Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

The Fat Lady has Sung

Posts

The Fat Lady has Sung

#1

Alan Young

The Fat Lady has Sung

Alan Young

>I delivered the end table last night and the client liked it. The color was good and she is happy. The client is 24 miles away and as I drove home I kept my cell phone at hand trusting that I would not hear it ring! :^)

When I got home I checked my e-mail and found this note:



Hi Alan,

XXX is happy with the table. They look great with our new lamps and I think the wood really warms up the large room. Moved the metal table into the dinning room where fixtures, etc. are all trimmed in like metal. All is well that ends well--------------thanks for all your hard work.

Sincerely,

XXX & XXXXXX

In summing up this project I guess I'd say Ellis's cometary is again DEAD ON. , It doesn't really matter how hard then job is or what the client wants-When you make a decision to take on a commission you must find a way to get the job done. I am sure I "lost" money on this job because of the mistakes I made and the extra time I spent repeating the finishing step,re-veneering, multiple delivery runs...on and and on it seems. I was ready to toss in the towel a couple of times but I knew the problem was mine -not the clients- not even the wood.

This project looked very simple and easy-In fact that's why I took it on- I already had two big project that I was working on but I thought-"These table are so simple I can knock these out in no-time"

I was party correct. I built them in two weekends time. But the finishing took me down.

Every so often we find ourselves in over or heads. I am grateful to Ellis and several folks here at WC for the lessons in toning the lacquer. It saved the job.

I have included Ellis's commentary from my post yesterday because it is important information for anyone contemplating commissioned work.

Alan



... maple is a great wood, able to be stained, dyed, glazed, finished, etc. without blotching, assuming correct procedures are used, so I don't think you can justifiably shift the blame to the choice of wood -- which is exactly how the client will take your claim. Better to admit that the finishing process got corrupted somehow and that you're there to give them what they want.

The way to have prevailed with your recommendation of anigre would have been to show them a sample of anigre finished exactly as you planned to deliver it to them. If they thought it was a good choice, they would have given you the green light and you could have done what you really wanted to do to begin with. But, it's also your job as the contractor to deliver a quality product regardless of the species they specify. Here again, this would have given you a chance to try to duplicate the look of their existing maple furniture. If you couldn't duplicate it, you probably should have found a finisher who could, or declined the project in that species.

The corollary to "the customer is always right" is that the customer most often doesn't have a clue as to what he/she's talking about or comprehending. You're the woodworker. It's your job to schmooze the customer and show them what their options really are: this wood, that finish, etc. Personal meetings and actual samples are so important to keep everyone on the same page. Bluelines and technical descriptions are worthless if the customer doesn't like the finished project. You may have the better argument in court or at an arbitration hearing, but that doesn't mean you'll get paid. It's best to keep the customer happy -- not at all costs, of course. :-)

Welcome to the school of hard knocks. I hope you win tonight.

Cheers, and, at worst, chalk it up to experience...

Ellis

Re: The Fat Lady has Sung

#2

Re: The Fat Lady has Sung

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Well done Alan,

You know, it's about a complicated balance. Some things teach you more than they pay, but they all have value.

I took a class a year ago with Thomas Stangeland, he said he always had 4 jobs on the go at the same time, 3 that paid and one that cost...and the one that cost always taught him more than the ones that paid.

I think it would be easy to stick with just the things you know how to do, but then when you do stretch yourself , even with the simple at first jobs, they make you a better craftsman.

Well done Buddy,

take care,

Jim

Re: The Fat Lady has Sung

#3

Phshew!

Joanne in Pt. Pleasant, PA

>Well done, Alan. You persevered and it paid off in some way, if not financially. I've been watching these posts with interest. I'm sorry I've had nothing to contribute finishing-wise. That is my least favorite part of woodworking and why I try to stick with clear finishes and letting the natural grain of the wood be the star. I'm not sure I could deal with a commission like that one. I'm glad you made it through relatively unscathed.

Re: The Fat Lady has Sung

#4

Alan - thank heavens for the Fat Lady

Howard In Toronto

>I think Ellis hit it right on.

YOU know what you're trying to say.

But it's your RESPONSIBILITY to check your client's understanding of your message.

Consistently throughout your presentation.

After that, it's up to you to manage their expectations.

Next time you bump into a variation on this Fat Ladt type of job, you'll have more insight into how top do so.

So I say congratulations on wrapping up this Fat Lady job.

Howard

Re: The Fat Lady has Sung

#5

Any trouble with customers, Joanne

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>and you could tell them you'd get Fred to flatten them out. A 32nd of an inch each time. :<)

George

Re: The Fat Lady has Sung

#6

Re: Any trouble with customers, Joanne

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>That could be plane painful George, especially if she went against the grain!!

Take care,

Jim

Re: The Fat Lady has Sung

#7

Dale Lenz

Re: The Fat Lady has Sung

Dale Lenz

>Good job Alan,

Glad you came out smelling like a rose, at least in her eyes you did. Hopefully, you will gain other sales because of her.

Re: The Fat Lady has Sung

#8

Psst! It's "Frank".

Joanne Adler in Pt. Pleasant, PA

>

Re: The Fat Lady has Sung

#9

Is George Loosing his Edge?

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>

Re: The Fat Lady has Sung

#10

Re: The Fat Lady has Sung

Thomas S Stockton

>Alan

I'm glad it all worked out.the client ended up with some nice looking tables.

Tom