Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Unisaw vs. Contractor's&Dust Collection

Posts

Unisaw vs. Contractor's&Dust Collection

#1

Unisaw vs. Contractor's&Dust Collection

Tom Norton

>So between the 2 which has the better capability of dust collection?

Re: Unisaw vs. Contractor's&Dust Collection

#2

Re: Unisaw vs. Contractor's&Dust Collection

Ray Binnicker

>The Unisaw, without a doubt.

Ray Binnicker

Re: Unisaw vs. Contractor's&Dust Collection

#3

Re: Unisaw vs. Contractor's&Dust Collection

Brian in SLO

>Unisaw. Hands down the better of the two.

Re: Unisaw vs. Contractor's&Dust Collection

#4

Another thing, but not the question you asked...

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>…people tend to think they need more room for a cabinet saw than a contractors saw. Actually the opposite is true—the footprint for a cabinet saw is somewhat smaller than a contractors saw because of the motor hanging out the back and the splayed legs (on the contractors saw). That's discounting the table extensions, which should cancel out, in any event, as you'd likely have the same for one as the other.

Rod

Re: Unisaw vs. Contractor's&Dust Collection

#5

Re: Unisaw vs. Contractor's&Dust Collection

Binen

>Dust collection for a contractors saw is generally any horizontal surface in your shop.

Binen

Re: Unisaw vs. Contractor's&Dust Collection

#6

Re: Unisaw vs. Contractor's&Dust Collection

Chuck Lenz

>Don't let these guys fool ya, they probably all own cabinet saws. Contactors saws can do a good job too if setup correctly.

Re: Unisaw vs. Contractor's&Dust Collection

#7

Re: Unisaw vs. Contractor's&Dust Collection

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I have owned several older "contractor" and table saws. Now own a Unisaw. There is no comparison to the Unisaw. It does a 10X better job. It comes from the factory with a tight -almost sealed base - that has a welded in slanted bottom leading to the dust collector connection. That said I have not owned any of the later models of the contractor saws, they may have made major improvements. I can't see how they can be quite as good due to the belt drive being behind the saw which has to have some openings. I still get some sawdust as I don't have an overhead pickup. I have seen several postings about homebuilt dust collector cabinets built to contain the dust. - Don't have to do that with a cabinet saw.

Re: Unisaw vs. Contractor's&Dust Collection

#8

Re: Unisaw vs. Contractor's&Dust Collection

Dan Manturi

>I'd say that the limitation on effectiveness of dust collection in a contractors saw is the open back and motor hanging out. With the contractors, the motor and belts are contained in the same cabinet as the saw works, which acts as a huge plenum. Had a contractors saw and it just seems that the unisaw is more effective without any modifications. I also have an overhead blade guard with NO dust collection (UNiguard) but plan on doing a modification on that. No difference there between a contractors saw and unisaw....

Good luck.

Re: Unisaw vs. Contractor's&Dust Collection

#9

Re: Unisaw vs. Contractor's&Dust Collection

Ray Newman

>Dan: I also have a Unisaw w/ a Uniguard. How do plan on modifying the Uniguard for dust collection?

I've been trying to figure something out, but really don't want to cut up the plastic guard & find that it will not work....

Re: Unisaw vs. Contractor's&Dust Collection

#10

Re: Unisaw vs. Contractor's&Dust Collection

Dan Manturi

>I saw an internet article in passing one day at the office about a dust collection modification and cannot find that link. When I do, and if it looks workable, I'll do the mod and post it...

I just have to find it.

Sorry - did not mean to infer I was read to go with it!

Dan

Re: Unisaw vs. Contractor's&Dust Collection

#11

Re: Unisaw vs. Contractor's&Dust Collection

knotscott

>Contractor saws can be modified for improved DC but the physics don't work in their favor compared to an enclosed base saw.

Re: Unisaw vs. Contractor's&Dust Collection

#12

I'm not so sure…

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>…that he was looking for a performance debate, per se—I think he just wanted some thoughts in the dust collection aspect. I threw in the footprint thing to help his thinking, solely because it is a not well known, and therefore, rarely considered aspect of the comparison.

Yes, I have a cabinet saw. Not because I thought it was twice as good (at twice the cost) as the contractors, but for other reasons, not the least of which is vanity. I don't think there is any question that one can probably do the same quality of work with either.

Rod