Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Scroll Saw Recommendations

Posts

Scroll Saw Recommendations

#1

Scroll Saw Recommendations

Greg Haugen

>Hello. As some of you may know me, I've been a woodturner for the last two years. I recently sold EVERYTHING. I became really burnt out and was in need of a change. I'm looking to "switch" gears and get into scrolling. I was wondering if anyone could recommend a good saw. I've done some research but I know the best information usually comes from those doing it.

Thanks for any info,

Greg H.

Re: Scroll Saw Recommendations

#2

Re: Scroll Saw Recommendations

Jim Swank

>The best bang for the buck is probably the Dewalt. I've had an RBI for better than 10 years with little problem other than the upper blade holder, which they changed on the newer saws. I've also had the chance to cut on an Ellipse. It is the smoothest saw I ever used, but seems like blade changes for fretwork would be a bit slow and awkward.

If you can, try to attend one of the several scrollsaw picnics and try several. Some of the manufacturers will be running specials at most of the picnics.

And contact Mike at http://mikesworkshop.com for the best blades I have found.

Re: Scroll Saw Recommendations

#3

Re: Scroll Saw Recommendations *LINK*

Terry Quiram

>Greg

If you are going to spend a lot of time scrolling then the only saw I can recommend is Eclispe. Every claim made by the Eclispe is true. I went through 2 Hengers before buying an Eclispe. The difference is amazing. If you are close to me (Central Illinois) drop by and test drive.

Terry


Eclispe

Re: Scroll Saw Recommendations

#4

DeWalt DW788

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I'm not sure how it compares to the $1000+ scroll saws, but for under $400 it's much superior to any of the others less than $300 range.

It's made/designed in Canada, by a company that makes high end scroll saws (Excaliber????).

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Scroll Saw Recommendations

#5

Re: DeWalt DW788

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

>Another vote for the DeWalt. Again I haven't compared it to the expensive saws but in the "affordable" price range it is the best IMHO.

I have had one for several years and don't regret buying it one bit.

Howard

Re: Scroll Saw Recommendations

#6

Re: Scroll Saw Recommendations

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>Greg,

A friend of mine owns a Dewalt DW788, and I have a Dremel Scroll station, model 1800. We've compared the two saws to each other, and personally liked either. So did my friend. Both are good saws, but if you like saving money, the Dremel can be bought for about $210-220. One of the things I like about the Dremel is the power-take-off/sander station on the right side of the saw. You can hook up Dremels flex shaft to it, chuck in a drill bit, and you're ready to saw away, never having to run to the drill press to drill your starter holes. Below is a clock I did using my Dremel. Close to 250 hrs without a problem!

Ron in Iowa


img

Re: Scroll Saw Recommendations

#7

Re: Scroll Saw Recommendations

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>Greg,

Nearly forgot- make sure you buy a scrollsaw that utilizes pinless blades! Time will come that you want to do some real intricate fret work, and you won't be able to get the pinned end into the small starter holes that some of this type of work requires. DAMHIKT.

Ron in Iowa

Re: Scroll Saw Recommendations

#8

Re: DeWalt DW788 *LINK*

JanManuel

>Actually, the DeWalt saw is no longer made in Canada. Production was taken to China several years ago. However, I've used the newer DeWalt saws and they seem to be ok.

My DeWalt is almost 10 yrs old now and serves me well. I cut everything from delicate fretwork to Corian with it.

The other saw worth a good look is the Excalibur EX-21 sold by Seyco. It's a bit more $$$ than the DeWalt, but is a good choice.

Beware the waiting time on the Eclipse. A friend of mine waited many months to get hers.


http://www.seyco.com/

Re: Scroll Saw Recommendations

#9

Holy Cow!! Very Nice!!

Greg Haugen

>

Re: Scroll Saw Recommendations

#10

Re: Scroll Saw Recommendations

CharlesYawn

>Greg, my vote goes with the DeWalt, too. Had mine for a few years now and am satisfied. Charles

Re: Scroll Saw Recommendations

#11

Re: Scroll Saw Recommendations *LINK*

Ken Platt

>I found a scrollsaw forum when I was considering getting one for some small projects. I never quite got around to making the purchase, but had also heard that the DeWalt was a very good saw for the price range.

Ken


http://www.scrollsawer.com/forum/scroll-saw/

Re: Scroll Saw Recommendations

#12

Eclipse

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>I've had the opportunity to run a fair number of saws and thought the DeWalt was a nice saw for the money. But, if money is no object look at the Eclipse, a very very nice saw.

Ray