Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Into the Lion's Den one more time. *LINK*

Posts

Into the Lion's Den one more time. *LINK*

#1

Alan Young

Into the Lion's Den one more time. *LINK*

Alan Young

>Well friends tonight I'll deliver the end table-The second of of two tables that have been a finishing nightmare for me.

In a post over a week ago my report was in the form of Operatic commentary. I'm too exhausted to put together another act but I have posted a series photographs showing the stages of finishing I went through. One of the real factors in the problems I encountered and created was mental and emotional fatigue. These lead to bad decision making and poor results. In one of his books James Krenov talks about making mistakes and "fixing" them. At some point you begin to convince your self it isn't a mistake and that it is actually better than the planned way. This was so true in my experience on the project.

I will be delivering this table(third time)this evening.Who knows what she'll say tonight when I deliver it. It isn't perfect. Each rejection so far has actually been one I can understand. Fuszzy finish-then wrong color-too dark etc. There are still differences in light/dark areas etc but what I have now is all I can do.

Wish me well.

Alan


General finishing sequence of events

Re: Into the Lion's Den one more time. *LINK*

#2

Re: Into the Lion's Den one more time.

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Sort of like White Line Fever eh Alan,

Nicely documented, but I feel your pain, it looked like it was going to haunt you....did you ever consider painted furniture as a way out..

:-)

Sorry for the joke, I am sure they appreciated your Perseverance...

I think some people would have just turned it around 180 degrees..

No Doze is not a wood working tool...

Take care,

Jim

Re: Into the Lion's Den one more time. *LINK*

#3

Re: Into the Lion's Den one more time.

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Your client must be rather boring. I like the first iteration.

Clint

Re: Into the Lion's Den one more time. *LINK*

#4

Alan Young

I think I'm outta the loop Jim

Alan Young

>Not sure what "White Line Fever" is??

Believe it or not my next project is a set of Painted Bookcases.

What could possibly go wrong??? :^)

I don't think they care about my trials and perseverance. I will find out tonight if they will accept this table. If they don't it and the coffee table


will probably be leaving for good.

Alan

Re: Into the Lion's Den one more time. *LINK*

#5

Alan Young

Clint- I've seen lots of great stuff you have made

Alan Young

>But it would never live in their home! One of my biggest lesson here is learning to "read" the client. If I had done a better job of understanding that from the beginning I'd have stuck to my guns and insisted upon building these tables from the anigre. It was my first suggestion as to what kind of wood to use based on the situation. I showed them an on-line image of anigre that was not very good and they just said we'll stick with the maple. That's where I should have said well It's your call but the result will likely be a blotchy look and I won't be able to change it.

Sigh. Another bit of tuition paid up to the School of Hard Knocks

Alan

Re: Into the Lion's Den one more time. *LINK*

#6

Re: Into the Lion's Den one more time.

Ernie Miller

>you may be better served to taks some blocks of wood with the finish you propose to the cliant for approval prior to finishing the commission. this will bring an end to the problem in the future. It looks good to me. I hope they are happy also.

Re: Into the Lion's Den one more time. *LINK*

#7

He Said...

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>White Line Fever Alan,

You are so focused on the line of getting it done that you sometimes forget the bigger picture, just another way of saying what you said that Krenov said, who ever said what ever they said...you know...what I said??

:-)

Take care,

Jim

Re: Into the Lion's Den one more time. *LINK*

#8

Just remember who won.

Charles R. Smith from Victoria

>A long time ago, one of my heroes went into the lion's den -- I hope you have the same experience that he did. As I recall, the final score was Daniel 1 and Lions 0. I watched a cute cartoon with my kids, based on that story: it finished with Daniel and the lions standing around eating pizza. Shall we hope that your clients from Hades are so impressed with your work that they invite you to share their food and drink?

Charles in Victoria (who has been on an African safari but didn't eat pizza with the big cats)

Re: Into the Lion's Den one more time. *LINK*

#9

Alan Young

Ah Yes. I get it... ..:^)

Alan Young

>

Re: Into the Lion's Den one more time. *LINK*

#10

Re: Just remember who won.

Thomas S Stockton

>Yea those cartoons are cute until you've sat through them 20 times.

Daad! you need to watch, not read the paper.

Glad my som likes some of the same movies I like.

Tom

Re: Into the Lion's Den one more time. *LINK*

#11

Alan Young

Re: Just remember who won.

Alan Young

>Charles, my appetite has been down somewhat lately but I am trusting for a similar fate and will look forward to a good meal-with my family though!

Alan

Re: Into the Lion's Den one more time. *LINK*

#12

Ellis Walentine

Ah, but Alan...

Ellis Walentine

>... maple is a great wood, able to be stained, dyed, glazed, finished, etc. without blotching, assuming correct procedures are used, so I don't think you can justifiably shift the blame to the choice of wood -- which is exactly how the client will take your claim. Better to admit that the finishing process got corrupted somehow and that you're there to give them what they want.

The way to have prevailed with your recommendation of anigre would have been to show them a sample of anigre finished exactly as you planned to deliver it to them. If they thought it was a good choice, they would have given you the green light and you could have done what you really wanted to do to begin with. But, it's also your job as the contractor to deliver a quality product regardless of the species they specify. Here again, this would have given you a chance to try to duplicate the look of their existing maple furniture. If you couldn't duplicate it, you probably should have found a finisher who could, or declined the project in that species.

The corollary to "the customer is always right" is that the customer most often doesn't have a clue as to what he/she's talking about or comprehending. You're the woodworker. It's your job to schmooze the customer and show them what their options really are: this wood, that finish, etc. Personal meetings and actual samples are so important to keep everyone on the same page. Bluelines and technical descriptions are worthless if the customer doesn't like the finished project. You may have the better argument in court or at an arbitration hearing, but that doesn't mean you'll get paid. It's best to keep the customer happy -- not at all costs, of course. :-)

Welcome to the school of hard knocks. I hope you win tonight.

Cheers, and, at worst, chalk it up to experience...

Ellis

Re: Into the Lion's Den one more time. *LINK*

#13

Re: Into the Lion's Den one more time.

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Allan,

Sometimes when the engine stops and smoke is filling the cockpit, and your feet are on fire, you have to consider jettisoning the aircraft.

George