Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

OT - Car brakes

Posts

OT - Car brakes

#1

OT - Car brakes

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>I have a 2005 Dodge SX 2.0 (think Neon with a different grille), with 27,000 km (about 16,500 miles) on the counter. The brakes shudder like crazy now, possibly as a result of hitting water after braking hard. And they seem to get worse.

I could change the front disks myself, but I believe the car has been fitted with poor disks to start with. Our grand Caravan, bought the same day, is just fine yet has more mileage on it.

Methinks these disks should be covered under warranty (which expires in 8 months), as I don't believe this should happen. I put probably 90% of the miles on that car, and I'm very easy on the brakes, on all the vehicles I've owned the brakes always lasted longer than the estimated replacement mileage.

Am I dreaming in color, or should I approach the dealer about this?

Thnx,

DC

Re: OT - Car brakes

#2

Re: OT - Car brakes

Chuck W

>Definitely tell the dealer about the brakes and that you think they are prematurely worn. It sounds like the disks have become warped and need replacing. The dealer may argue that 27,000 km's is within the normal wear range for these type of brakes. An acquaintance of mine had the same situation. The dealer replaced pads, rotors under warranty after he pressed his point that his car had very low mileage.

Re: OT - Car brakes

#3

Re: OT - Car brakes

JLSeigal McMinnville, OR

>Dennis; The brake rotors have warped after going thru the water and just replacing the pads will not fix the problem. The rotors will need to be resurfaced at the dealer or at a brake shop, etc. This is not usually a warranty covered repair. Jim , former truck/auto mechanic.

Re: OT - Car brakes

#4

Re: OT - Car brakes

Mark Nowicki

>As a rule, brake pads and rotors are not covered under warranty. i had a similar situation with a Windstar. The dealer said he would have gone to bat for me had I been a regular customer of his service department.

Feelings nothing to do with it, money talks.... you know the rest.

Mark

Re: OT - Car brakes

#5

Re: OT - Car brakes

Neal in San Jose

>I would definitely take this back to the dealer. This is a safety item, and they usually take this more seriously than knobs falling off the radio! I had an Audi dealer replace the rotors and pads on my '86 Audi with way over 50k on it (warranty expired at 50K) without me pressing him very hard.

Re: OT - Car brakes

#6

Re: OT - Warped rotors

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>You have warped the rotors, but I think you already knew that. This can be caused by a number of things, but one of the biggest culprits is repeated hard braking. I have teenager who can warp a set of rotors in less than a year. He drives fast and brakes hard. The brake mechanic gave him a bit of a lecture at the last rotor turning and showed him how the rotors were glazed and had hot spots (kinda like burn marks) on them.

For this reason, I don't think you will get any waranty satisfaction. You may know you brake easily, but how does the dealer have proof of that? Rotors warp in response to heat. Good luck.

Re: OT - Car brakes

#7

Re: OT - Car brakes

Kneale Brownson in Northern MI

>I'd definitely approach the dealer about the "safety issue" with brakes that create violent shaking.

If they won't do anything, then you could try what's been called an "Italian brake tuning" where you go out on the highway, make several long, hard stops from as fast as the law will allow (not in traffic, of course), so the brakes get good and hot and then drive for ten miles or so without using the brakes to let them cool down evenly. Might reduce/eliminate the warping. Might not.

One thing that helps warp brake discs is the practice of sitting at long stoplights with the pads clamped in one spot when the brakes are hot from stop-and-go driving in traffic. I try to avoid that by stopping with some space ahead so I can let the car creep if it's an automatic or just take it out of gear if the road is level or a manual.

Re: OT - Car brakes

#8

Re: OT - Warped rotors

JKJ in East TN

>>You have warped the rotors... This can be caused by a number of

>things, but one of the biggest culprits is repeated hard braking.

According to a recent article, another cause is driving with the left foot "lightly" resting on the break pedal. Evidently people who do this are often applying the breaks without realizing it, causing them (the breaks) to overheat.

JKJ

Re: OT - Car brakes

#9

Re: OT - Car brakes

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Dennis,

I would definitely take the car back to the dealer. 16,500 miles is way too low on the mileage scale for rotors to be warped. If you still have 8 months on the warranty, then they should replace the rotors. I agree with everyone else that misuse can create the problem, but so can defective rotors.

Just be sure to talk with the service manager and make it clear that you are more than willing to talk to the factory rep about the problem.

Gary

Re: OT - Car brakes

#10

Re: And many of today's stock.....

Jamie Donaldson

>... rotors are too thin to turn- require total replacement instead.

Re: OT - Car brakes

#11

Thanks all

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>I will talk with the dealership, given the responses here, thanks.

Thing is, I'm very easy on brakes. The car is a manual, and I use the engine as much as possible for braking, and unless faced with having to do a sudden stop I always brake in "spurts", pressing a bit on the pedal, let go so that the disks can cool, brake again, and so on. And I don't ever leave a foot resting on the brake pedal (can't do that with a manual anyway), I actually had to admonish my wife about that when we started going out together. My father is a retired mechanic, and he taught me about how to be easy on the brakes.

And yes, rotors are often thin enough these days that they can't be resurfaced, besides, having them turned often would cost more than buying new ones.

Thanks all,

DC

Re: OT - Car brakes

#12

engine breaking :-)

GolfSteve in Calgary

>I used to engine brake a lot but now I believe it's cheaper to replace brake pads and rotors every 125,000 km rather than the gearbox syncros every 250,000 km. Seems like downshifting into second all the time to get some engine braking is hard on the syncros.

New rotors are pretty cheap these days (at least for a VW; around $25 each from memory). Most places refuse to turn them because they are too thin. If the dealer doesn't give you satisfaction (as I'm sure my VW dealer would not), then you could try installing a set of new rotors yourself...not too hard to do.

pardon the pun in the subject line ;-)

Re: OT - Car brakes

#13

Re: engine breaking :-)

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Oh, I take it easy on the synchros, I double-clutch, or at least blip the throttle berore downshifting. Remnant from my farm days...

DC

Re: OT - Car brakes

#14

Interesting

Dan Donaldson

>It is interesting how many people anyore don't know how to drive a stick shift at all, let alone know what it means to double clutch;-)

(Spoken by one that learned to drive in an old pickup that had a non-synchro tranny.)

Re: OT - Car brakes

#15

Is it a coffee or a purse?

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Double-clutch? Is it an expensive coffee or a type of purse?

I've driven stick shift for many years until I could afford an automatic, but must admit I've never drove anything that needed a double-clutch.

So if it's not a coffee, and not a purse, is it two clutch pedals on the floor side by side, next to to the brake and gas pedals?????

;) ;)

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT - Car brakes

#16

Ever have to shift without the clutch?

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>I too learned to drive an old Chevy Pickup on the farm. Everybody learned how to double clutch. I once broke the clutch pedal link on an old Corvette. Had to drive it home. Start the car with the transmission in first, chuga-chuga-chuga, pick up speed, then slip out of gear and blip throttle to get gears speeds to mesh for next gear, etc, etc...... Approaching a stopsign, slip out of gear and turn car off. After stopping, same routine. Double clutching taught you how to match gear speeds to avoid that wonderful grinding sound.

Geez, now I feel really old.

Re: OT - Car brakes

#17

Oh yes......

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Bust my clutch on two old cars. On the first, I had to shift without a clutch for 5+ months before I had enough money to get the clutch fixed. Ah, to be young again ;)

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT - Car brakes

#18

BTDT ;-)

Dan Donaldson

>

Re: OT - Car brakes

#19

Drove an old Plymouth witht a fluid clutch

Ray SW Ohio

>

Re: OT - Car brakes

#20

You betcha!

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>Both with my 63 Dart and my 81 Goldwing. The Wing had to make it through city traffic, a little bit of a challenge. It's a good skill to know.

Bruce

Re: OT - Car brakes

#21

One more possibility

DB

>The problem could also be with the ABS system.

Re: OT - Car brakes

#22

That one's easy

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>The car doesn't have ABS brakes.

Thnx,

DC

Re: OT - Car brakes

#23

Re: OT - Car brakes

Bart Leetch

>"The dealer said he would have gone to bat for me had I been a regular customer of his service department."

I would have told the dealer he had things back wards the way to get business is to go to bat for the customer & make them a regular customer of his service department because of the good service.

So do you want me as a regular customer or not?

Business practices today are for the most part not what they should be.