Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

I posted this on the quiet side what do you think

Posts

I posted this on the quiet side what do you think

#1

I posted this on the quiet side what do you think

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I would first like to apologize for bringing this subject up on this sacred forum (Hand Tools). But I am spurred to ask this question. What produces the most felicitous results, using power tools or using hand tools? Perhaps �result� is not the proper word maybe �process�, which is more pleasurable?

What tools bring you pleasure and don�t mind using for hours on end? A tool screaming or a tool singing?

Not what is more profitable or more efficient or more productive but what would you rather do? If you could do woodworking with no regard to actually making money how would you like to spend your time woodworking? Time, cost of materials, overhead, buying more tools, none of these things matter (well you can always justify buying more tools), which path would you choose?

Stephen

Re: I posted this on the quiet side what do you think

#2

Re: I posted this on the quiet side what do you th

Tony - Memphis

>When working on a project, I am always glad to get to the point where I am through with the power tool usage. I really appreciate the quiet effiency and lack of dust. I can listen to the radio, not where a mask and ear plugs, and get a little excercise. I feel like I get much more predictable results using hand tools. Now, I really appreciate the work that my jointer and planer do for me!

Tony

Re: I posted this on the quiet side what do you think

#3

Raise Your Glass For A Toast To Hand Tool Users

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>More POWER to them. :<)

George

Re: I posted this on the quiet side what do you think

#4

Re: I posted this on the quiet side what do you th

Paul Dwight

>Woodworking is purely a hobby for me so I don't have to worry about profitability or return on investment. I still use mostly power tools. I enjoy using hand tools, but I also enjoy the sense of accomplishment when I finish a project in a reasonable period of time -- which is what my power tool-focused methods allow me to achieve. I totally understand that some woodworkers get most of their enjoyment out of the process, and for them a hand tool-centric approach makes perfect sense. I enjoy the process, but I also enjoy the sense of accomplishment from having finished a project. For me, the best balance focuses on power tools and uses hand tools when they are more appropriate for individual tasks.

To each his (or her) own! -- Paul

Re: I posted this on the quiet side what do you think

#5

Re: I posted this on the quiet side what do you th

Barry Irby

>I am mostly a power tool guy. I am mostly self taught and that is not a good thing. I know I do much better with a coach or some type of instruction, but for some reason, I have never gotten the instruction I think might benefit me in woodworking. I took shop class in high school and loved it. Had an excellent Teacher the first year, but he left and for the second year we were pretty much on our own. The so called shop teacher was not a wood worker. (He was a Magician with a torch and a welder and I wish I had paid more attention) I actually ended up "teaching" woodworking the second year. School actually arrange for me to spend my study hall in the shop, so I could show others how to do stuff in wood shop. And It really was "how to do STUFF".

My point is that somehow I formed the opinion that we had left all that had stuff behind and graduated to power tools. An example of how wrong my Opinion is: I have known about card scrapers forever, but only recently got one (a set). I am stunned at how useful they are and how effectively they do some things. I thought it was ancient technology we had left behind. If we left card scrapers behind, we need to go back and get them. Wow. Just last night I quietly slipped over to the Hand Tool forum (under and assumed name) and read a discussion of rasps. Look out card scrapers, their may be some rasps coming. Those guys are passionate about their rasps. Who knew?

Their is a guy in my local turning club that made a chest of drawers. (Not on the lathe, he went to the flat side for a few minutes). The hand cut dovetails were masterful. I would be happy to pay him for a lesson. If I could do those dovetails, I would believe I had arrived.

Wood working is an endless hobby. There is much to learn.

Re: I posted this on the quiet side what do you think

#6

Re: I posted this on the quiet side what do you th

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I don�t have to make money from woodworking and I have a want-to-do list of projects that keeps growing that will outlive me. For me, every one is a trip that has a journey and a destination. After 40+ years, each successive journey looks much like its predecessor. The excitement and satisfaction comes with the arrival at the destination and the anticipation of the next destination, so the objective is to find the shortest distance between start and finish without worrying about the occasional detour. Tools and technique evolve, and I try not to obsess about either; the limitations of both are accepted. Projects that don�t fit within the limits are rejected unless the result is so wanted and the stretch is modest enough to justify a new tool or more labor. Different strokes for different folks.

Clint

Re: I posted this on the quiet side what do you think

#7

Re: I posted this on the quiet side what do you th

David C. Lykins - guitardude - Marietta GA

>As much as I like power tools, I'd really have to say that one of the biggest enjoyments I get is hand shaping certain parts of my electric guitars. The concave spoke shaves are just awesome for carving the back of guitar necks and its just a blast to see and feel a somewhat long plank with a headstock be shaped into a real guitar neck that is nicely contoured and fittet for its player.

The other nifty tool I love to use are the microplanes, I think I have almost ALL of them now and have even made a special handle for the blade that's suppose to fit in a hacksaw frame. I'm always amazed how much wood I can remove and how quickly things like the tummy cutout on the back of a guitar body take shape using the Microplanes. I was really afraid at first that I would have problems with controlling it and staying within the lines I had marked off for the section to be carve. I was pleasingly surprised.