Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Finishing Question...

Posts

Finishing Question...

#1

Finishing Question...

Rob Hix - King George, VA

>Hey all,

I think this project has produced more finsihing questions for me than ever.

Now that I have a few coats of polyurethane on, there are some places that, when I sand between coats, look like the stain never soaked in. The place manifests itself as about a 1.5 - 2" wide band of lighter wood. When I put a new coat of polyurethane on, It blends it in with the surrounding wood, so it is not a problems.

The big problem is when I am finished and I want to rub-out the topcoats. Even the slightest bit of sanding will cause the streak. I am worried that it will show up after the final rub out.

First of all, what could be causing this?

Second, my last coat of polyurethane went on realt smooth. It hardly needs sanding except around the grain pattern. Do I really need to sand between coats, or can I just put on my last two poly coats and rub-out at the end.

Sorry this is so long, but thanks for the input,

Rob Hix

Re: Finishing Question...

#2

JL

Re: Finishing Question...

JL

>For polyurethane, I almost always sand between coats. One, it knocks down the "nibs" that occasionally stick up. Two, it promotes adhesion between coats.

Some finishes partially "dissolve" the outer part of a coat and blend in that way. Polyurethane has some rather large chains and once the initial load of solvent from a coat evaporates, it is difficult to redissolve. Just my opinion.

Re: Finishing Question...

#3

Re: Finishing Question...

Dave in Haverford PA

>Rob: What grade sandpaper are you using? I would suggest 320 or XXXX steel wool - it doesn't take much to give the next coat a grip. Don't why you want ot rub out the last coat unless it's to achieve a satin (non-gloss) finish. If satin is what you want I would use satin poly. Incidentally, I use foam brushes for poly - flows great and there are no brush marks or nibs. Good luck!

Re: Finishing Question...

#4

Re: Finishing Question...

Rob Hix - King George, VA

>Amen to the foam brushes. All this time I thought I was getting tons of dust in my finish from the shop. Turns out the tons of dust I was getting was from the rags I was using. Even ran the rags through a few wash and dry cycles this time and it was still happening. I used a foam brush to apply my thinned poly last night and man do those sides and shelves look and FEEL good.

I thought I might need to rub-out due to the little roughness I am feeling over the open grain portions of the wood. I have not tested to see if the rub-out will even help there.

Thanks for the input,

Rob Hix

Re: Finishing Question...

#5

Re: Finishing Question...

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>My guess would be you are sanding through at that spot. Not getting enough build with one coat and you go right through it. If putting on a new coat brings the right color then I would put on 2 or 3 coats (thinned) on that area before sanding. If it needs staining I would wipe lightly with a stain rag to even the color then put on the coats of poly. Letting the stain dry first of course.

My poly routine, right or wrong, is as follows. 3 coats of wiped on poly thinned about 30% with naptha, each coat about 6-8 hours apart. Let dry 24-48 hours and lightly sand with P400. 3 more coats of the same mix, dry, and sand with P800. A couple of more coats, dry and rub out. If I want more build I do the first step as many times as needed to get the desired build.

Ray

Re: Finishing Question...

#6

Re: Finishing Question...

Paul Dwight

>As long as you don't wait more than a day or so to apply a new coat, the new coat should adhere to the prior coat whether or not you scuff-sand in between. If a couple of days go by before you can recoat, you'll probably need to scuff-sand with 320 to be sure the new coat adheres to the prior coat.

If your last coat isn't more than a day old and doesn't have defects that need to be sanded out, go ahead and brush on another coat without sanding.

If the surface over the open grain parts of the wood feels rough after every coat of finish, it's likely that you're feeling the grain of the wood, itself, and not an irregularity in the finish. If you didn't like the look or feel of the open grain, the easiest thing would have been to use a paste wood filler before you started putting on topcoats. It is possible to get a smooth surface by filling the open pores with finish, but it's a lot of work and polyurethane is a poor choice for this purpose. Basically, the process involves putting on 4-6 coats of finish and then sanding most of it off in order to leave a level film over the entire surface. If you still have enough film thickness after sanding, you can polish the sheen back up (otherwise you apply another coat of finish). Polyurethane is a poor choice for this technique because you'll get witness lines as you sand through each coat of finish, and because it's hard to sand, and because it's not easy to polish. Shellac or lacquer are the traditional choices for this technique.

If you're happy with the look and feel of the finish except for the slight roughness over the open grain areas, I would probably live with it the way it is. Trying to get a perfectly smooth surface over the open grain areas at this point would be a lot of work and might not give you a good result.

Good luck! -- Paul