Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Motor and Magnetic Starter

Posts

Motor and Magnetic Starter

#1

Motor and Magnetic Starter

Kevin Rabenaldt

>I decided to upgrade my electric motor on my Sears tablesaw to 1-1/2 hp with a magnetic starter. I can find the motors ok, but where do you find the proper magnetic starter switch? I find switches that cost $200 and up but they do not look like the ones you see on tablesaws.

Kevin

Re: Motor and Magnetic Starter

#2

Rick L

Re: Motor and Magnetic Starter

Rick L

>Grizzly and Woodworkers Supply sell mag startes for under $100. An option is the safestart plug.

http://www.jdsproducts.com/tech.cfm Doesn't have overload tprtection but it will keep require resetting if the power goes off.

Re: Motor and Magnetic Starter

#3

Re: Motor and Magnetic Starter

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>The $200+ (+++) units would work fine - but they are really rated for industrial use. If it were me, I would look for a starter on Ebay- If you stay with either Square D or Allen Bradley, spare parts are very easy to obtain (although expensive). The 3 phase units will work fine - you just use 2 of the poles for your 220V motor feed. If you can find one with the right rating (motor amps) you will also have very good motor overload protection. New heaters (the overload "breaker/fuse") cost about $30 - $40 each for exact protection. These are available for either the Allen Bradley or Square D at almost any industrial electrical supplier. The coil (part that pulls in the contactor is quite expensive so be sure you purchase one that has the correct voltage you are using for the control circuit. You will also need - if you do not already have - a start stop button - momentary contact for both buttons. The magnetic contractors are wired in so that when the start switch is pressed the contactor "latches" and is held in with the voltage only. This lets the contactor open immediately if power is interrupted to the equipment. When power comes back on, the saw will not restart until the "start" button" is pushed. You can also wire other emergency switches in the "latch" circuit to stop the saw if you desire. The industrial motor starters are very heavy duty, and should last the life of your saw plus in normal use.

Re: Motor and Magnetic Starter

#4

What is the benefit of a mag. switch?

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>I have never learned what benefit a mag. switch provides. Perhaps someone can enlighten me. I just used a heavy duty switch on motors of this size and smaller. They seem to have worked for about 20+ years, and they sure cost a lot less.

Re: Motor and Magnetic Starter

#5

Re: What is the benefit of a mag. switch?

Kneale Brownson in Northern MI

>The benefits are the safety features like the motor won't start running again after a power outage and overload protection.

Re: Motor and Magnetic Starter

#6

Safety...

John in New Mexico

>The switch will actually turn off if there is a brief power failure. That way your saw does not re-start just when you let go of the board to go check the breaker or whatever. Out here at least, 10 second power failures are fairly common during the summer due to intense thunderstorms - which is the only reason I'm aware of the need for magnetic switches. There may be other reasons as well of which I'm not aware.

I only have one of these switches, it came on my bandsaw. I just don't use the machines during thunderstorms.

John

Re: Motor and Magnetic Starter

#7

Re: Benefits of a magnatic starter.

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Bill, responding as a manufacturing engineer (retired)- there are several benefits - 1) Switch life - on a larger motor the arcing causes failure of the contacts in a manual on/off switch much earlier than the contacts of a fast acting magnetic switch - when the duty cycle (on / off) is multiple times a day this is an issue. The contacts can be replaced easily on motor contactors. For home use it is not as much of a concern.

2) Motor protection, the motor start contactors have a "heater/breaker" in each line. This is rated in fractions of an amp over the maximum run current of the motor. As it is a "heater" it will start a motor with high inrush current, but will trip out if the motor is pulling 5% (or less) more than the normal maximum current required. Thus it will trip /open if the motor is just slightly overloaded due to bad bearings or other causes. This allows you to repair the unit without replacing a burnt up motor. 3) One of the most important features is the safety. If a power interruption occurs, the start / run circuit will open. If your in the middle of sawing a board and the motor dies, with a standard stop / start switch, the saw could restart at any time the power is restored. This could be real bad if your just starting to get the board off the saw and have it bound up on the blade. Or if you clear the saw and forget to shut it off, you might be in the wrong place when the power comes back on. The above reasons are why 99+% of all motors used in industry (and I'll bet all the sawmill's equipment) are equipped with motor start contractors.

Re: Motor and Magnetic Starter

#8

There's lots of possibilities for mag starters

Forrest Addy

>The whole idea of a motor starter is to provide safe reliable across the line motor starting, motor over-current protection, under-voltage protection when so porvided, low voltage operator stations, and accidental re-start protection. People are wise to install such undustrial electrical apparatus on their home shop woodworkig equipment. NEMA and IEC rated starters are intended for hundreds of thousans fo full load starts and are very reliable for the protections they offer and they provide means of adding any number of additional electrical contacts to support complex interlock and control circuitry.

There's lots of possibilities for mag starters. There are full blown mag sterters which consists of a contactor, an overload relay, and if you wish a pushbutton control station right on the enclosure. In the small motor applications usited for the home shop a NEMA rated motor starter can cost $200 and up if bought new from an electrical supply house.

Some scrounging and shopping can save you a lot of money.

Don't shy away from a used starter such as a take out from a HVAC shop or a motor shop. So lont as the overload heaters are selected in installed to suit your motor a used starter (cleaned up and inspected, certainly) is as good as a new one and for a lot less money.

There are also integrated motor starters such as this one from Grizzly. It uses magnetic holding so your equipment is protected from inadvertent re-starts if lost power is restored.

Try this one:

http://www.grizzly.com/products/G4571

There are other choices from Grainger and other sources.