Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Pricing question....

Posts

Pricing question....

#1

JL

Pricing question....

JL

>Okay, I met with the client. She accepted the price for the buffet shelf (16" x 52") with supports. Not a problem.

I gave her the price for the kitchen table (38" x 50" x 30" H). This is for an oak table with a pedestal base with feet. There is a lip around the outside of the top so granite tiles can be mounted in the table. There is an apron (4") on the bottom. The pedestal would be made out of 8-12 pieces and then turned. She didn't like the price. What would be a good price then? I'm looking at a few hours of shop time here (maybe 8-10).

Re: Pricing question....

#2

Re: Pricing question....

Virgil

>I would quote the job at 50.00 per hour x how long I thought it would take me to do the job. No sense in working for free.

Re: Pricing question....

#3

Re: Pricing question....

Chuck Lenz

>You could order a pedestal from VanDykes and build off of that to try to save on shop time and maybe costs, I'm not sure what they get for a pedestal but it may be something to look into. Today I yanked my classified ad for custom woodworking in a local internet site. I'm done geting beat up and yanked around by the public that doesn't understand what it takes to do this kind of work. I had a gal call me the other day wanting a fairly simple frame made, she was going to cover it with fabric so it didn't have to be too pretty, just made out of pine with a 1" deep recess. I told her $20, but if she wanted more made in one order I could do a little bit better on the price. Her reply was, well you know when you people make stuff like this you really don't get paid for your time. Yeah right, I bought thousands of dollars worth of equipment, and work in a hazardous enviroment just so I can be some kind of wood fairy to snobby strangers. You bet.

Re: Pricing question....

#4

Re: Pricing question....

Mark Nowicki

>What happened to your " somewhat reasonable" rate of $20 to $25 per hour?

Mark

Re: Pricing question....

#5

JL

Re: That's for odd jobs, not shop rates..

JL

>and that is for the little old ladies of the church! But even so, using the non-shop rate that would be $250 for labor and maybe $200+ for materials.

Re: Pricing question....

#6

Re: That's for odd jobs, not shop rates..

Mark Nowicki

>Given that this client is young, tall and does not attend church, IMO, the price should be $825.00.

Mark

Re: Pricing question....

#7

Re: Pricing question....

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>Raise the price. No one says the price has to go down.

I always end up underestimating the time it takes to get anything finished anyway. Have for years.

Re: Pricing question....

#8

Dale Lenz

Re: Pricing question....

Dale Lenz

>If you are comfortable with your price, don't come down. Your feel ripped off during the project. When some one ask me for a discount, I feel like saying, sure: will you work for me all day Friday for free, PLEASE, shhhh! But, then again, I'm back logged nicely. Been there done that. I always thought, once they see my work they would come back for more. They might, but always wanted a Wally-Mart price. I finally came to the conclusion they are not the market I'm looking for.

Re: Pricing question....

#9

YUP !

s.mackay@worldnet.att.net

>

Re: Pricing question....

#10

Re: Pricing question....

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>Why is it that you are not confident in your price? You don't mention what the price is in this post, so I have no idea what you quoted; it would be interesting to know. One of the things you have to keep in mind is that if you are good at what you do there will be plenty of people who are willing to spend money for your work. The problem with the lack of self assurance / self confidence from not knowing what you are doing I think can be felt and is definitely noticed by most people. They are not willing to spend money if they are not confident in you. On the other hand, they may actually not be able to afford your work; that is not your problem, that would be their problem. If someone were to hand me stuff for free, I would probably take it, unless I could think of some reason not to. I occasionally buy something just because I think it is cheap.

Re: Pricing question....

#11

Re: Pricing question....

Ronald Walls

>I would charge one half of whatever the cost of the material would be. Maybe not much but this is my hobby. Maybe to much but it is my hobby. Not there's!!

Re: Pricing question....

#12

Re: Pricing question....

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Without going into all the detail cost considerations that make up a pricing determination, if you don't charge at least $60/hour for labor and consultation plus 125 percent of your cost of materials, you might as well give it away. Project pricing ain't negotiable.

Clint

Re: Pricing question....

#13

JL

Re: Thanks all, I was just grousing...

JL

>I quoted her what I thought a reasonable rock bottom price would be for a delivered table. $600. I guess she wanted Ikea prices or something.

If it had been an ordinary "legged" table, it would have been less expensive.

Re: Pricing question....

#14

A good starting point Clint. And to JL......

Art Silva

>No two jobs are alike unless you are puking particle board cabinets out the back door at the rate of 100/day. If this is your bag, then the only thing you have to fear is the end of stupidity and bad taste. On the other hand, if you have built your expertise in woodworking over time, and have demonstrated to yourself that you are truly able to turn out quality work on which you are not afraid to sign your name, then it is time to charge what is commensurate with your effort. If you are at a point in time where prospects are viewed as your next bag of groceries, then you are definitely in the wrong line of work.

Many, many people on this site will concur with this observation that is not original to me: A customer who appreciates and values good work, and is willing to pay for it, will be anxious to show off his new acquisition. This will result in referrals. Chiselers, if accomodated, disappear!

Re: Pricing question....

#15

You are kidding, right?

Robert W - aka nailshooter

>I mean, you have to be. You cannot do all your glue ups, turn a custom OAK base to a specific design and attach the feet in the amount of time you allowed.

If you don't stave the base so that it is hollow, you will be turning one helluva log, there. Gotta big lathe?

Then you are going to make a top?

Please don't tell me this included any material or hardware...

If it does, though... I would sure consider putting you on the payroll at those prices!

You are TOO cheap! Even if this is a hobby!

Robert

Re: Pricing question....

#16

Re: Pricing question....

Sgian Dubh

>I don't believe you can make that table in 8- 10 hours JL, considering the amount of work you described.

I'd guess- without going through my normal estimating procedure which is where I break the job down into its constituent parts and price each element, that your time is more likely to be around 45 to 55 hours.

Then you'll need to add up all your material costs and mark them up by a minimum of 25%, and more likely somewhere between 50% and 100%. After all, no business can afford to resell materials purchased for a job at a loss.

Your $600 quote does look rather optimistic to me, unless I'm missing something fundamental. It's even crossed my mind that you're planning to buy a kit of ready made parts needing no more than assembly, sanding and polishing, because your estimated time of 8-10 hours might cover most of that side of the job.

I just don't know. There is something seriously out of kilter here. I can only think I'm missing something really obvious, and if that's the case I apologise. Slainte.

Re: Pricing question....

#17

Re: Thanks all, I was just grousing...

Mac

>Hang in there JL. I think the $600 was low myself.Once you gain confidence,you are worth what you ask.If you start working for low wages you will be stuck there for a long time.

Re: Pricing question....

#18

Re: Pricing question....

Joe Pack

>A single pedestal 42" round solid cherry kitchen table runs just shy of $600 from an Amish woodshop, Twin Locust Furniture, in Holmes Co., Ohio. The owner and his cousins build them themselves on-site. (The same table ran as much as $1100 in furniture stores...the same wood, same style, different levels of "snooty" at the stores.)

Re: Pricing question....

#19

Re: Pricing question....

Sgian Dubh

>Are you saying they're mass or batch produced Joe? To start from scratch to do a one-off isn't the same thing.

The batch or mass producer will have a routine developed through experience along with a series of jigs and patterns to repeat previous jobs.

A bespoke item is quite different, even if the construction and shapes are very common. For instance, I have all the machinery, resources, skills and knowledge to reproduce one of Ikea's �20 wooden folding dining chairs.

Unfortunately I couldn't even buy the wood for what Ikea are selling their chair for, and in the end all I'd be making would be an extremely expensive copy of a mass produced chair. Doing the job would be a complete waste of my time, and no-one would pay me for it.

It's what I can do that isn't already available and mass or batch produced that makes furniture designing and making worth me doing. Slainte.

Re: Pricing question....

#20

Re: Pricing question....

Thomas S Stockton

>Here goes without reading responses yet. Bottom line the price is what you told her. If she wants a cheaper wood or wants a simpler design redesign and rebid but don't discount it more just to get the job and make her happy. She should be able to afford it. Explain to her that this is what it costs to make the project and let her think about it if she really wants it she'll come back. Usually when I do this the clients think about it and order anyway.

This is a hard lesson to learn but it does you no good to under price/value your work and actually will hurt you in the long run. Some of the worst jobs I did when I was starting out were ones where I fell into this trap, you end up resenting the job a client, especially after you deliver it and realize that they can afford the extra.

Tom

Re: Pricing question....

#21

Re: Thanks all, I was just grousing...

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>I think you will need to focus on higher end woodworking in order to survive in the woodworking industry. There are several different ways to actually support a family as a cabinetmaker. As an example, do a Google search for "Ikea" and look through their website. Cheap functioning furniture is being imported by the ship loads from overseas. The labor is so cheap that it is not included in calculations to determine the cost of the finished goods. One way to survive is to lease a shop full of automated equipment and build kitchen cabinets. Another way is to build a reputation as an artist. None of this is really easy so they call it "work". It burns me a little bit when somebody looks at prices from Ikea or Crate & Barrel and thinks I can make it for less money.