Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Router bit question?

Posts

Router bit question?

#1

JL

Router bit question?

JL

>I am making a table. The router bit that I would like to use for edging has a large diameter of 2 1/4". Obviously I'm going to use it at low (10,000 rpm) speed.

Due to the size of the piece, it would be a big PITA to wrestle this about on a router table. Therefore I was planning on doing this one with the table top clamped to my workbench. Should I reconsider this and do it on my router table? TIA

BTW - I'd be using my PC 891.

Re: Router bit question?

#2

Re: Router bit question?

Robert R Clough - Thorncraft

>I would never use a bit that large freehand.

Re: Router bit question?

#3

Re: Router bit question?

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>I've done it, just make sure you have an escape route in case stuff happens. As usual if the operation makes you to nervous, don't do it.

Ray

Re: Router bit question?

#4

Re: Router bit question?

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Evening JL,

It should work okay if you are able to make several passes and the piece is well secured.

George

Re: Router bit question?

#5

Re: Router bit question?

Barry Irby

>About two months ago I put a "thumb" molding on a table. The bit had to be 2 1/4 or 2 1/2" and had a guide bearing. I did it with a hand held router (PC plunge router) and it was a breeze. Did it in two passes, but I think one would have been fine. The bit was carbide, new and sharp. I also put a quarter inch radius on the underside of the same top. A small bearing guided bit and I cranked the router up to full speed for that. About the same "scary factor".

I did use an offset base on the router. Mine was homemade and just a piece of quarter inch plywood attached to the base with the base screws. If you make one, be sure you put the offset handle on the side away from the trigger if your router uses a trigger switch. That way one hand can hold the base firmly on the table and the other can fire up the router. My base was a little flimsy (tippy) and I'm not convinced it was much of a help. A sturdier one would be nice.

Re: Router bit question?

#6

Re: Router bit question?

JKJ in East TN

>Sounds scary! Got any shops around that could do this for you?

To increase stability, I might construct an extra large router baseplate to be supported by the table, sort of like an inverted router table. In fact, I might even try to create a fixture all around the edges with mdf or ply surface built up to the exact thickness of the table top to help support the other side of the router, leaving a "channel" for the bit. In this case, the whole thing might be best done on the floor if the table top is large.

I'm not sure lowering the speed would make a difference in safety.

JKJ

Re: Router bit question?

#7

JL

Re: Thanks...

JL

>I'll go ahead and either use an offset attached to the router base or have some support clamped to the workbench.

Re: Router bit question?

#8

Re: Router bit question?

Bill Hammond, Oregon Coast

>real question is...How strong are you hands, arms and back? If the router decides to take a jump are you going to be able to control it?

bill

Re: Router bit question?

#9

JL

Re: Hopefully strong enough :)...

JL

>

Re: Router bit question?

#10

NO!

Jerry Nicholson

>You might be able to handle a bit that size (I wouldn't try it myself but I am old and decrepit) but I don't think that PC 891 is anywhere near heavy enough for that operation. You need one of the so-called "3 hp" routers, not because you need more power but because they weigh a lot more and are sturdier.

I tried edging a tabletop with a table mounted router (much smaller bit though) and caused enough damage to the table edge that it took several hours (and a small patch) to fix it.

Jerry

Re: Router bit question?

#11

Bart Goldberg

Only in a Router Table!

Bart Goldberg

>

Re: Router bit question?

#12

Re: Router bit question?

Scott Whiting - Glendale, AZ

>"I'm not sure lowering the speed would make a difference in safety."

Yes it will. One of the reasons for speed ratings on larger bits is the carbide is only able to handle impact up to certain speeds. The farther from the center of the bit the cutter gets the faster it moves so you need to lower the speed to help keep the carbide from shattering apart.

Scott

Scott's Sharpening Service

Re: Router bit question?

#13

If your real name is not Magilla Gorilla..........

Art Silva

>with arms to match, then I seriously caution you not to try this.

Re: Router bit question?

#14

JL

Re: I'll try it with scrap first..

JL

>and see how I do. I wouldn't mind having a larger router (3+ hp), but it isn't in the budget right now. I'd rather have a cabinet saw first.

I'll try it freehand with the piece clamped to my bench, with supporting wood helping me keep the router level. If that doesn't work, I'll try it on my router table. I have enough plywood to build a shelf around the router table.