Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

Posts

Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

#1

Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

Joanne Adler in Pt. Pleasant, PA

>Welcome to the Design Chat Room. Well, sort of�I get to chat and you get to listen/read. :-)

A while ago I posted the cherry table I built for my parents for this past winter�s holiday gift. For my sister, I built a large jewelry cabinet. She has an extensive collection and tends to keep things in their boxes or in little zip lock bags to prevent tarnishing. So she needs a lot of room. No little 8�x 10� dresser-top box for her! Now, my sister is not your typical, conventional kind �o� gal. She is artsy and funky and not into symmetrical lines. I knew I could NOT make a box like this traditional Pennsylvania Spice Box that I made for my mother a few years ago.


So even though I designed a cabinet with two columns of drawers, with each drawer the same size as the others in its column, I knew I had to do something different. Warning�to some eyes, this may seem a bit much and busy. I used a lot of different woods for drawerfronts. But my sister was thrilled. And that was the whole point.

With every thing I build, I try to learn something new and try a technique or skill I have not used before, as well as practice and work to improve other skills. This box is full of �firsts�. I�ve joined panels before, but I don�t believe I have mixed wood species in doing so. I thought using all walnut might make the piece too dark, so I added maple. These are also my first raised panels.




To �hang� the drawers, I used runners and grooves in the drawer sides�that was also new to me. While I have cut dovetails by hand, and half-blind dovetails by hand, before, I have not done quite so many. There are nine drawers here; that�s a lot of dovetails! The drawerfronts are walnut, cherry, maple, and ambrosia maple. To line the drawers, I cut oaktag or posterboard a little smaller than the drawer bottoms, put a piece of foam on top and covered them with a piece of blue ultrasuede fabric. The hot glue gun works great for such tasks.




Since the basic box and drawers were so rectangular and �regular�, I added some curves to the top. It started out more asymmetrical than it wound up, but it works okay. One of the gifts I received from my sister last year was a Dremel Engraver, I�ve been trying to use that to sign my work and write the date and species used.



Since space is at a premium in my sister�s apartment and there is no dresser space available for such a big box (footprint is about 21� x 12�; it�s 19� tall), I knew I needed to build a stand or table. I was picturing something like a Krenov cabinet on an open stand, like this picture from the web.


I wanted to try to incorporate some of the curves from the top in the legs. I made a prototype out of cherry and maple. I was going to use some through tenons and peg them. But before I tried sculpting curves into the stretchers and trimming the tenons and adding pegs, I decided I didn�t like the stand. I didn�t know what to do with it. I�ll be brave�here it is (or �was�):


Master Craftsmen Thomas Skaggs and James Shaver to the rescue!

I sent them some pics and asked what they�d do. Jim said to taper the legs on at least 2 sides, perhaps 4. Or even better, on 6 sides and make them hexagonal. Hmmm. That sounded interesting; I�ve done 2-side tapered legs. It would be a challenge to do all 4 or to try to do 6. Tommy said he didn�t like the open stand at all and would do something more like a table. He suggested tapered legs also, and making a tabletop that would be the same shape as the cabinet top. Aha! Now that made a lot of sense! He ever-so-kindly included �a really bad sketch� (as he put it). Happily for me, Tommy�s really bad sketch is far nicer than any of my really good sketches. I balked at having to figure out angled stretchers, so he came up with a way to avoid that and stick with 90� angles for my mortise and tenon joints.

Here is what I came up with. I was able to reuse most of my maple stretchers. But it was �off to the sawmill� for some more 8/4 stock for legs. I tried using Golden Mean to keep proportions nice. It may not appear so in the photos; angles are weird in the shop. The table parts are still in the finishing stage, so in these photos, the top is not screwed on. Nor is the cabinet attached to the tabletop (which it may never be, since it is so big and heavy, it is not going to go anywhere). Yes, the rear legs are closer together than the front legs. Each leg is tapered on its two inside faces (bandsawn and cleaned up with handplanes and spokeshave).




I think it came out much nicer than what I might have come up with on shaping the open stand. And it forced me to go get more 8/4 walnut and make the stand out of walnut and maple (like the main cabinet), instead of the 8/4 cherry I�d had on hand for the open stand�this looks better. There are some things I might have �tweaked� on this stand, but I�m sort of anxious to finish and move on. I learned a lot about a lot of things on this project. I got to use a lot of hand tools, too. I had a piece of walnut for the tabletop that was wide enough without needing a glueup. My jointer can flatten a 16� board (go Frank!), but my planer will only take a 12� board. I pulled out my No. 7 Bailey jointer plane and flattened that second side by hand. Phshew! What a workout! I have new and infinite respect for the folks who do most of their work with hand tools!

I know my sister will love this piece (well, 2 pieces). I think I will love finally seeing it leave my shop! I�m ready for my next project and to learn some new things! Huge cyber hugs to Tom and Jim for their generosity with their brilliant ideas, time, and support.

Re: Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

#2

Dale Lenz

Re: Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

Dale Lenz

>What can I say, I'm Very Impressed. Bravo! Bravo!

Re: Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

#3

I like them both!

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>Wow, your sister sure is lucky! That's A LOT of work in those two pieces. Real nice job on the stand and...I don't know how you had the patience/perserverance to hand cut all of those drawer dovetails. I would developed A.D.D. on the 2nd or 3rd drawer.

Re: Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

#4

Re: Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

Angus Barclay, in New Zealand

>Hello Joanne,

I reckon you've made a spectacular looking piece.

If I was making this (and I hope use it as inspiration one day) I would go for straight-sided table and cabinet tops, fewer woods, and the rear legs slightly further apart (but still closer together than than the front).

Even though the use of so many different woods doesn't appeal to me, there are a lot of design elements in this piece that I really like. I'm impressed with the combination of stand and chest, the proportions of the drawers in relation to each other, the placement of the vertical divider between the drawers, the proportions of the back panel with its contrasting stripes, the way the stretchers tie into each other as well as the legs, and the way you've matched the cabinet top with the table top.

Have you got any photos of it during construction?

regards

Angus Barclay

Re: Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

#5

JL

Re: Sweet! Are the drawers interchangeable?

JL

>So if she wants to change them around for a different look, she could?

I really like the 2nd stand. It adds a lot to the piece.

Re: Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

#6

Re: Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Joanne,

What a great post and the cabinet and stand look wonderful.

I was only kidding about a six or eight sidded leg, but the off set staggered legs look perfect!!

You have made a lot of design choices here as well by experimentation and also by SEEING design in other people's work. I really think that your incorperation of these combinations has taught you a lot about scale, balance and the challenge of making them work together.

So many great details from the HCDT side hung drawers, to the raised panel back, to the mirrored design in the top and bottom of the cabinet...my favorite is the base.

This experimanet has been a great project for you and I know that as you continue to SEE, that your work will also continue to grow in it's satisfaction, WELL DONE!!

Take care,

Jim

Re: Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

#7

Have you lost your mind woman? ;-)

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I didn't think you would actually act on any of my hair brained suggestions! But hey, it sure turned out nice. I think the bottom panel really helps compliment the top. And even better, you were able to learn a lot of new tricks with this project.

Well done!! Bravo!

Tom

PS..rave and gush.

Re: Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

#8

You need to meet my sister

Joanne Adler in Pt. Pleasant, PA

>to understand the choices in woods and shapes! Then all would be clear, Angus. If I were making this for anyone else, I would also use fewer woods and straighter lines. I look forward to seeing what your cabinet would look like; by all means, use whatever parts tickle your design fancy.

Alas, no shots of it during construction. Sorry. I need to start remembering to document the building process.

Re: Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

#9

Alan Young

Re: Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

Alan Young

>Joanne,

What a great Post! The mix of elements is a step out into the bold but that final version of the stand really ties everything together. The different spacing of the front vs back legs is a great look.

Wow. Thanks for the story. I'm sure your "artsy and funky" sister will be thrilled.

Alan

Re: Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

#10

Re: Sweet! Are the drawers interchangeable?

Joanne Adler in Pt. Pleasant, PA

>Sort of. While I used spacer blocks to try to get the drawers evenly spaced, it didn't work out perfectly (accuracy is one of those elusive skills I'm working on!). Most drawers will slide into any socket in their column, but they don't necessarily look better there. But I love the interchanging drawer idea and I'll bet my sister will think of it, too.

Re: Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

#11

Thanks, guys

Joanne Adler in Pt. Pleasant, PA

>Jim--"8 sided"??!! I don't remember THAT suggestion. If I had seen that, I'd have known you were kidding! Or crazier than I am, which would be difficult. :-)

Sir Thomas--no modesty, now. This cohesive element catching Alan and everyone's eye is your table design idea. So I thank you once again.

Re: Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

#12

Re: Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>Beautiful Job, Joanne! I'm impressed!

Ron in Iowa

Re: Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

#13

Re: Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

Bri in Mtl

>I like them, like them a lot in fact. But only as 2 different and separate pieces. They don't compliment each other imho.

Despite the top of the cabinet being the same as the table top it still looks(to me) like a cabinet that someone left on a table.

All my personal opinion of course.

Re: Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

#14

very nice, eclectic

Mark Valsi

>Nice Job

Re: Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

#15

Re: Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

Don Orr

>Beautiful work Joanne ! I really like the variety of woods for the drawer fronts and I LOVE the mixed species raised panels-gorgeous! The final stand completes the piece wonderfully.

Re: Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

#16

I Bought The Identical Piece At K-Mart..

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Joanne,

....or was it Ikea?

Joanne, you don't do anything by half measures. That jewelry chest is beautiful: a work of art and an object of total thoughtfulness. What sister wouldn't be thrilled by it, and the effort which went into it? I hope you are making this a Shop Shot. Its gorgeous.

George

Re: Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

#17

You have a Very Lucky Sister :)

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Joanne you should be so proud of this piece. So many challenges and new tricks to add to your arsenal. What a feat of accomplishment. Your sister is going to be blown away by this incredible gift. I love the way that you incorporated the top of the cabinet with the top of the table. It's a great look and really anchors the cabinet to the base. I think in the cherry stand it almost looked like you were holding the top portion and hunting for a place to set the box and that's the place that you found! Don't take that the wrong way! The cherry stand will be perfect for another project :)...that is testimony to you seeing beyond the cherry stand, and doing what many of us do by saying "that's good enough".I think it's fantastic that you pushed further and created something even more connected to the cabinet. I can't even imagine how your sister's heart is going to feel the moment you present her with this gift from yours. Bravo girl! I'm so thrilled to have seen it up close and in person :)

Jen

Re: Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

#18

Re: Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

GolfSteve in Calgary

>Beautiful job, Joanne. You turned to the right people for help with the base; I agree that the first base just wasn't right.

Re: Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

#19

Ellis Walentine

Very nice, Joanne

Ellis Walentine

>What an interesting set of design decisions you made. Thanks for the stream-of-consciousness details of your process. You put almost as much work into your post as you did into the piece itself. (Not!:-)

Remind me to show you a trick for hanging this type of drawer.

Congrats on a very lovely and ambitious piece. It seems your most involved work is for your family and friends. That is very generous of you.

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

#20

Re: Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

Andy Lincoln,In Dearborn MI

>Joanne,

That looks really funky:-)And I mean it is a good way.I like the ecclectic style,it matches my brain quite well.Your work is an inspiration for all of us to continue to think out side the box.

Andy

Re: Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

#21

Joanne, what beautiful work and

Fred West in West Chester, PA

>what a very lucky sister. She and my sister should meet as they sound identical. :o) Truly great work. Fred

Re: Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

#22

Colonel, Shhhhhh!

Joanne Adler in Pt. Pleasant, PA

>You're not supposed to tell where I got my design ideas! lol

Thank you, kind sir. Yes, David has already grabbed this article for a Shop Shot. Thanks.

Re: Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

#23

Thanks, Jen. I thought the same thing

Joanne Adler in Pt. Pleasant, PA

>about the first stand. That's why I couldn't finish it and sought help. The cabinet is so big and bold, I think any stand is going to look a little overwhelmed. This one, at least, ties in the curve element and highlights the box.

Re: Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

#24

Thanks, Ellis. Generous? Moi?

Joanne Adler in Pt. Pleasant, PA

>Here I am thinking I'm selfish in practicing all new skills on my friends and family, before I start making things for ME. By the time I get to my furniture, I should be pretty good. :-)

Re: Exercises in Design (long w/ mega pix!)

#25

Thanks Fred--Hey, Bill Hylton is

Joanne Adler in Pt. Pleasant, PA

>trying to get a hold of you. Contact him, if you haven't already heard from him.