Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

To trust or not?? that is the question !!

Posts

To trust or not?? that is the question !!

#1

To trust or not?? that is the question !!

Dave Anderson (PacNW)

>After many moons of needing a bigger bandsaw and saving pennies. I finally had the funds for a new saw. I read and reread all of the reviews on 14" saws from the ww mags. When Woodcraft had their 10% sale last week , I ordered the Rikon 14" Deluxe Saw (The Top Saw in nearly every magazine test). On Friday They called to tell me my saw was in--HAPPY DAY !!!! Yesterday, I slogged through 1 1/2 hours of traffic, paid my pennies and took home my new toy. I promptly started to assemble the saw and the exstasy turned to disappointment to disgust. First, the shelf inside the base is 1/2" to too short in width. Second, the base plate ofthte saw had been miscut by about 3/8" on 2 corners. They beat the corners together then welded them. The result was a base that the diagonals measured 7/8" differance. I began to really pay attention. The weld on the front of the column to base was cracked. upon opening the lower wheel cover I was truly shocked, there were only 4- 3/4" welds 1/16" wide inside holding the lower column together. It was only held together by spit balls and paint! I didn't bother to finish unpacking it, back into the truck and back to Woodcraft I go. They were vey nice to work with but after examining the floor model and finding the lower front column weld was cracked, I opted for a refund. Wonderful design, (insert 4 letter word for smelly brown stuff)quality control! These magazine tests need to really examine off the shelf equipment and not gussied up manufacture's toys.

I am now looking at Powermatic 14" with a riser block.

Just my 2 cents Worth,

Dave Anderson

Re: To trust or not?? that is the question !!

#2

Re: If you trust a magazine review...

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>There's a bandsaw review in the FWW that came in yesterday's mail.

Of course, they liked the Laguna, but they also liked a Griz. For me, it was worth reading. I'm not buying a saw right now, though.

Re: To trust or not?? that is the question !!

#3

Re: If you trust a magazine review...

john lucas

>I try to take all the reviews with a grain of salt. I think they are done with good intentions and perhaps there are quality control issues on every brand. I went to the main office of the Steel City tools to look at the various models, especially the bandsaws. I was extremly impressed with the machines and attention to detail. The FWW review rated the machine very poor. I had not seen any of the problems they reported and would have bought the bandsaw if I had the money. I think they just got a bad one. If you can look at a Steel City machine do so. I'm not affiliated in any way I was just very impressed with the products.

Re: To trust or not?? that is the question !!

#4

JL

Re: Something to be said for old iron...

JL

>I have a 14" Delta - it may be older (I am the 2nd owner) - but it works well. It's got a mobile base. My only complaint is I couldn't really do any resawing with it.

Re: To trust or not?? that is the question !!

#5

Re: If you can afford it - long

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I highly recommend the MiniMax MM 16. I did a lot of searching when I replaced my Crapsman tilting head saw about 6 months ago. I have looked at the various saws at the tool shows and woodworking stores, including Delta, Powermatic, Laguna, Grizzly, Minimax, and Jet. I am retired and only intend to purchase a major tool one time. I did want the capability of re-sawing, and ability to saw thick blocks for lathe work. Looking at the standard offerings in the 14" saws, none had these capabilities as manufactured. If you figure the cost of adding the Carter guides, riser block, Mobile base, new tensioning springs etc. When finished you end up spending $1,000 - $1500 and have a "modified" version - still underpowered, with a small table, light trunnions and maximum 3/4" blade capacity - not capable of using the carbide tipped blades. Soooo, I looked at the larger 16 to 20" saws. Essentially, I felt these would be a better buy for my shop. After doing a whole lot of reading of reviews, I decided the MM -16 had all the features I wanted, right out of the box! I purchased one - total cost delivered was under $2400, (including mobile base, and an excellent dust collector system). I just looked at the web site and they have them on sale again - $2295 + shipping. I am delighted with the quality in all areas. It has a very heavy cast Iron trunnion, you cannot flex the table - period (unlike the Delta 20"), The saw is very, very smooth running, has 16 inch resaw capacity with a 4.8 hp motor. I am a retired manufacturing / quality engineer, so inspected every area of the saw, only issue I have is with the start switch - works perfectly, just don't like the design - I may replace it after the warranty expires. I have resawn White Oak using a woodslicer blade, with 8" thick material the saw didn't slow down at all no matter I fast I fed, didn't even have to "skew" the fence to cut straight and true. I would recommend this Cadillac of saws to anyone.

Re: To trust or not?? that is the question !!

#6

Re: If you can afford it - long

Barry Irby

>Larry, I have to agree. I have never even seen the saw you mention, but I bought a Delta 14" saw about five years ago. I feel like I bought a kit and have tried to build a bandsaw out of it. Riser block, guides, tension release, homemade dust collection add up to over a grand. I still have the saw and use it, but its a love/hate relationship. Wish I could afford to go the way you did. Actually, I wish I could keep the one I have with a "circle" cutting blade and get the one you have for cutting straight, but that's another story.

Re: To trust or not?? that is the question !!

#7

Re: If you can afford it - long

Loft Guy

>Hi,

Another endorsement for the MM-16; After investigating all the brands available, I bought a MM a couple of years back and couldn't be happier.

I do a lot of resawing of cherry, maple and walnut and am always pleased with the results.

Alos, there is a MM owners web site which contains a tremendous amount of helpful info.

Bob

Re: To trust or not?? that is the question !!

#8

Re: To trust or not?? that is the question !!

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Dave,

I am frankly surprised that you exp4erienced so many problems with a saw I admired recently in a Woodcraft showroom. I just replaced my 1997 14" Jet with another 14" Jet. The difference was 10 years, a riser block, and mobile base. My #3 son got my older machine with 7 blades. Because I got such a great deal on my new one, the Rikon didn't even enter my mind. But it did look good and I was impressed. So often I have been lead to specific tools as a result of reading reviews, only to purchase another brand which was rated lower. I think there is wisdom in using reviews only as a guide, and bearing in mind that what is in the showroom isn't necessarily what is in the box. You were right to take the thing back. Hope your Powermatic or whatever you buy exceeds your expectations.

George

Re: To trust or not?? that is the question !!

#9

Re: If you can afford it - long

Thomas S Stockton

>I thought I saw a used mm-16 for sale in portland Just can't remember were. Peobably either the minimax yahoo group , woodweb tools for sale forum or sawmill creek. I was in the local western tool and looked at the powermatic and felt like it was fairly expensive and for a couple hundred more you could get a jet, rikon or grizzly steel framed saw that is much sturdier and more heavily built. I've always felt like the 14" saws based on the old delta design are at the edge of there design limits when fitted with the riser block and resawing 10" or so of hardwood into veneers. I have a 20 year old mm s45 saw and it seems very similar to the jet or rikon 18" saws and actually these saws have some nicer features and more power. the other thing about bigger wheels is that they are less stressfull on blades not so important on wider blades but 1/4" or narrower blades tend to break more often than others.All this said the old delta's were pretty bullet proof I worked in a shop with two of them that ran almost all day and except for bearings and occasionaly tires these saws just didn't stop.

Tom

Re: To trust or not?? that is the question !!

#10

Re: To trust or not?? that is the question !!

Samuel Brooks

>I have the Powermatic and really like it. It has all the upgrades right out of the box and mine has been great. I really like the tention release and the work light. The machine runs smooth and is very quiet.

For the under $1000 category I really like the Powermatic. If you are going to spend more then $1000 on a bandsaw then you might as well look at a MiniMax that class of equipment because lets face it. If you can afford more then $1000 for single piece of shop equipment then you can afford $2000 :-). I think I might try that logic on my next purchase maybe I can talk myself into a combo machine.

I am happy with my Powermatic and that was almost 2 years ago, I have no buyers remorse on price or features.

Good luck with whatever you decide.

Sam Brooks

Re: To trust or not?? that is the question !!

#11

Main problem with magazine reviews....

wilbur

>I think that one of the main problems with magazine reviews is that they focus on a set of parameters that may not be important in daily use. For example, the current FWW 14" bandsaw review mentions wheel alignment as being important, and they rated the bandsaws accordingly. Now, I certainly think that wheel alignment is important. But from a user's standpoint, I think that the more important issue is how long those wheels stay aligned once you align them.

If one bandsaw had wheels out of alignment by 3/16", while another had perfect wheel alignment, the first bandsaw would get dinged in the FWW article. But the degree of msalignment would not matter if the bandsaw with perfect wheel alignment drifted out of alignment after resawing only 6 feet of boards, while the bandsaw with poor out-of-the-box alignment stayed true after correcting the alignment and resawing over 500 feet of boards.

For this article, the only thing that I found important was the fact that the Jet and Powermatic's wheels were so far out of alignment that they couldn't be brought into line due to the short shafts on these bandsaws.

Just because you can measure something doesn't mean that it's important.

Re: To trust or not?? that is the question !!

#12

Re: If you can afford it - long

Don Evans

>Larry:

I own the MM16 also and "ditto" to all you said, even the power switch. But once I got use to the switch it's no problem for me now.

What blades are you using on it?

I'm still using the 1/2" that came with it and have couple of Timberwolves hanging on wall but haven't tried them yet.

Don

Re: To trust or not?? that is the question !!

#13

Re: Main problem with magazine reviews....

Bill White

>"JUST BECAUSE YOU CAN MEASURE......"

You couldn't be more right. I am as concerned with accuracy as are most of the woodsmiths I know. Where I go nuts is the never-ending search for the ability to get to 5 decimal place measurements.

Now don't think that I'm blowing off quality or craftsmanship. I just don't think that the guys who built the antiques we own were too worried about those things, but ya know what? Those wonderful pieces are still holdin' together despite time, temperature, some abuse, ignorance, and shipping from England.

That being said, I feel that there is no excuse for poor quality on a much-touted piece of equipment.

Ya done good by sending it back.

Phew! I feel better.

Bill

Re: To trust or not?? that is the question !!

#14

Re: If you can afford it - long

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Dan, I am using a 1/2" Woodslicer from Highland Hardware. I have the 3 blades (Olson??) that came with the MM16 - I opted for an 1 1/4, 1" and 1/4 as I remember but I haven't even tried them out. When the saw was shipped the blades were shipped separately, I ordered two Woodslicer's at the same time, 1/2 & 3/4. the 1/2" came in before the MM blades so I installed it. The 3/4" Woodslicer had just been offered for sale, and was back ordered, I have it now - still in the wrapping. I was talking to the gentleman at the carbide saw and tool sharpening service where I have my round blades sharpened. He offered me the Lenox Trimaster for less than $150 - Many have to purchase one - hard to pass up at that price after all the good things I have heard about them. The woodslicer is also an excellent blade. I have a Timberwolf on my old POS Craftsman, good blade but I think the Woodslicer is somewhat better. However it is to compare due to the saws.