Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

brush/wipe/spray on poly, which one? (long)

Posts

brush/wipe/spray on poly, which one? (long)

#1

brush/wipe/spray on poly, which one? (long)

MN deepwoods (Dave)

>I installed a bank of base cabinets in my kitchen. To provide more drawer space for my wife I added two more drawers on top, built a pre-finished matching carcass and am about to add 3" of pre-finished clear coat covered maple to the drawer fronts to adequately cover the larger drawer openings.

I bought pre-made drawers and am adding 3" of depth to them. This seemed quicker than building them from scratch. I'm jointing down the 1/8" radius edge on the drawer front's top, adding my 3" piece of stock with biscuits and will round over the 'new' top of the drawer front with another 1/8" radius. Now I need to protect the raw wood, and make it match the rest of the drawer.

What would be the recommend method of finishing up the raw portions of this new drawer front. I've only ever used brush on poly. Would a rub on poly work better here or do I need to strip down and sand the whole face and just poly it all as one piece?

TIA DWDave

Re: brush/wipe/spray on poly, which one? (long)

#2

Re: brush/wipe/spray on poly, which one? (long)

Chuck Lenz

>If it was me I'd strip and sand it down. A can of spray would probably do the trick.

Re: brush/wipe/spray on poly, which one? (long)

#3

Ellis Walentine

Hmm. Tough call.

Ellis Walentine

>It sounds like you're trying to match a finish into some prefinished drawer front that you have extended. That is a very unlikely scenario. I'm with Chuck on this one, that you should probably sand the entire extended front down to bare wood and then finish it all with the same finish. The problem that this doesn't address is how to match the finish to the rest of the carcases.

Regarding the difference between wipe-on and brush-on polyurethane, my take is that they only differ in their solvent mix and their solids content. That is, you can wipe a varnish that is thin enough.

Ellis

Re: brush/wipe/spray on poly, which one? (long)

#4

and sometimes not even that

Michael Dresdner

>Ellis wrote:

"Regarding the difference between wipe-on and brush-on polyurethane, my take is that they only differ in their solvent mix and their solids content."

Possibly, but often the only difference is that formulators will swap out some higher molecular weight resins for lower ones. Thus the solids content stays the same but the viscosity drops. Another strategy is to go the opposite direction and create a wipe on gel, often with the exact same solids content as a liquid polyurethane. I have in my shop three different materials -- a Danish oil, a brushable polyurethane, and a wipe on gel polyurethane -- that are all the same solids content.