Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Dyes or stains?

Posts

Dyes or stains?

#1

Dyes or stains?

Marv

>Been reading about dyes for wood instead of stains such as MinWax for example. From what I've read, dyes are the way to go. I'm leaning toward the water soluble type. Any opinions or experience? Thank you.....Marv

Re: Dyes or stains?

#2

Re: Dyes or stains?

Tony - Memphis

>That's all I use. I use the Lockwood brand. Very easy to use. You can play with the concentration to get the color you want. You can also combine colors to get a look. It may take some experimenting to get the color you want. I get mine from Lee Valley or directly from Lockwood.

Tony

Re: Dyes or stains?

#3

Re: Dyes or stains?

David Yoho

>Marv, I don't believe there's a "one way" to color wood that would be the best way every time. Both dyes and pigmented stains have their own advantages. I think it really depends on the wood species or desired effect as to which is best to use. I've even used both before to achieve a desired match on a refinished table top. Learning which to use and why will enhance your finishing and become "tools" you can use on future projects.

David

Re: Dyes or stains?

#4

Re: Dyes or stains?

Marv

>Thanks David,

I'm specifically dealing with trying to match wood colors between old wood and new wood. I restore and repair old handsaws. Often times the horns are damaged or missing so I use new wood for the repairs, mostly Applewood. I strip the old wood down to the bare surface and then add the new wood. Even when using old wood for the repairs, the wood won't match. Applewood varies tremendously in color and grain formation.

My experience with using pigmented stains has been, well, not good. It just doesn't want to penatrate the dense tight grain of Applewood.

Can water soluble dyes be mixed with say Boiled Linseed Oil? Can you use the dyes after sealing the wood with BLO? I'm thinking maybe doing the dyeing and sealing at the same time.

TIA,

Marv

Re: Dyes or stains?

#5

Bart Goldberg

Re: Dyes or stains?

Bart Goldberg

>Generally, if you apply any sort of top coat prior to applying a dye, it will inhibit the dye from penetrating the wood. Sometimes this is desirable depending upon how much of the dye you want to penetrate. Most of the time I apply dyes to bare wood, then seal the wood with shellac. Then apply other finishing products (like glazing for example to create a contrasting color that just fills the pores) before applying my top coat.

Hope this helps

Bart

Re: Dyes or stains?

#6

Re: Dyes or stains?

Dave Arbuckle, Plano, TX

>Can water soluble dyes be mixed with say Boiled Linseed Oil? Can you use the dyes after sealing the wood with BLO? I'm thinking maybe doing the dyeing and sealing at the same time.

Oil and water don't mix, but some dyes can be mixed into BLO with more or less trouble. Transtints will, after first cutting with acetone, IIRC.

Recommend not doing that, it's a lot harder to control the color than if you keep everything separate. Please note that dyes must have sealer over them, unprotected they won't look good nor last.

Re: Dyes or stains?

#7

Re: Dyes or stains?

Marv

>Thanks Dave,

I read that there's a dye that is made to be mixed with an oil. Have you tried any of those? I think Lockwood makes it.

I'm guessing though, that the oil type dyes won't penetrate as well.

Marv

Re: Dyes or stains?

#8

Dye is Stain

Howard Acheson

>Not to pick on you but in the interest of using the correct terms, dye is type of stain. The other primary type of stain is pigment. Most premixed store bought stains are pigment stains. Minwax Oil stain is a combination of dye and pigment but most oil stains are exclusively pigment.

So, dye is one type of stain and pigment is another type stain.

Dye stains are absorbed into the wood and do not obscure the grain. Pigment stains sit on top of the wood or lodge in nooks and crannies.

Re: Dyes or stains?

#9

Re: Dyes or stains?

David Yoho

>Marv, you are correct in thinking a dye is the right choice for dense close-grained wood like you're using. I believe I'd stay away from trying to mix water soluble dyes with Boiled Linseed Oil.

If you plan to use water soluble dyes, I'd find the color or combination of colors that match the best and apply them alone first. After it dries, try applying your BLO. Whenever I've applied an oil finish over a dye, I usually make the color outcome a little darker than needed to compensate for what is removed when applying the oil. It seems to lighten just a bit from wiping on the oil.

It's always wise to try this on a test piece first to see if it works like you want.

David

Re: Dyes or stains?

#10

Re: Dye is Stain

Marv

>Hi Howard,

It bugs me too when people don't use the correct terms. I guess that dyes are stains but stains (pigment) are not dyes. I just assume that people who are familiar with the subject will know what I mean. Thank you for the lesson.

Marv

Re: Dyes or stains?

#11

Re: Dyes or stains?

Dave Arbuckle, Plano, TX

>Dyes that are actually made to be dispersed into oil are called oil-soluable dyes, and yes Lockwood does have them in their line. They need to be dissolved into mineral spirits or similar chemical before being introduced into the oil. I recommend against doing this because it will be difficult in my opinion to get a good match against the existing wood, easier to separate the functions of color application and sealing. Do please note that dye when wet looks like it does under sealer, when it's dry it color shifting and generally looks terrible.

With regards Howard's comments about terminology, I think you have it sorted out. General categories of colorants include dyes, pigments, and chemicals (like ammonia, lye, and potassium dichromate), all of which are stains.