Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

Posts

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

#1

Ellis Walentine

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

>Hello again, folks, and welcome to the dog days of summer. It's time for our latest "Ides of..." survey, our bimonthly attempt to unravel yet another woodworking mystery, or debunk another myth.

One topic that has been widely debated in recent years is the issue of hand tools vs. power tools. Most woodworkers (but not all) would rather prepare and dimension stock with power equipment, saving their manual labor and hand tool skills for the final stages of a project -- the joinery, final surfacing and detailing. How do you decide which tool to use for a given job? What are the tradeoffs? What are the optimal efficiencies? Is there a formula, or can you develop a process for deciding on the fly?

As usual, in a week or so we will harvest your replies, strip them to their bare essentials and send them off to Woodworker West magazine for our next "News & Views" column, to appear in their September-October 2007 issue.

Thanks again for your participation!

Ellis Walentine, Host


Woodworker West

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

#2

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY***

Rob Sandow

>Ellis,

I think there are probably 2 schools of thought on this. If you are a professional, I would guess you would make the decision purely on what is most cost effective and time efficient. Perhaps if you are a hobbyist doing a limited producion run for a bunch of gifts or the like, then you might choose the same way.

On the other hand, if you are a hobbyist doing a piece for the pure enjoyment of it, then you will probably choose the method that you enjoy most. That's why we have a separate hand tool forum, to limit debate. Personally, I would prefer to use a power tool for anything I possibly can. Not because of the speed and efficiency, but because I am an engineer by education and trade, and not an artisan. I find it fascinating to figure out how to best automate a process, building jigs and developing methods that will get the job done. I guess you could call me a Normite.

Personally I find hand tools to be a necessary evil. I have a few very nice planes and chisels that I know how to sharpen and I use when I need them, but I usually don't have much fun with that. Every time I have to use a hand tool, I find myself contemplating how I could get this done with a machine.

Rob

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

#3

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY***

MikeW

>"That's why we have a separate hand tool forum, to limit debate."

heh, heh, heh...didn't work this time. They let me come and visit the, the, just what the heck is this side of WC?

I would prefer to view it that the hand tool forum offers a more focused flow of information more specifically related to hand tools.

Hi Ellis,

I think there are few hand tool purists. Most (my apologies to Stephen, Adam et al) hand tool workers have a power tool or two that gets used often. Some that get used less often. And I suspect some that get used quite often. I also believe that there are no real hard and fast delineation as to what to use and when as regards power tool or hand tools.

Well, there are most likely certain tasks which a given person will use a particular tool for that task in the main. For instance, though I have and use power tools, I will most likely always cut my rebates using a moving fillister plane. I will most likely use my bandsaw to resaw a nice piece of wood to make shop-sawn veneer.

That I have used my WoodRat for rebates and a hand-powered saw for veneer is simply a case of variety or the fickleness of my decision-making process at the time.

So generally, Ellis, I mostly choose which tools to use based upon what goals I have, the time constraints, motivation, or simple enjoyment for a given task. For me, that means plenty of hand tools, saving the few powered ones mostly for mundane work.

Take care, Mike

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

#4

Skewing the Survey

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I use hand tools exclusively because I don't own any power tools with forked tails.

I do have power tools, a foot powered treadle lathe and a Great Wheel lathe powered by an apprentice or assistant.

I let my apprentices and workers in my shop do the surfacing, good practice for them, less work for me.

I and a few others out there actually make 'hand made' woodwork and furniture, all other claims to be 'hand made*' need an astrisk.

Stephen

N.B. I responded on this side to keep the HAND TOOLS side, pure.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

#5

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY***

john lucas

>I choose which tools mostly due to speed or ease of the task. Most often this has to do with the size of the workpiece. I can't surface pieces shorter than 12 on my planer. Other tasks like making a tapered octagon on a bed post are simply quicker with the hand plane.

Hand sawing is a different matter. I used to do a lot to develop my skills but now I seldom pick one up unless it's a dovetail saw.

A lot of times it's a matter of which tool you are the most comfortable with. I rarely use my router dovetail jig so when I am just doing one drawer I'll do hand cut dovetails. If I'm going to do 6 I'll pull out the manual to the dovetail jig and "re-learn" how to use it.

I use a brace and bit a lot whenever I make a chair because it's much faster than setting up jigs and angles on the drill press.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

#6

JL

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY***

JL

>Depends on what you call a hand tool (ducking and running) :).

I usually size the plywood with a circular saw and rip it to width with the table saw. I usually cut the large boards with a dozuki and rip them to width with the table saw. For jointing, it depends on the size of the board. Some I joint using a joiner (large, long ones) and some I use a plane (smaller ones).

For spindles, legs and stretchers, I use the chainsaw to cut the logs to length and dimension them using hand tools (axes, wedges, riving knife, draw knife and spoke shaves).

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

#7

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY***

NickB

>It's mostly an issue of time for me. I'm a hobbyist, and have very limited time in the shop, so the fastest way wins (before I had a thicknessing planer and a jointer, I jointed and dimensioned by hand, but man, does it take a long time). So dimensioning is via jointer, thickness planer, table saw and power miter saw. If a hand tool is faster, then it gets the nod, but I've become much more power tool-centric as time has passed (and as the kid total has gone up to 3).

Nick

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

#8

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY***

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>For me it often depends on the "danger" of damage to an assembly or part when I have invested a lot of time or material. I am pretty casual about the method of roughing in projects - as they get farther along I become more cautious. For instance I will spend 10-15 minutes by useing my chisels to pare off a through tenon after glue-up where I might use a table saw or router earlier. I tend to really slow down as a project nears completion - use a lot more finesse - and hand tools. I'm not happy when I gouge or screw up then.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

#9

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY***

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I can say that my slection of tools to use for any given procedure have changed as I have transitioned from hobby woodworker to professional. As a hobbyist I had the luxury of time. Efficiency was not the goal...enjoyment was the goal. The tactile nature of woodworking I feel can be more fully enjoyed with hand tools and so I often would favor them just for the satisfaction factor.

I have now established a woodworking business and as with any business, time is money. My clients are unaware of the methods I use and are generally unconcerned about the hand tool/power tool equasion. That leaves the choice of tools up to me.

My choice is simple, choose the tools that do the best job in the most efficient way. Sometimes that means power tools and sometimes that means hand tools. If I have tenons that are slightly too thick then it is far most efficient for me to grab a shoulder plane than to set up a power tool to shave them down. No project goes out the door of my shop without having been built with a combination of hand tools and power tools. Experience tends to be the best judge of what tool selection to make and when.

Every so often my schedule allows me to slow down and enjoy the "zen moments" of woodworking. But for the most part it's good business for me to think of quality of result with efficiency as the goal.

Tom

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

#10

I'm a Neanderdabbler

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>and I suspect that applies to a fair percentage of us. I have a number of both tailed apprentices and hand tools and use both types with nearly everything I build. Even when it comes to things like surfacing a plank, I find it's a great deal more expedient to take the twist out with a scrub plane before running it through the planer. Fitting joints? Nothing works better than a plane and chisels.

For me, it's a matter of both economics and expediency. So many people have never learned the hand skills that would make a one-off job much cheaper (not to mention better) that their first choice is many situations is a power tool. Doesn't need to be that way. A number of years ago my ex-BIL who owns a production cabinet shop offered me a job because I build largely with hand methods. He has clients who want things made that way. Me, too.

Bruce, an old curmudgeon.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

#11

Hand Tools??.... whas' that.

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>I even mounted forked tails on my planes so they wouldn't be lonesome.

Ray - Tongue planted firmly.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

#12

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY***

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Whatever handy that works best

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

#13

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY***

Hank Knight

>Ellis, for the most part, I agree with Tommy Skaggs: I use the tool that does the best job in the most efficient way. The "best job" is a flexible concept and depends on what I'm building. The "best job" for a quickie jig or a piece of rough carpentry is not the same as the "best job" for a piece of furniture or cabinetry.

I generally rely on hand tools for fine fit and finish work - which often begins with power tools and ends with hand tools. But that's not always the case. Sometimes it's easier and quicker to pick up a hand tool for rough work than take time to set up a power tool for the job. In other cases, it might be easier and quicker to set up a power tool for the job, but I opt for hand tools to get the "look" I want. And then sometimes I just feel like doing the job with hand tools to enjoy the "Zen experience" Tommy spoke of.

Putting all of this together, there doesn't seem to be a crisp formula or set of rules that dictates when I use hand tools or power tools. It depends on the work, on how big a hurry I'm in, on how I feel at the time, on how confident I am in my skills with the tools and sometines on the look I want. Oh, I almost forgot - and sometimes on how recently I sharpened the hand tool I want to use.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

#14

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY***

Sgian Dubh

>There's an argument out there that if you don't have the equipment to work efficiently, you effectively pay for it anyway in your time and labour and general inefficiency.

For instance, take the basic process of flattening and squaring wood. An efficient business does it one pass with a power fed multi-spindle machine. Rough wood in at one end resulting in fully dimensioned and squared stock at the other.

A relatively inefficient business uses heavy duty hand fed power planers. There's a lot of work involved and the job takes four or five times as long.

Inefficient businesses do the job entirely with hand planes. What the multi-spindle machine does in ten seconds takes the hand tool worker perhaps two to four hours.

Is the argument I mentioned at the start right? Well, perhaps, in parts. It depends. Can you keep that �40,000 machine busy all day? How often do you need to plane wood square? Is speed always important? Only each woodworker, ie, either the business or the amateur can answer those questions. Slainte.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

#15

results oriented approach

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>I build stuff because either I need it or want it so I am interested in getting the job done. If I already own it, I use the tool that best accomplishes the task. In general hand tools are more precise and take more skill/experience to effectively use.

Nothing compares to hand tools for precisely removing small increments of wood. Hence, hand tools are the tools of choice for fitting. I don't buy the argument that a hand planed surface is superior to a sanded surface for the finishes I use. Never-the- less, I will hand plane a machine planed surface to remove glaze and ripples if it is small, just to avoid sanding dust. Large surfaces or jobs are machine sanded to save time. Sometimes if the number is small it is quicker to do it by hand- for example mortises and dovetails because there is no machine set up involved. This trade off assumes a proficiency with the hand tool approach. Hand tools are not always the cheapest approach.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

#16

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY***

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Some interesting points made there. And there in lies one of the exceptions. There is a market, especially on the east coast for hand made period furniture. There are customers who appreciate furniture made entirely by hand, using traditional methods, and are willing to pay for it. Certainly the labor hours are reflected in the price but there is a number of woodworkers who are making a living by working without electrons.

In my area of the country such patrons are few and far between. If I made furniture entirely with hand tools and charged what I needed for the effort I would never sell a single piece. Go figure.

T.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

#17

mortising

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>I have tried to place myself on this continuum by examining in detail how I approach making mortises. I own a horizontal mortiser which gets used, nice mortise chisels which get used, a drill press with bench chisels which is yet another method I use. I've even made through mortises simply by laminating four boards with a space between the two in the middle.

So much for labels. I seem to do better with hand planes and chisels than saws. As my projects get smaller and finer, I might wonder what all those machines are doing taking up valuable lumber storage space.