Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Which door to use?

Posts

Which door to use?

#1

Which door to use?

Barry Irby

>I am making a version of the hunt board or side board featured in FWW in Dec. Mine is more down scale or low country that the one in the Mag and I have made it out of heart pine which I re-sawed from beams so that it is quarter sawed. This is old growth timber and may have twenty to thirty rings per inch.

There is a door left and right and three drawers in the center. The question is about the panels in the doors. In the magazine, he use contrasting wood with outstanding grain. I thought I might feature plain sawn heart pine in mine. I have made two set of panels, one flat or plain sawn and the other quarter sawn. The frames are quartersawn. Trying to decide if I have too much of a good thing. The question is, which do you like?

(Note: This is a mock up, the panels are actually behind the doors and not installed in the slots)


img

Re: Which door to use?

#2

Re: Left

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>Barry,

I like the set on the left.

The panels on the right tend to disappear into the frame, while those on the left stand out.

Whichever you decide upon, you're going to have a beautiful piece of furniture there.

Al

Re: Which door to use?

#3

Re: Which door to use? *LINK*

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I prefer the plain sawn myself, it's just a little more eye-catching. There is a really good book, mostly pics, by Franz Karg, that has a lot of shots that may help you decide.

Bruce


Solid Wood Cabinet Construction

Re: Which door to use?

#4

Some stray thoughts......

Barry Irby

>I counted the growth rings in those quartersawn panels. 120 in 4 1/2". Amazing. It took 26 years for each inch of wood.

I was wondering why the cathdral grain in the other panels did not stand out more or were not more "outrageous". Then it dawned on me that it has to do with the tight growth rings. What I need is a piece of heart pine that had larger coarser rings to make a more spectacular pattern.

I tried resawing a piece that had a spike knot in it, but it fell apart. Any other suggestions?

Re: Which door to use?

#5

Re: Some stray thoughts......

Paul Dwight

>Personally, I like the cathedral pattern you have in the existing plain sawn panels. I agree that it's not as pronounced as what is seen in most plain sawn pine, but that's exactly what I like about it. You're not making a Krenov-style case-on-stand, which really benefits from having spectacular wood in the door panels. The success of a large piece like a sideboard depends more on using wood that complements the overall design and proportions. In my opinion, it's good that the grain of the panels won't fight for attention with the overall design of the piece. -- Paul

Re: Which door to use?

#6

Re: Which door to use?

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>Contrast or quiet?

The plain sawn is a louder look-at-me look, relatively speaking. If you want the piece to exude a very quiet elegance, all rift or QS leans more that way. The cathedral grain is a little showier and a strong highlight. Both looks "work" and it is a personal aesthetic decision you face.

If there is a LOYL/client in the picture, why are you asking us?

Me? Decide now? QS.

Re: Which door to use?

#7

LEFT

robert davis

>

Re: Which door to use?

#8

Re: Which door ? Right door. Just my opinion.

Ray Carson, Lawrenceville NJ

>

Re: Which door to use?

#9

Lee Gordon

I'll take the curtain where Carol Merril is standi

Lee Gordon

>

Re: Which door to use?

#10

Ok, A third choice, trying again

Barry Irby

>I went back and cut a third set of panels. This time cutting at an angle to emphasize the cathedral grain. Again, A mock up with the panels oversized and under the door, leaving enough margin to trim them to line up nicely. So. Strong cathedral, Mild cathedral, or quarter sawn?


img

Re: Which door to use?

#11

Third time is charm

Mark in B'ham

>The third choice makes it look like you were trying to get a dramatic cathedral look. The left door on the first post looks more like you just found some boards that fit rather than actually choosing to put a cathedral grain on them. I think the QS looks too straight, but it would help de-emphasize the doors if that is what you want. I hope you'll post a picture when you get it done.

My 2c worth

Re: Which door to use?

#12

Re: Mild

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>Barry,

I still prefer the mild cathedral...left in the first photo posted.

Al

Re: Which door to use?

#13

left side.....framed as is

Scott in Eastern Iowa

>

Re: Which door to use?

#14

agree

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>Because the arch is perfectly centered you have a much less "random" feel to the arches than the original cathedral look. It becomes more formal and a very strong design element.

IMO either QS or the most recent cathedral look will make a refined look. It comes down to whether you want whisper quiet or formal loud. What's the rest of the room like? Where will the piece sit?

Re: Which door to use?

#15

Ellis Walentine

A matter of taste

Ellis Walentine

>When dealing with a strongly grained wood I usually opt for an understated look, which would be the rift or quartered option here. It is pretty tough to come up with four solid wood panels that have similar cathedrals. The panels in your most recent example have similar cathedral shapes, but the coloring is still a bit wild. You could get close to an exact match with veneer, but then you wouldn't be able to raise the panels.

Ellis

Re: Which door to use?

#16

Interesting side note

Barry Irby

>I cut the last four panels in sequence. I tried book matching them. They appeared as one light, one dark, one light, one dark. Note that on the edge of these panels the stripes of the quartered grain are at about a 15 degree angel to the face. This apparently give the pieces a chatoyance (sp?) effect. The light affects the rising grain differently than the "descending" grain. The effect and color reverses if you walk around to the other end. To make the color appear consistent they had to be slip matched, not book matched. Considering they came out of the same piece of wood a 1/16" apart, the effect is amazing.

Re: Which door to use?

#17

Re: Agree -- Mild.

Paul Dwight

>