table saw motor
Sean Troy
>Hey all, how much trouble and expense would there be changing out a 3phase 3hp motor on a PM model 66 TS to a 3hp 230v single phase motor? Thanks for any help. Sean
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
table saw motor
Sean Troy
>Hey all, how much trouble and expense would there be changing out a 3phase 3hp motor on a PM model 66 TS to a 3hp 230v single phase motor? Thanks for any help. Sean
Re: table saw motor
Jim Swank
>Not too bad, changing out the motor, though you'll want friend to help hold while you loosen/install bolts. You'll have to change out the power cord tto, and either replace or maybe just put new heaters in the stop-start button.
consider a phase converter...
Grant Smith
>Over the years, I have built my shop with all single phase machinery. There have been many times that I have passed on a bargain tool simply because I don't have 3 phase power.
If I had it to do over, I would consider buying a rotary phase converter. They can be had for $350-700 or so new for a made in USA unit.
You could then buy used older 3 phase machinery and overall probably outfit the shop more cheaply than with single phase stuff. Usually, 3 phase stuff at auctions doesn't go as high as single phase stuff due to the buyers present not all having 3 phase.
Another added benefit is that 3 phase motors are cheaper to manufacture, and as such even new machinery can be cheaper in 3 phase versus single phase.
Food for thought, link below to one I googled to get you started...
Grant in Iowa
Ooops! its a link, not a photo! *LINK*
Grant Smith
>
Temco
Re: table saw motor
john lucas
>You can also get a Variable Frequency Drive. You should be able to get your local motor company to set one up for you. They aren't very expensive and work quite well.
Re: table saw motor
Ken Romines
>Sean
I recently converted a Unisaw from 3 phase to single phase. The motor is not a problem to change. Mine required one bolt and a rod hanger, took nearly 5 minutes of puffing to get it done by myself. (No, I don't recommend doing it yourself--it's a huge strain.) But the new 3 horse motor cost +-$300 and the new switch was another $100. I'm real happy with the trade but I don't have any other 3 phase equipment nor am I anticipating getting any more heavy equipment for a while.
Ken
Here you go. Cheaper than a new motor
Forrest Addy
>http://cgi.ebay.com/3-HP-VFD-VARIABLE-FREQUENCY-AC-MOTOR-SPEED-DRIVE_W0QQitemZ130138030312QQihZ003QQcategoryZ71393QQssPageNameZWDVWQQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem.
There's stuff to know about VFD's so do some research. Some of the beauties about a VFD is the controlled accelleration that practically eliminates the starting surge, adjustabel speed, and the adjustable electronic braking.
You'll want on on your drill press too. But they don't work with single phase motors, only three phase.
VFDs
phil in NJ
>A few things to consider, before going the VFD route...
- The VFDs with single-phase input should be derated appropriately. Check out the manual for the specific unit you're interested in. A nominal 3HP VFD probably isn't appropriate for a 3HP 3phase saw motor on a single-phase input... you'll need a bigger VFD.
- A proper VFD installation is more than just the drive. You really should have an enclosure with fuses, a contactor, and appropriate controls. VFDs should not be exposed to dust in general. Often VFDs have filters on their power inputs to reduce harmonics and EMI.
- strictly speaking, a VFD on a standard motor (non inverter-duty) will stress the insulation of the motor more than a true 3-phase source. Again, while this is OK for casual use, a VFD will probably shorten the lifespan of the motor.
While lots of people probably just stick in a drive and do OK, if the drive ever fails catastrophically, it could catch on fire, etc.
If properly fused, and enclosed in a steel enclosure, things are much safer IMHO.
Re: table saw motor
McKay
>I have had a 66 and I believe that it is NOT possible to change the motor in an economical manner. A phase converter would be worth the time and money. I also have a unisaw and have used sawstop, davis/wells, and laguna. You will find that the older 66s are worth saving and changing.
For the record
Forrest Addy
>For the record, a VFD qualified as an over current protection device under the new Code. You still need a means of curcuit interrupt withing sigth of the equipment and a molded case or fused circuit protection.
Single phase rated VFD's (many if 3 HP 230 V are but look for a specific single phase rating anyway) are common these days.
I would never consider changing out a three phase motor for single phase or use a phase converter given the many virtures of VFD's. I have seven VFD's in my shop from 3/4 to 40 HP.
Re: For the record
Phil Thien
>Theoretical question. If you have a 40HP VFD, couldn't you use that to wire your entire shop w/ 3-phase and just use that single VFD for all your tools?
Practical answer, yes but...
Forrest Addy
>Practical answer, yes but the 40 HP is dedicate to the 20 HP metal working planer. It's 40 HP because that was the one that was cheap. All the others are running vaiable speed loads and I'm too lazy to haul VFD's areound and connecting them to the machines I need to run.