Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

OT-Bathroom air purification

Posts

OT-Bathroom air purification

#1

OT-Bathroom air purification

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

>I screwed up. I have an unfinished half bath on the first floor of this house. Starting to finish it and make it useful. Now realize that I have eliminated the possibility of running an exhaust line up thru the second floor to the outside. Now the only way to get an exhaust line outside is to drill a hole thru a 18" log wall. I don't want to do that. Has anyone seen a recirculating bathroom fan using a charcoal filter? Moisture is not a problem since this is a half bath. Recirculating fans to purify air is old technology but I am having trouble finding a commercial unit for a half bath.

Howard

Re: OT-Bathroom air purification

#2

Heck....

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Forget about the fan. Just leave a pair of Dr. Scholl's Odor Eaters behind the loo.

Have a nice weekend,

Clint

Re: OT-Bathroom air purification

#3

Re: OT-Bathroom air purification

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>And Howard, all this time I was under the impression that your sh** doesn't stink!! HA!

Seriously, I wouldn't know why a charcoal filter wouldn't work. Thought of building your own using a filter from the kitchen range hood? Might be worth a try. At least you would know whether the filter would work to your liking, without paying a great deal for a manufactured model. Most hardware stores carry replacement charcoal filter elements that are cheap.

Good luck!

Ron in Iowa

Re: OT-Bathroom air purification

#4

Re: OT-Bathroom air purification

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>In the old days, we kept a box of stick matches in the bathroom or outhouse. After polluting the air we would burn 2 or 3 matches. The burning sulphur smell would overpower the aroma we created. Close box before striking !!!!

Re: OT-Bathroom air purification

#5

Re: OT-Bathroom air purification

Bill Hammond, Oregon Coast

>spray bottle of Fabreeze (howevertheheckitisspelled)

or just put the litter box in there, people expect the smell then....

Re: OT-Bathroom air purification

#6

Re: OT-Bathroom air purification

Marv

>I heard that if you light a match it will clear the air instantly. so just have a box of matches handy.

Warning....could be explosive...

Marv

Re: OT-Bathroom air purification

#7

Re: OT-Bathroom air purification

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

>Ron, I think that you may be on the right track. I may just build my own filter and see out it works.

Thanks,

Howard

Re: OT-Bathroom air purification

#8

Doesn't work

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I've tried several of those charcoal filters. They don't work.

Bad design on my house exhausted the fan into the space between the joists, so there was nearly zero airflow. Put in new fan and vented into adjacent closet, and even with filters, it stinks. Next project will be to pipe up through the second floor closet into the attic.

The filters should should, but they don't.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT-Bathroom air purification

#9

Re: Doesn't work

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

>That is not good news Mark. I haven't looked yet to see what type of charcoal filters are readily available.

I just had a thought. How about a small ozone generator?

Howard

Re: OT-Bathroom air purification

#10

A possible alternative.

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>Sounds like exhaust fans and filters are not viable options. Here's something that works well for us if deodorizing is the action you're looking for. First the background—when I was condo president early in the decade, we had time metered deodorizers installed in each end of each floor of each building on the campus. At some point I wound up with one of the mostly empty containers (roughly the size of a WD-40 can) after a routine replacement. I brought it home and we used it in the bathroom (which also had no vent/exhaust/filter capability). I was amazed because for the first time in our history of bathroom sprays we had something that actually deodorized instead of just masking or overpowering with another noxious aroma.

The product is TimeMist Premium Air Freshener With Odor Counteractant. The installation in the buildings included a dispenser with a timer. The refills can be used without the dispenser, and one of the nice things about it is when you depress the spray button it gives about a 300 msec. spritz of product. The amazing thing is how effective it is. Just one shot in the general direction of the offending event and within five minutes or so, all traces of the event and the spray are essentially gone.

It comes in a variety of scents—we prefer the milder varieties—and we found the refills locally at our commercial restaurant supply. You can probably find them online, as well, at one of the janitorial supply houses. The original can we had was Peach, which we liked well enough, but when we couldn't get that at the restaurant supply, we wound up with Clean & Fresh, which really is. We like it so well we returned for another couple of cans so that each of our bathrooms, exhaust fan notwithstanding, is fully equipped for the most potent of our friends and family, regardless of meals.

Rod

Re: OT-Bathroom air purification

#11

Re: Needs to exhaust completely

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>Or at least that's what I've always been taught. Just going into another space doesn't really get rid of anything.

I don't think it's just a local thing, but it might be...

Re: OT-Bathroom air purification

#12

Re: A possible alternative.

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

>Thanks Rod, good ideas. My original plans had been to finish this half bath before doing the full bath above it. If that had happened I would have been able to do an exhaust up thru the walls but it didn't happen that way. So now I am considering my options.

Howard

Re: OT-Bathroom air purification

#13

Re: Needs to exhaust completely

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>I'm somewhat confused. What good does a charcoal filter do under a range hood? Maybe just get rid of any smoke, and nothing else? I asked my wife if she ever noticed any cooking oders coming from our unvented hood, but she admitted that she never paid any attention whether there is or not. My curiosity is peaked. Inquiring minds wanta know!!!

Ron in Iowa

Re: OT-Bathroom air purification

#14

Re: Needs to exhaust completely

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

>The filters in over the range hoods are supposed to remove the cooking odors. Having never had one of them I can't comment on how effective they are in practice.

Howard

Re: OT-Bathroom air purification

#15

Glade-Fresh Linen?

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>:)

Sorry...I coudn't resist.

Re: OT-Bathroom air purification

#16

Exactly

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I've never seen/heard of a bathroom fan that was NOT vented outside or to the attic, but I had to go and buy a house with one vented between the joists. Figures :( It never worked properly vented to joists (guess the previous owners didn't stink as much) so I figured the next best thing was venting to an adjacent closet and filtering it. The ventilation worked well, after than, but the smell? I was just transferred :(

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT-Bathroom air purification

#18

Re: Serious answerer

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

>Yes, I could go down but there is a S/D line that blocks me from going outside there thru the wood. I could go down and then out thru 8" of poured concrete. That doesn't seem like an easy solution either.

Howard

Re: OT-Bathroom air purification

#19

Re: Needs to exhaust completely

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>Well, not just odors. There's a lot of steam coming off of those cooking pots. Sending it into an attic is a bad thing.

And in the bathroom, I'd rather those odors were exhausted to the outside environment.