Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Planer -delta 580 vs 560 - trade up?

Posts

Planer -delta 580 vs 560 - trade up?

#1

Planer -delta 580 vs 560 - trade up?

Dan Manturi

>I have a delta 22-560 planer. nice little machine. I can get a Delta 22-580, the big brother with 2 speeds. Second hand, likely for $180. I can probably sell the 22-560 for $100 or so. Is there that much of a difference? Anyone who has used both - let me know.

Yeah, I know, I heard the Dewalt 735 is better, but I cannot get one used!

Thanks.

Dan M.

Re: Planer -delta 580 vs 560 - trade up?

#2

Re: Planer -delta 580 vs 560 - trade up?

Stuart Hough

>I have the 22-580. I can't say that I have any experience with any other planer at all. I lucked into a STEAL at Lowe's when they discontinued that model. It retailed for $479, and I happened to be right there when they reduced it to $249. I almost soiled myself! I had read the reviews in all the magazines and here it was...affordable. I snapped it up and promised to explain my good fortune to my loving wife, later. I have to say it lives up to every word of praise from the reviewers! The standard speed leaves a beautiful surface, and the finishing speed is just...WOW! I finally explained it to my wife when she came home early from work and found me up to my ankles in shavings. She said I looked like I had been caught with a girlfriend. Imagine that, me with a girlfriend. Hmmmm.

Re: Planer -delta 580 vs 560 - trade up?

#3

Re: Planer -delta 580 vs 560 - trade up?

David Yoho

>Dan, I moved up from a 540 to the 580 (as a point of reference). Actually, I didn't see anything wrong with the old 540. Mine worked like a charm, believe it or not! However, when Lowe's reduced their price to discontinue the the 580, I couldn't snap one up fast enough.

I've read all the good press about the Dewalt but I have to say I haven't been sorry about getting the Delta one bit. It works great. I think the only negative I've found (for me) is the chip shoot with the four-inch port for dust collection. I think they could've designed it better to allow for better chip extraction. Otherwise, I think it's as good a machine as any other.

David

Re: Planer -delta 580 vs 560 - trade up?

#4

Re: Planer -delta 580 vs 560 - trade up?

Terry Alexander

>Here's a great story.

When Lowes was discontinuing the 580, I called around and finally found one. Made the guy tell me he was actually looking at it before I drove 30 miles to pick it up (we've all been there).

When he zapped the carton for me to pay, it came to $121.00. I told him that I really would like to buy this planer for $121, but it retails for $479 and the price should be $225. He said: "Mister, I can call my supervisor over here and he's going to do the same thing I did. Zap it with this gun and tell you it's $121.00. Now do you want it or not?". I politely asked......."Do you have anymore?". (which they did not).

Now for your question.....I have a friend who has the Dewalt and the BIG difference is that the Delta has a steel drum and the Dewalt has an aluminum drum. It is only a question of WHEN you will strip out the holes in the aluminum when changing knives.

HTH

Terry Alexander

Re: Planer -delta 580 vs 560 - trade up?

#5

Another honest man?

Dan Manturi

>Wow! You actually corrected them and they gave it to you anyway? I went to Lowes for some 6/3 wire and a bunch of other stuff. I left and when i got home noticed I had not been charged for the 6/3 wire ($120!!). So I went back and paid for it.

Feel pretty dumb but honest.

Dan

Re: Planer -delta 580 vs 560 - trade up?

#6

I own the whole family tree

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>540, 560 (actually TP400, same machine), and 580. For the cost difference to you, I'd say jump on it. That second speed in itself is worth trading up, along with a number of other nice features.

One thing that I've found out is that when the knives become less than sharp (and start tearing out on the high speed) switching to finishing speed will still give you a nice surface, handy when in the middle of a job and replacement knives aren't available. The only thing about the 580 that's not likeable is that the dust hood tends to clog when planing wide stock, especially pine, despite a powerful DC attached.

For all people say about the DeWalt 735, I have yet to see one that makes a smooth cut, although many like their machines...

DC

Re: Planer -delta 580 vs 560 - trade up?

#7

Re: I own the whole family tree

Bill Sampson

>AS I have never used the Dewalt, I can't compare, but I would purchase another 580 if I needed one. I have owned the 540 for 10 years and it has served my needs very well. About 4 years ago, I purchased the 580 and used it sparingly. The Belt broke and the motor was not running well so I got new brushes and a belt from Delta. After about 100 bd feet, the motor died. I called Delta to find a service shop in my area and explained to the rep what happened to my 580. He asked if he sent a new motor, would I be satisfied. I told him yes, but the unit was way out of warrenty and he really did't owe me anything. He agreed, but said sometimes a motor goes bad and he didn't have a problem with replacing it. Didn't even want the old motor returned. Reason to continue buying Delta products;for me,yes. The unit now works fine at both speeds.

Bill Sampson, Richmond

Re: Planer -delta 580 vs 560 - trade up?

#8

Re: Planer -delta 580 vs 560 - trade up?

Paul Dwight

>I had the 560 before upgrading to the 580 years ago. The 560 was a nice little machine that gave me perfectly acceptable results. The 580 is better is better in nearly every way, as long as you don't mind the extra weight. The 580 is heavy enough that calling it "portable" stretches things a bit. Compared to the 560, I think the 580 leaves a smoother finish with less tear out when used at the slower speed -- but the difference isn't really dramatic. The 560 gave good results, the slow speed on the 580 gives somewhat better results. If you can swing the upgrade for $80 net (after selling your old 560), I would say it's a no-brainer. Go for it! -- Paul

Re: Planer -delta 580 vs 560 - trade up?

#9

Re: Planer -delta 580 vs 560 - trade up? *LINK*

knotscott

>I made the jump from a 22-560 to the 22-580 when Lowe's put the 22-580 on sale for $230. Overall I like it better, and for the cost difference you mentioned I'd do it, but it's not 100% in favor of the 580.

The 560 has some well thought out features...like the cord cleat, and the ability to raise the outfeed with the DC chute in place. The DC chute is better on the 560 than the 580, and the feedrollers get dirty and slip far more often than they did on the 560.

That said, the 580 has some nice features too. The 2 speeds of the 580 are handy sometimes. The beds are longer, and it has a thickness gauge that the 560 lacked. The 580 is also heavier and more stable. With any planer, assuming some ability to reduce snipe by holding the cutterhead in place, the performance boils down to blade condition, cuts per inch, and table alignment.


http://www.epinions.com/22-580 review

Re: Planer -delta 580 vs 560 - trade up?

#10

Guess I'll go for it..

Dan Manturi

>Thanks for the input. I guess i will make the jump. I actually have an old Jet planer (real old) but would hesitate to sell that to anyone. i use it strictly for rough planing and will keep it for that purpose. If I sell something, I want to know the new owner gets something that is usable.

thanks for the input.

Dan