Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Staining question?

Posts

Staining question?

#1

JL

Staining question?

JL

>I've been asked to "duplicate" this stain as best I can for a project.

By all appearances, it is a "white" stain on red oak. I was figuring on using a white stain and maybe glazing it to duplicate the color.

Or should I just use a white stain and use the "color" of the finish to darken/yellow it up a little?

Here is a picture of the stain.


img

Re: Staining question?

#2

Re: Staining question?

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>JL,

Every computer monitor displays colors differently, but IF (and thats a big IF) mine is close to the real thing, I'd say it's been pickled. Someone else on here might see something different. I'd say experiment on some scrap to see how close you can get using different stains, whitewash milk paint, etc. Good Luck!

Ron in Iowa

Re: Staining question?

#3

Ellis Walentine

Even worse...

Ellis Walentine

>Pickling is an inexact science, to say the least. You can pickle wood with pigments, dyes, paints and whatever else will yield that ghostly look. To boot, white is never white. Pickled finishes are always leaning to the blue, pink or yellow spectrums.

Now, add a glaze to this confusion, and you have a recipe for hair-pulling.

All I can say is to try some samples and don't give up until you find the right combination.

Ellis

Re: Staining question?

#4

Alan Young

I'm an expert

Alan Young

>in screwing up a "please match this finish" job.

I'd run Run RUn RUN! FAR AWAY!!!!

Listen to Ellis. Make lots and lots of samples till the customer signs and dates it.

Alan

Re: Staining question?

#5

Re: Staining question?

Thomas S Stockton

>The pickled white look is hard, my best try was to seal first I used vinyl sealer but shellac would work and then go over it with a glaze or stain. Glazes are just heavy bodied stains. I used stuff from mohawk but I bet a whiteish stain from the big box store would work.

I find it is easier to sub stuff like this out to a finisher and let it be there problem and pass the cost onto the client.

Tom

Re: Staining question?

#6

Re: I'm an expert

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Evening JL and Alan,

Several times in the past few years, I have been tasked by my #3 son as well as his former employer to duplicate finishes/match existing cabinets. I even had to duplicate an existing Pogenpol (European) cabinet door for my own client, because the line had been discontinued by the manufacturer.

All I can say is that its a real bear, and nothing is guaranteed. I've been successful after many hours of experimentation which the high end customers were willing to pay for. I recognize I've been pretty fortunate applying some knoiwledge, but must admit luck was also on my side. My advice is don't get too involved unless is is worth your while and you have lots of hours to tinker with results. You can get involved with texture, grain of imported woods, dyes and stains, colors and shades, and paint/glazes, and various top coats.

George

Re: Staining question?

#7

Re: Geeze, Ellis-Didn't want to scare the guy!

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>

Re: Staining question?

#8

Yes

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>

Re: Staining question?

#9

That is not a bad place to start.

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>If you want an alternative here is what I would do. Make a test board maybe 4 or so inches wide by 3 or 4 feet long. Mark it off in 5 or 6 inch increments. First I would put on a coat of thin shellac over the whole lenth, maybe a 1# cut. Then I would get some white latex and rag it on the first 6 inches to match the way the original was done. Last I would put on my clear coar of choice, put it in the sun for a few days and compare to the original. I use SW a lot so I would go back and have them tint my white base in the direction needed and make another 6 inch sample. Keep making samples then until you dial in the right shade.

Ray

Re: Staining question?

#10

Pickled? I don't think so.

Michael Dresdner

>Maybe it is my monitor but that sure as hell does not look like a pickled finish to me, and it certainly does not look like pickling on oak, a process that whitens the pores and the recesses. Instead, it looks like the semi-transparent toner finish common to early telecasters. It is done by spraying lacquer that has been laced with a very modest amount of white pigment so that you are spraying transluscent white. The giveaway is that the high spots are whiter than the recesses in the carvings. Again, you can't tell much from a photo via a computer monitor, but that's my immediate reaction.

Re: Staining question?

#11

Re: Staining question?

DB

>If were me I would take a sample to Daly's Paint and finishes. They can match anything that you bring them. They will even tell you how to do the job.

Re: Staining question?

#12

Best advice...

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>is for you to get pickled.

Clint

Re: Staining question?

#13

JL

Re: Wine, beer or what? :)....

JL

>the only other pickling I'm doing nowadays is watermelon pickle and sweet cucumber pickle.