to fast. Stainless cams out easier than non. By the time I'd catch the slip it was too late. I clearly don't have the best tool for deck installation (which is fine because I won't have to do that again for a long time).

I was pretty anal about making sure the head was below the deck surface. My deck is full sun and my kids and I regularly walk around barefoot. On the deck at our old house, the nail heads would burn our feet. No matter what tool I used, I had trouble ensuring a good consistent countersink without predrilling at least the countersink. I can see an impact driver being better able to deal with that final push and get the thing countersunk.

In reality, I only had problems with maybe 1 of every 15 screws. But, when you cam it out just before countersink it takes a ton of effort to extract it. When you're talking close to 1000 screws, it's a lot of hassle. So, after the 10th time it happened, I predrilled the rest.

Jay