OT- Laptop pre-purchase question
Chuck W
>I am considering buying a Dell Inspiron 1420 with 3-year warranty. Should I go with a Dell or buy an Apple laptop instead?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
OT- Laptop pre-purchase question
Chuck W
>I am considering buying a Dell Inspiron 1420 with 3-year warranty. Should I go with a Dell or buy an Apple laptop instead?
Re: OT- Laptop pre-purchase question
A.J. Hamler Actually, it's not Dell vs Apple, but PC vs Apple. If you decide on a PC, you can't go wrong with Dell. I have three _mine, my wife's and my daughter's -- and I've been nothing but pleased. As to the PC vs Apple question, well... That's a biggie. For me, I say PC, but I suspect you're going to get a huge range of responses. A.J.
>Whoa... Let the war begin.
My $.02
doug f, san clemente, ca
>Chuck - recently had the same decision. I tried (and returned) three different PCs, HP, Sony and Toshiba. All had the same problem; VISTA. The new operating system from Windows had trouble with my network connection, my printer and several of my software programs.
We bit the bullet and bought a Mac. More money, but so far no compatibility problems. Be aware that a lot of programs simply do not run on a Mac, but the ones I use (Word, Excel, Power Point) all have Mac equivalents that work just fine.
Good luck.
Doug
Re: My $.02
Glenn Madsen near San Francisco
>We have both. IBM/Lenovo, Dell laptops. Sony desktops. And one son runs three Macs, including a $2800 super laptop. That one is the very coolest computer in the group.
I've had a PC for 25 years. My next one will be a Mac of some type. (Except whatever the company buys me...)
Re: My $.02
Stuart Johnson
>I have a HP with Vista and have run into some problems. Not all software that ran on Win98 (my last OS) will run using Vista. It does have feature that allows you to open programs using older versions of Windows and so far I have only one program Adobe PhotoDelux that will not work.
My current problem is when linked stuff won't work. For example I cannot access the WoW chat server. And, just last week I have run into a problem with Wood Central. Is this a problem with Vista, Java, ParaChat or the way the three are interacting. On the other hand it could not be related to any of the three. Only a tech support in India knew and his job was outsourced to Bangladesh.
Re: Depends who you want to talk to
Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa
>Employee of the Month
(I Think I spoke to this guy once or twice!! )
Mujibar was trying to get a job in India
The Personnel Manager said, "Mujibar, you have passed all the tests,
except one. Unless you pass it you cannot qualify for this job."
Mujibar said, "I am ready."
The manager said, "Make a sentence using the words Yellow, Pink and
Green."
Mujibar thought for a few minutes and said,
"Mister manager, I am ready."
The manager said, "Go ahead." Mujibar.'"
Mujibar said, "The telephone goes green, green, and I pink it up, and
say, 'Yellow, Mujibar now works as a technician at a call center for
computer
problems .
No doubt you have spoken to him, too.
Re: OT- Laptop pre-purchase question
Dan Manturi
>If you are looking at a Dell, do not overlook the dell outlet. I have included the link. These are current model machines that were built for folks and orders canceled, minor blemishes, and some refurbs, all with Dell warranty as new. You need to sort of settle for a configuration, but I have gotten some excellent deals there.'
Know nothing about Vista or Macs. I can also say that on occasion when I had a problem with my Dell handheld PC, I got excellent support from an India based tech, however I have also been frustrated with same from other companies and other offshore companies.
Check out the outlet. you can tailor your choices somewhat on searches as well, Easy site to navigate.
Regards,
Dan M.
Re: My $.02
Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio
>I bought a new Dell Latitude just a couple weeks ago, and had the choice of XP or Vista (basic home).
I very gladly chose the XP system. I figure that by the time this laptop is worn out/obsolescent, they'll have the bugs out of Vista - and probably will have yet another bug-filled gee whiz replacement for it. I'll probably opt for a Vista machine then...
Re: My $.02
Dan Donaldson
>I did sorta the same thing, except that I bought my new one with linux on it and no windows at all. I ain't going Vista. I really had no serious problems with XP other than the constant stuff you had to do to keep spyware and viri out of it, but I just don't like the Vista philosophy. Basically MS owns your computer and you get to use it, but only how they want you to. If you like to tinker, have a high threshold for frustration and are willing to learn, then go with Linux. It is free, has equivalents for almost any Windows program (except games) and runs on most current hardware. Otherwise, buy and Apple and just use it.
Warranty issue
Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie
>If you knew that a Mercedez-Benz car typically lasts 10 years before having any problems, would you buy a car that costs less that typically starts having problems after 3 years? Sure.
Would you pay for an extended warranty on that cheaper car? Perhpas.
What if the cost of that cheaper car plus the extra warranty exceed the price of the Mercedez?
I can't comment on that exact Dell model, but what I can tell you from years of experience is that these manufactures make several lines of computers. The retail/consumer grade machines that come with a one year warranty are built to last, get this, one year. Business grade machines with a standard 3 year warranty are built to last 3 years.
They build computers using different components.
So buying a machine that was built for one year, and getting an extended warranty, isn't going to change how it was built. It mearly changes who will pay for repairs WHEN it breaks.
For the same money, I think it is always better to buy a machine that was designed and built to last 3 years than a machine that was built to last 1 with an extended warranty.
Now there is nothing wrong with spending $400 on a laptop with a 1 year warranty, and replacing it each year if it breaks, compared to buying a $1200 computer with a 3 year warranty. But if you're buying a computer with a 1 year warranty and then spending more to extend the warranty, better check to make sure you're not paying as much as a business class machine.
Happy Woodworking!
Re: OT- Laptop pre-purchase question
Tom
>You have your choice with Dell usually, XP or Vista. For now at least. You can get a fully loaded Core 2 Duo Dell for less than $700. I'm guessing that is about half the price of an equivalent Mac. The whole pc/Mac debate is a personal preference, as far as I'm concerned. The Dell Small Business division usually has much better deals than the Home division. A nicely furnished AMD dual-core can be had for roughly $525 currently (so nice I've got 3 on the way:) ).
Apples/oranges: Dells not necessarily cheaper
wilbur
>If you outfit a Dell laptop to match the specs of a Macbook, the difference in price closes down considerably. For grins, I just configured an Inspiron 1420 to match the middle level Macbook ($1299), and I got a price difference of about $100. Starting with that $700 laptop, I had to upgrade the processor, add a CD / DVD writer, an 802.11n wireless card, Bluetooth, and a built in camera, all of which come with the Macbook. Because of promotions, the Dell gets an extra 1GB of memory, and 40GB of hard drive space, but the Macbook comes with a much more robust software package, and you won't have to buy an antivirus subscription.
It's true that Dell will sell a cheaper laptop in the sense that you can give them $700 and they will sell you a laptop, but that doesn't mean that Apple is more expensive. It means that Apple has not chosen to make a laptop at that price point.
Re: OT- Laptop pre-purchase question *LINK*
wilbur
>I would say go with a Macbook. You can have a secure, hacker-resistant computer with much less work than you would need with Windows.
You might want to look at this thread, where another WC'er was looking to get a new laptop, and ultimately wound up buying a Macbook.
Email me if you want the uber-geeky reason why I think Mac OS X is a better designed operating system than Windows. It's like the difference between a dovetailed drawer and one made with butt joints.
Another WoodCentral thread on laptops
Re: OT- Laptop pre-purchase question
Ray SW Ohio
>Ended up buying a mac laptop for myself. Got tired of all the security updates with Windows. The mac is faster than the toshiba I have too.
Re: Apples/oranges: Dells not necessarily cheaper
Lee Gordon
>That is a very interesting comparison, and indeed, to get a Dell similarly equipped to a mid-level Mac, the price does become a bit close. However, before anyone makes the purchase they have to ask themselves if they really need all the stuff that comes with the Mac, such as the built-in camera, because they're paying for it whether they want it or not. At least with the Dell and many other value-priced PCs, you have the option to omit some of the things you have no use for.
Out of curiosity...
Ellis Walentine
>...what was the nature of the WoodCentral problem. Certain inquiring minds like to know these things.
Ellis Walentine, Host
Yikes! And factor in your time...
Ellis Walentine
>Now there is nothing wrong with spending $400 on a laptop with a 1 year warranty, and replacing it each year if it breaks, compared to buying a $1200 computer with a 3 year warranty. But if you're buying a computer with a 1 year warranty and then spending more to extend the warranty, better check to make sure you're not paying as much as a business class machine.
I spend so much time keeping my computers and network healthy and functioning that I wonder how I can ever recoup the value of my time. I've given Macs more than a look. Now with the dual platform capabilities, they're more attractive to me than ever.
I started in the mid-80s on a little Mac. It was cumbersome and slow, but of course Apple addressed all the early problems. I have a pal who is a Unix guru and an awesome PHP coder, and what he can do on his Mac laptop is astounding to me.
Ellis
Re: OT- Update: Laptop is purchased
Chuck W
>I went with the Inspiron 1420 after all. Thanks to all who weighed in with an opinion on the subject. I qualified for a discount from Dell through my company so price was the deciding factor for me.