Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Bessey K-Body vs. Gross Stabil PC2

Posts

Bessey K-Body vs. Gross Stabil PC2

#1

Bessey K-Body vs. Gross Stabil PC2

Ed in Lawrence, KS

>Any opinions on Bessey's K-Body parallel jaw clamps vs. Gross Stabil's PC2's? Bessey evidently purchased Gross Stabil and is liquidating their clamp stock. Consequently, Woodpecker is having a half price sale on the Gross Stabil PC2's. It looks like a can't miss purchase, but I can't really find anything definative on the Gross Stabil's to back me up. I just don't want to buy something that will gather dust on my tool shelf. Thanks.

Re: Bessey K-Body vs. Gross Stabil PC2

#2

Jim in Burlington Ont.

I have both

Jim in Burlington On

>I have quite a few Gross Stabil clamps and about 12 bessy K body clamps. Gross Stabil's have a replaceable face pad. I think you can get more clamping pressure with the Gross clamps. They are a bit heavier than bessys also. Can't go wrong with either clamp. I spray the bars with TopCote so glue just falls off them. I wish the sale was closer to me I'd be heading over for 8 of the biggest ones they make.

Re: Bessey K-Body vs. Gross Stabil PC2

#3

Re: I have both

mike from American Sycamore

>I purchased 50 Bessey K bodies when I started the school six years ago and they are worn out. I called Bessey and they bring no replacement parts into the country, I have several broken as well. The Besseys look good hanging on the wall, but I will never buy another. I will only buy the Adjustable Clamp Jorgenson heavy duty I-bars style 72. I have learned my lesson. I wish I knew back when I started what I know know. (?)

Re: Bessey K-Body vs. Gross Stabil PC2

#4

Re: Bessey K-Body vs. Gross Stabil PC2

Thomas S Stockton

>Ed

at half price you can't go wrong, never seen them in person but I've heard really good things about them and ordered 12 of the larger sizes

Tom

Re: Bessey K-Body vs. Gross Stabil PC2

#5

Re: I also have both

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>They both are excellent clamps. I buy whatever's on sale, between the two, although a hobby garage with a couple dozen is probably enough for now...

I've never noted any sizeable differences between them in use.

Re: Bessey K-Body vs. Gross Stabil PC2

#6

Re: I have both

Thomas S Stockton

>Mike

I would tend to agree with you especially in a school situation, I have some bessey tradesman clamps and wetzler clamps and I usually grab a wetzler first the tradesmans tend to slip around as the are getting older. I bought the gross-stabils mostly for holding carcases together and other medium duty clamping and doors and such. I've found that clamping up anything angled with the bessey style clamp is pretty useless, these things were designed for stuff like doors and cabinets that are either flat and/or square. I also have the Jorgenson I-beam clamps along with pipe clamps the I-beams are so much nicer and can take more preasure with less deflection, the only drawback is they are heavier and you can't couple them together and make a 15' clamp like you can with the pipe clamps.

I think what it comes down to is you need to use the right tool for the job and if you understand the limitations they should last but all bets are of if hundreds of people are using them and it is totally frustrating and not very proactive that they don't carry replacement parts

Tom

Re: Bessey K-Body vs. Gross Stabil PC2

#7

SAD ..Re: Bessey vs. Gross Stabil

Mark Mcc

>I have both and when I first was introduced to GS I thought some of their innovations were superb and at a great price. Sad to see Bessey bought them out ( not if your GS of course) Any info on whether Bessey will adopt some of GS technology or is this just a case of the lazy old giant swallowing up the competition so it can keep selling the same old stuff? (had a better word for it)

Mark

Re: Bessey K-Body vs. Gross Stabil PC2

#8

agree.

Ted Wong

>We have a dozen Besseys at our school shop too. And I'd have to say they are pretty mediocre in this setting. The plastic on half of them is cracked and a few have developed a funky behavior with their screw handle. I'd pick an iron bar clamp or a Wetzler any day.

Re: Bessey K-Body vs. Gross Stabil PC2

#9

Re: Bessey K-Body vs. Gross Stabil PC2

matt overton

>I thought bessey was good (I have 20 of them) until bI bought the Jet version. Jet's clamping pressure is much better with much less deflection, and they work great as spreaders as well. Thr GS at half price is a steal. You can't have enough quality clamps

Matt Overton

Re: Bessey K-Body vs. Gross Stabil PC2

#10

I always like to point out…

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>…that the statement “You can't have enough quality clamps” is inherently and demonstrably untrue. Sure you can have enough quality clamps. If you only have one and that's all you need, you have enough. What is demonstrably inviolable (and most correct) is to say “one can never have too many clamps.”

Rod
whose bountiful inventory is yet open ended.

Re: Bessey K-Body vs. Gross Stabil PC2

#11

Re: I always like to point out�

Stuart Hough

>3 or 4 years ago one of the magazines did a comparo on all the K-body style clamps available at the time. The GS (Scotty Phillips signature line) came out on top due to 3 main areas. They clampoed harder, they deflected less, and the "plastic parts" held up to accidents (dropping) better. IMHO, unless Bessey uses the better resin formula on their "plastic parts", we have just lost a superior clamp. Since I couldn't find the GS clmps when I need them I bought the Jorgensen Cabinet-masters, and have been very pleased. Keep in mind ...this is from a neophyte's poit of view.

Re: Bessey K-Body vs. Gross Stabil PC2

#12

Re: I always like to point out�

Thomas S Stockton

>Oh man I hope the ones I got don't have his signiture on them. Just seems the height of silliness to have a signiture line of clamps. Nothing against Scott Phillips never watched his show.

Tom

Re: Bessey K-Body vs. Gross Stabil PC2

#13

Re: Bessey K-Body vs. Gross Stabil PC2

Ray SW Ohio

>Just ordered some, mine came out being a little over the 50% off the regular price, in my favor. Still like my Jorgensen Cabinet Master Clamps. For the price, you can't beat the GS PC2. My 2�.

Re: Bessey K-Body vs. Gross Stabil PC2

#14

Re: Don't they both produce to much pressure?

Peter Gregory

>When I read up on this sort of thing, you don't want more pressure on your glue joint. If you really crank clamps like these, you don't leave enough glue in the joint, so it is weaker.

Re: Bessey K-Body vs. Gross Stabil PC2

#15

Re: Don't they both produce to much pressure?

Thomas S Stockton

>That is more of a problem of self control than the clamp. I find that I usually don't have to use a lot of pressure when clamping panels together. Being able to use more pressure comes in handy when gluing up a joint that is hanging up like on a chair. No matter how nice your joints fit it always seems like one is going to hang up and that extra pressure is nice to pop it in place.

Tom