Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

OT Plumbing

Posts

OT Plumbing

#1

OT Plumbing

Howard

>The vertical main drain line in my friend�s townhouse does not run all the way to the roof. It stops just above the top bathroom and is open into the space between the walls.

He checked the adjacent houses and saw that they had vent stacks coming thru their roofs. The house had been renovated a few years before he purchased it and I guess that the contractor wanted to save a couple of bucks.

Does anyone see a problem with this set up?

Thanks

Howard

Re: OT Plumbing

#2

Re: OT Plumbing

Kneale Brownson in sunny N. MI

>Doesn't meet codes anywhere I'm familiar with, can be a source for deterioration of the roof and its supporting lumber and potentially can poison the air in the living area.

Re: OT Plumbing

#3

Re: OT: Plumbing vent piping

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>Howard,

Vent pipes are (normally) extended through the roof for a number of reasons. Toxic gases (methane, for example) are produced in waste piping and need to be sent outdoors, not into living space. One could argue that venting into a wall space or attic will allow the gases to reach the outdoors eventually if the attic is ventilated but, why take the chance?

Moisture escapes from the vent pipe. Do you really want extra moisture in your walls, attic, or insulation?

Mice and other vermin would enjoy building nests in that warm, dark pipe. It seems they delight in seeing humans run plumbing snakes down pipes trying to make them drain properly, while the problem is up the piping. You won't hear them laughing but, trust me, they will.

Have you ever smelled sewer gas? It ain't pretty and I'd avoid pumping it into living space.

Yes, extend the vent pipe through the roof.

Al

Re: OT Plumbing

#4

Re: OT Plumbing

David G. Sparks

>I've recently had to deal with a sewer gas problem in my house. It turned out to be a combination of a leaking wax ring and a new puppy peeing on our bathmat, but I learned some things about how plumbing works in the process. I spoke to a plumber about the possibility of a plumbing roof vent being clogged. He said that if the vent is clogged the plumbing system can't breathe. I got the opinion that the vent pipe acts like a chimney to draw the gases the system as well as keeping a vacuum from forming preventing liquids from draining properly. If the vent doesn't go through the roof it can't work properly. The other guys are right; this has to be a code violation.

Re: OT Plumbing

#5

Re: OT: Plumbing vent piping

Gene Gauss

>A previous owner of my place had done a slipshod job of making a connection in the vent pipe going to the roof. It disconnected several years after we bought it, and I discovered the problem when tracking down the source of the stench in the adjacent room. Extend that pipe out the roof. Gene Gauss

Re: OT Plumbing

#6

Re: OT Plumbing

Barry Irby

>You have gotten good advice here and it should be clear there are several reasons what your friend has is not good. Extending it through the roof may be required locally and is certainly a good idea, but there may be an alternative.

There are vents that are suitable for indoor use. Locally called Pro-vents (I believe that is a brand name, I can't think of the generic name.) These are one way "valves" that let air in, but not out. They will let the air in to break the vacuum that might develop and allow the water to flow smoothly in the system, but not allow sewer gases to escape. So, your friend might be able to use one of these and not have to cut a hole int he roof and flash the opening. The trade off is the potential for a roof leak against the potential for a sewer gas leak. Check with your local building official on the Pro-Vents. Personally, I am slowly turning into an old fuddy duddy and would rather have the "old school" approach of the vent through the roof. Ancient technology I understand. Either way, don't ignor it.

Re: OT Plumbing

#7

More info

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>Around here every trap has a vent that extends into the attic space. One of the stacks must extend through the roof, the others may have pro-vents and stay in the attic. If you have only one stack it must extend through the roof. That is code here, check your own local codes.

Ray

Re: OT Plumbing

#8

Even More Info.

Barry Irby

>Might be a good idea to look around for other similar vents. If "they" failed to connect or terminate one properly, they may have for gotten others or all of them. Most probably there should be at least one running out through the roof. It is possible they put a tee in that stack and meant to run this one into it. That would mean the other vent is "open" too.

If there is a vent through the roof "handy" you could cut it, insert a Tee and tie this one into that one. In this situation, the Tee should be "upside" down. The tees are "swept" (not symmetrical and designed for flow in one direction). For a vent the flow is up and out.

Re: OT Plumbing

#9

Re: OT Plumbing

Kneale Brownson in sunny N. MI

>I always thought pro-vents were for use in places where it's impossible to extend a vent pipe up a wall and through the roof, like under a vanity sink, and they were not to serve as the main vent stack, only to improve flow from a single fixture located too far from the stack to permit good flow.