Ah, the eternal question, to taper or not to taper
doug f, san clemente, ca
>I'm building a pine sideboard, pretty basic, legs, low shelf and two drawers. But the question I can never answer is whether to taper the legs on two sides (inside faces) or four sides. Square legs, approximately 1 3/4" tapered to 1 1/8" at the bottom about 35" high.
What's the general consensus; taper 2 or 4 faces?
Thanks for the help.
Doug
Re: Ah, the eternal question, to taper or not to taper
Re: Ah, the eternal question, to taper or not to t
David Hay @ Denver
>I'd say it probably depends on the style of the piece. For some reason, I associate 4-sided tapers with more ornate pieces. But I'm sure there are examples where this is done on plainer pieces as well to good effect.
Your best bet is to sketch it out in some way and see what you like. Another thing you might do is to make the legs, but before cutting any tapers, put some tape on the waste side of the taper cuts to help you visualize what the piece might look like with that bit missing.
David
Re: Ah, the eternal question, to taper or not to taper
Re: Ah, the eternal question, to taper or not to t
Mark McC
>I guess whenever I hear Pine I immediately think (rightly or wrongly) of a more "country style". And I associate country as having mostly 2 sided tapers. Maybe thats because allot of the early pine antiques and shaker influenced pieces seem to have allot of 2 sided leg tapers.
4 sided tapers for me is more of a traditional, formal style.
Depends what you are going for with this piece.
You already know either way works and there's no wrong way!
Sadly for me, "eternal questions" require a mandatory "eternal process" of having to fret and worry about these decisions for a while before getting on with it!
Re: Ah, the eternal question, to taper or not to taper
Re: Ah, the eternal question, to taper or not to t
Barry Irby
>I am making a hunt board or side board that was featured in a recent issue of FWW. (I can walk down to the shop and get the issue date and number if you care.) The piece was built by Garrett Hack out of quarter sawn cherry. I had some heart pine beams I have been hoarding for thirty years. I resawed them, quarter sawn and rift sawed some stock for legs.
The end result of all this babble is that I chose to dress the piece down a bit from the one in the Mag. It did have two sided tapers and I kept that Idea. He had put little decorative cuffs on the legs and changed the taper at that point. I believe his legs were very slender ending 7/8 or 13/16 square. I tapered mine from 1 3/4" to 1". I was thinking mine was a little more low country. Now I am not sure. Maybe I should have gone to 7/8". (I'm agonizing over adding a second short taper att eh bottom.) Other than that, I am really happy with the piece and if I ever finish it I will post some pics.
Re: Ah, the eternal question, to taper or not to taper
Re: Ah, the eternal question, to taper or not to t
Hank Knight
>Barry, I've started the same piece with the same idea of dressing it down some. I've been struggling with the bottom of the legs too. Garrett's inlay band won't work for my piece. What kind of "cuffs" are you using?
Re: Ah, the eternal question, to taper or not to taper
Re: Ah, the eternal question, to taper or not to t
Barry Irby
>No cuffs at all.
I just put a straight two sided taper on them.
I have made the drawer boxes and the carcase of the piece itself.
The top is made up, but I have not tapered the edges. I am debating a straight bevel like Garrett used or a long cove made on the table saw. Made several pieces recently with the TS cove and really like it, but don't want to get carried away.
The doors are the next thing. I don't think I am going to inlay the dark wood around the inside of the openings. So far everything is quarter sawn, but I am considering flat sawn heart pine for the panels, just to get some outrageous "cathedral grain" for the panels. What do you think?
Where are you in yours and what are you making it out of?
Re: Ah, the eternal question, to taper or not to taper
>It's Dec 2006, No. 187 and it's the cover article. I know you can find it on line at Taunton Press.
I have kept the dimemtions pretty close to the original. I did change some of the the construction. I used dovetails on the face frame rather than the M&T joints in his.
It happened that I had a piece of 1/4" oak plywood left over from a previous project so I used it to make a stress skin panel for the bottom. (Similar to the torsion boxes in the most recent issue of another mag.) The bottom is flat on the inside but has a curve on the under side that matched the curve of the the front and rear rails. It's 7/8 thick on both ends and 2" in the center. Couldn't stand it. He discussed the necessity of strength and his solution was to make the top and bottom thicker. The Pack Rat AND the Engineer in me came out. I used something I had saved and engineered it to be stronger. The Scrap I had was precisely the correct width and only two inches too long when cut in half. I was a happy little woodworker.
Re: Ah, the eternal question, to taper or not to taper
Re: Ah, the eternal question, to taper or not to t
Hank Knight in SC
>I haven't started cutting yet. My wood arrived from Hearne's last week and I'm letting it sit in the shop for a while. I'm going to milk paint evertyhing but the top, drawer fronts and the door panels with barn red, green and ending up with black, rubbing the finish out so some of the red and green under colors show at the wear places. All of frame and carcass will be soft maple. The top, drawer fronts and door panels will be natural finished curly cherry. The maple from Hearne's looks good, but the cherry is lighter than I wanted and has less dramatic figure than I'd hoped for. I have several good sized curly cherry pieces left over from another project that may do. I need to dig it out and measure to see how much I have. I won't get started until late next month. I'm going to the Center for Furniture Craftsmanship in two weeks for Garrett Hack's "Precision with Hand Tools" course. I plan to pick his brain while I'm there. Anything you want me to ask him?
Post pictures of your's when you're done. Mine will take a while. I'm very slow.
Hank
Re: Ah, the eternal question, to taper or not to taper
Re: Ah, the eternal question, to taper or not to t
Johanna
>Can you dry assemble it before tapering the legs? If so, mask off tapers on the legs to see how it would look. A few years ago I was planning on tapering the legs of an end table. I assembled the table, taped off the proposed taper and discovered that although it looked great on paper, it looked awful on the project. I left the legs square. You can see that table at http://home.comcast.net/~thompsonjo/Yo-WW1-tbl.htm