Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Granite: out of the kitchen, into the workshop *LINK*

Posts

Granite: out of the kitchen, into the workshop *LINK*

#1

Granite: out of the kitchen, into the workshop *LINK*

wilbur

>At AWFS Steel City announced a table saw and band saw that have tables made of GRANITE!

They also announced jointers that have granite fences.

To say this was surprising is the understatement of the day.


Popular Woodworking blog: Steel City

Re: Granite: out of the kitchen, into the workshop *LINK*

#2

Re: Granite: out of the kitchen, into the workshop

Patrick Schupbach

>Too cool!!! What a radical idea.

Re: Granite: out of the kitchen, into the workshop *LINK*

#3

JL

Re: Granite: out of the kitchen, into the workshop

JL

>I guess that means magnetic featherboards and jigs can't be used with it :). Looks interesting. They definitely won't rust, but I'd still be worried about chipping.

Re: Granite: out of the kitchen, into the workshop *LINK*

#4

Re: Granite: out of the kitchen, into the workshop

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Makes pretty good sense, Granite has both weight - to reduce vibration, excellent flatness (can be purchased to within .00001 flat in 48". It is also very stable and obviously no deterioration due to rust etc.. The cost of granite gage plates at reasonable tolerances (.0001 in 12") is fairly low - the only drawbacks are the shipping cost (due to the weight) and ease of attaching accessories. Granite will chip. But even if chipped by dropping a tool or item on the top, it can be fairly easily repaired with epoxy. Wood should slide fairly easily on the surface - especially if coated with wax.

Re: Granite: out of the kitchen, into the workshop *LINK*

#5

KInd of a no-brainer when you think about it.

Forrest Addy

>KInd of a no-brainer when you think about it.

Granite is plentiful cheap and easy to work using modern tools and processes. Interfacing and assembling it with other materials is also easy when you consider bonded inserts and strong two part adhesives. In plaine prismatic shapes are referred to in the link who make a pattern and go through all the fuss with sand and molten metal metaallurgy, molding and pouring, fettling and detailing when you can buy granite in large hunks and saw it up as needed. Yes it's brittle and not particularly strong compared to cast iron but you have low cost, thickness, and stability, no rust, - and novelty - to compensate.

Come to think of it, it's a natural step. I wonder why it hasn't happend earlier.

Re: Granite: out of the kitchen, into the workshop *LINK*

#6

Re: Granite: out of the kitchen, into the workshop

Barry Irby

>This really is a no brainer. Why didn't I think of it? I had a pool table years ago with a slate top.

Re: Granite: out of the kitchen, into the workshop *LINK*

#7

Not So Fast

Kevin Rabenaldt

>Appears to be a good idea. However, granite would be weak in any kind of tension force. You have a weak area around the slots and the blade openings. Also, vibration over years of use could create fractures. Not all granite is the same and I do not know where they are getting this granite, but microfractures typically exist in granite. This microfractures or even hidden fractures (one that you do not see) usually do not give problems unless the granite is put in a stress condition. Ask countertop installers if they are surprised that a particular piece breaks on them for no apparent reason. Don't pound on your top for any reason (and don't forget because failure will come quickly).

While some may get years of reliable service from such a top, I would guess that some failures will occur.

I think I will stay with a good quality cast iron top.

Kevin

Re: Granite: out of the kitchen, into the workshop *LINK*

#8

Kind of a "duh" thought isn't it.

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>

Re: Granite: out of the kitchen, into the workshop *LINK*

#9

I was talking to a client about that.....

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I have a client that uses tablesaws and also works with granite and corian. They've made some saw table "covers" with corian. It's quicker to cover the top of a tablesaw saw with formica or corian than it is to remove rust, etc. They also use extra pieces of these type materials for some of there extension tables and jogs, etc. We were out in the back of their shop, looking at a pile of excess countertop materials, talking about using granite on a tablesaw,just last summer.

I wonder if someone was listening in ;) ;) ;)

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Granite: out of the kitchen, into the workshop *LINK*

#10

Chinese innovation

wilbur

>That part of China where the factory that makes Steel City equipment is well known (in China, at least) for granite quarries and working granite. Actually, there's some incredible stonework that is done in China. It's not usually done to Western tastes, so it's not exported out very much, but if you have a Chinese furniture store near you, you'll be able to see some examples.

I guess this would give the lie to the idea that Chinese factories can only imitate, and not innovate.

Re: Granite: out of the kitchen, into the workshop *LINK*

#11

I mentioned it here for a router table top..

Craig Daymon

>a few years back (4?). Didn't get too much support then, though there were some comments about it making a pretty impressive piece of shop furniture. I never did get to making it and I have a large piece of lab table phenolic waiting to become my new router table, so I may never. My thinking was that I could get a dead flat surface and that I would add a layer of support using BB ply or some such under it. This would also allow me to extend forward to add a miter slot to the front edge, like the Benchdog track that is available.

Maybe Benchdog will make a granite top in the future?

-Craig

Re: Granite: out of the kitchen, into the workshop *LINK*

#12

I vaguely remember that, bet you're

Forrest Addy

>I vaguely remember that. Not you by name but the suggestion. Bet you're slapping your head "D'oh!!" now.

For general information, large blocks of granite have formed the basis for high accuracy apparatus like coordinate measuring machines, optical benches, and reference flats for generations.

There are enormous deposits of granite throughout the world and quarrying technique is getting ever more productive.

Re: Granite: out of the kitchen, into the workshop *LINK*

#13

I think someone was going to try it

Craig Daymon

>If I remember correctly, someone who lives in South America (Brazil?) was going to try making the router table with a granite top. I think his location put him close to a good source.

Unfortunately, I don't recall who it was.

-Craig

Re: Granite: out of the kitchen, into the workshop *LINK*

#14

Neat idea....

John in New Mexico

>I wouldn't mind one of those myself, cheapskate though I am. Nice that they've added a riving knife too. Even at 2" thick I think I'd still worry a little about eventual failure at a miter slot - due to the sharp corner - but not enough to keep me from trying one if I was in the market for a new saw.

John

Re: Granite: out of the kitchen, into the workshop *LINK*

#15

Re: 4 years? Don't think so!

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>Craig,

Actually, it was August 24, 2000, 3:43:00 AM. Your memory is as bad as mine. You should have purchased the Badger Pond Archives CD. ;^)

You're a man ahead of his time. You procrastinated and Steel City stole your idea. Wonder if they were Ponders?

At the time, I called a local stone fabribricator and to cut a 9" x 12" rectangular hole with 2" radius at each corner and centered in your 2" x 24" x 36" stone would cost no more than $150.00 with shipping costs borne by the customer. I'm confident that the price would be lower with a volume order.

Al

Re: Granite: out of the kitchen, into the workshop *LINK*

#16

Re: Brazil

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>Craig,

That was "Kees in Brazil." I'm tellin' ya, you should have bought that Badger Pond Archives CD! ;^)

At that time (February 16, 2001, 6:31:00 AM) Kees could get �" thick granite for $5.00/square foot, including polishing the top and rounding/bevelling the edges.

Kees' information:

Kees Wijnstekers -- Brazil

Kees.Wijnstekers@Halliburton.com

It would be interesting to know if he built the table top.. have no idea whether the e-mail address is still valid, though.

Al

Re: Granite: out of the kitchen, into the workshop *LINK*

#17

Ouch! Now I do feel old!

Craig Daymon

>Good thing the memory seems to be going. That way I'll think it was only 4 years ago again in a week or so.

-Craig

Re: Granite: out of the kitchen, into the workshop *LINK*

#18

Chinese innovation------WebKitFormBoundarydDV8HSVL

wilbur

>That part of China where the factory that makes Steel City equipment is well known (in China, at least) for granite quarries and working granite. Actually, there's some incredible stonework that is done in China. It's not usually done to Western tastes, so it's not exported out very much, but if you have a Chinese furniture store near you, you'll be able to see some examples.

I guess this would give the lie to the idea that Chinese factories can only imitate, and not innovate.