Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Sprayer for varnish?

Posts

Sprayer for varnish?

#1

Sprayer for varnish?

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot Idaho

>I have a lot of varnishing to do over the next few weeks. I have six knotty pine interior doors, and four sets of louvered pine closet doors to apply finish to, as well about 300 lineal feet of baseboard and other trim. My Wife has given the go-ahead to see about a sprayer. We are using regular old oil-based polyurethane so far, but I am open to suggestions.

I don't think I can afford an HVLP setup. I was wondering if a simple air sprayer with a small cup would work for this? The only spraying I've ever done before was using an airless sprayer to paint the house.

What would work for me at an economical price? Do you have any suggestions on products or process? Thanks!

Scott.

Re: Sprayer for varnish?

#2

Re: Sprayer for varnish?

Chuck Lenz

>Your asking the wrong people, everyone in here hates poly, well, except me. Nice to see someone from my old stomping grounds though, I use to live in Idaho Falls.

Re: Sprayer for varnish?

#3

I gave them a call . . .

s.mackay@worldnet.att.net

>awhile back to ask the same thing. Minwax & Verathane both pretty much said " don't do it ". Of course I'm sure their worry is liability but after several departments at each I was told that the brush on isn't designed to be applied by spray. Wether its mixing with air in the lines and spray head or a flamability concern down to that the finnish just would'nt come out right. They DID mention that the aresol can contents are engineered / mixed specificly for that application. Without a chemistry degree I called it even and brushed it on.

Re: Sprayer for varnish?

#4

Not true!

Tony - Memphis

>I like poly! I use it a lot. Lately, I have been using Rockler's gel poly. It goes on easy, spreads well, and the satin finish fits my taste. I would gladly challenge anyone to look at the stuff I have built and tell me which pieces have poly and which have lacquer or shellac! Even Phil Lowe has been known to throw a coat of poly on top of shellac on a tabletop or other highly used surface.

Tony

Re: Sprayer for varnish?

#5

Re: Sprayer for varnish?

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot Idaho

>Hi Chuck!

Idaho Falls is still there, only now they're acting more like Boise all the time! ;-)

Scott.

Re: Sprayer for varnish?

#6

Re: I gave them a call . . .

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot Idaho

>Sheesh! That'll take me forever! I've been rollering it on and following up with a brush to smooth it out, but that still takes a long time. And I know those louvered doors are going to be a bugger!

There's a particular look that pine gets with varnish. We've got a lot of 40 year old pine in the cabin already, and we want to stay with that look as much as possible. What we won't do to get a particular look! I guess I had better get started! ;-)

Thanks!

Scott.

Re: Sprayer for varnish?

#7

Re: Sprayer for varnish?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I spray Minwax poly often. I thin it about 50% with mineral spirits, naptha, turpentine etc. dependent on how fast I want it to dry. It sprays and flows very well. However no manufacturer of paint today is allowed to tell you to add thinner. This is due to the EPA VOC rules - thats why the "DO NOT ADD THINNER" warning is on the label. I add thinner if I am brushing, spraying or wiping it on. I have sprayed with a cheap off brand air bleeder gun and a Binks auto paint type spray gun - both did a reasonable good job, Obviously the Binks is a better gun. These are conventional air spray guns - I have a 60 gal Campbell Hausfeld 10 SCFM @ 100 psi compressor. It doesn't work too hard when I'm spraying. I think you will do fine - if you have a large enough compressor. I sprayed a door (interior) last year, had to give it three coats to achieve the thickness I wanted but turned out great.

Re: Sprayer for varnish?

#8

Re: Sprayer for varnish?

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Why not a Wagner airless? I just got the $129 model at Lowes to shoot exterior semi-xparent and solid stains on a new cedar fence. Don't see why it wouldn't do your job as well.

Clint

Re: Sprayer for varnish?

#9

But I DID cut the time by a third . . .

s.mackay@worldnet.att.net

>well, maybe less. Put on her favorite Chick-Flick and hand her a brush. Your right about " that look " though. With seven or eight coats on it sure seems worth it ! Well, after its done that is !

Re: Sprayer for varnish?

#10

Re: Sprayer for varnish?

Paul Dwight

>If you already own a decent-size compressor, there are several budget priced options available. Harbor Freight sells a gravity feed HVLP gun for under $100 that some people have had good results from. Porter Cable sells a similar unit for a little more money and it's OK -- I got good results from mine but I had to fiddle around for a while with different viscosities, air pressure, air volume, fan size, distance from gun to surface, etc. In my experience, better guns can get good results over a broader range of variables, which makes them easier and quicker to set up. You might also want to look around at www.spraygunworld.com -- they have a broad range of prices and make specific recommendations for different situations (for example, spraying wood finishes with an undersized compressor).

If you don't already own a decent compressor, then the least expensive route into spray finishing is probably a turbine system. I think Harbor Freight still sells a little turbine with a bleeder gun for around $100. Again, some people report good getting good results with this thing. Woodcraft sells a two-stage turbine system with a gun that looks to be much better than the HF unit for around $300.

I used to spray Minwax oil-based poly all the time. As someone said earlier, it has to be thinned quite a bit to be sprayable. With all that thinner in the mix it takes more coats to build up a decent film. If you thin with mineral spirits it will take forever to dry -- use a faster thinner like naptha or acetone. The biggest drawback I found with spraying oil-based poly (other than needing a bunch of coats to build up a film) was that the overspray was a sticky mess. With lacquer, shellac and a lot of waterborne finishes the overspray will mostly dry in the air and settle as dust. With solvent-based poly, the overspray was still wet when it settled out of the air so it formed a sticky layer on everything.

I've switched to waterborne topcoats. The best of the waterborne finishes look good, are incredibly durable and spray like a dream. Cleanup is very easy. No worries about fires or explosions. Less impact on the environment.

Good luck! -- Paul

Re: Sprayer for varnish?

#11

First

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>You'll have to thin the finish to get it to properly atomize. I have sprayed Minwax gloss poly forget the semi or matte for spray application) with a cheap HVLP gun after thinning it with 30% naptha. Levels out well on horizontal surfaces (will sag like Grampa's, um, well, whatever, on vertical surfaces |;-}} ) provided you're not working in heat above 80* + humidity above 65% or in direct sunlight (skins over too fast). Do note, however, that you should only mix what you'll use in a single session and do NOT return the mix to the original can. Naptha causes poly to autopolymerize and the next morning you're likely to have a whole can of "jello".

With the product thinned, I would not try it in a turbine-driven gun because those units warm the finish and tend to flash the solvents leading to orange peel.

If you've got a compressor that puts out more the 3 CFM, a cheapo Harbor Freight HVLP gun (# 45001-3NDH or 46719-1NDH @ $40) might be worth the risk. Between the 2, take the top feed.

You will have to clean the gun with solvent immediately when done. The sfuff will clog ports and stuff in short order.

Good luck.

Re: Sprayer for varnish?

#12

Re: Sprayer for varnish? *LINK*

Steve in Chicagoland

>I too am considering buying a HPLV spray gun for water based topcoats. However, I am really having a difficult time deciding which gun to buy. There are lots of choices in a variety of price ranges. Check out the selection and discussions on compressor requirements at the link below.

I really should get on the ball and pick one, because the truth is that most guns will be a large improvement over hand application.

Thanks!

Steve


Spray Gun World

Re: Sprayer for varnish?

#13

A different take

Robert W - aka nailshooter

>As contractor I have been spraying poly as needed, specified or required now for well over a year with my Fuji Q4 HVLP. I don't have any problems with heat generated by the turbine affecting any finishes, even in South Texas.

But I don't thin with Naptha, either. In my case, I thin any of the polys that I shoot about 10% with mineral spirits (much less VOC than naptha!) and fire away.

One of the hobby guys I know just bought the little Harbor Freight HVLP setup for about $50. He thins by about 25% or so, but that little single stage shoots his Home Depot purchases really well. This is about the third person I have put onto that little rig and everyone has been really happy.

My Fuji Q4 with all bells, whistles, extra whip, extra gun, and 3 separate air caps - $1400. Honestly with some tutoring, they turn out a pretty damn good finish with that little HF model. This is the one I am talking about:

http://tinyurl.com/2w29dw

I actually bought and use this next gun. I is great because it has a large capacity, and I bought it when it was on sale so I wouldn't have to take my turbine out to the job when I wanted to do a bunch of priming or staining. Since the compressor was already on the job powering the nailguns, this seemed like a good idea. But I liked the finish it left and the easy of cleaning the gun so much I use it a lot now. This gun is affordable enough you could also upgrade your compressor if you needed to:

http://tinyurl.com/y24n6g

If you have a lot to do, make sure you get a gun that will hold a fair amount of finish. The little detail guns are a major pain as you will never get your rhythm since you will be refilling all the time since some of them hold only 4 - 6oz. Remember, you won't be filling these cups all the way to the top. Also, they have really small aircaps (some as small as .7 mm) and that is much to small for a resin finish.

Urethane is easy and forgiving to spray. I even spray doors in the upright position, assembled cabinets, etc. If you buy new equipment, set it up and try it out on a lot of scrap before firing away on your doors, etc.

Good luck!

Robert

Re: Sprayer for varnish?

#14

I used a garden sprayer

Charles Sharp

>When I refinished my frame and panel garage door I used a garden sprayer and a brush. I was spraying Thompsons Advance which I recall was a water base finish. It's worth a try, and garden sprayers are cheap (like me).

Re: Sprayer for varnish?

#15

Thanks!

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot Idaho

>Thank you all for your great advice! Especially Mark and Robert for those suggestions at Harbor Freight! I've got to talk it over with the Boss, but I may be up and spraying by this weekend!

You guys are the best!

Scott.