Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

OT: Finding a Legal Case Question

Posts

OT: Finding a Legal Case Question

#1

OT: Finding a Legal Case Question

Barry Irby

>I live in Virginia. My son made an improper left turn and got T-boned for his trouble. He was charged with "failure to yield the right of way". His pickup was totaled. His Insurance paid for everything.

I told him to plead "no contest" and to ask the judge to dismiss the charges or reduce them. This was based on the fact that he went through an intersection that was "the worst one in Virginia or certainly Colonial Heights" (according the judge). He pointed out that the other car did not have it's lights on in the rain and that they must have been speeding Based on the fact that both cars were totaled. Add to that that the intersection is actually under construction or reconstruction because it has such a poor record.

On court day, the judge looked like a bobble head doll acknowledging that he was aware of the intersection and that it was the worst one anyone knew of. He asked my son why he should not be found guilty and my son mentioned that both cars were totaled and he thought the other people contributed by speeding and not have their lights on. (speed limit was 35. The judge snapped that there was a "very interesting case" that indicated you could not tell how fast a car was going by how much damage it did. Then asked "if they were going a 100 MPH do you think that give you the right to pull out in front of them?" My son said "No." The judge fined him $60 and Cost.

I am curious to see the case the judge referenced. Does anyone know how to find it?

Re: OT: Finding a Legal Case Question

#2

JL

Re: OT: Finding a Legal Case Question

JL

>Go to the University of Richmond Law School library. They might be able to help you there.

Re: OT: Finding a Legal Case Question

#3

Re: Finding a Legal Case

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Barry,

There are legal-tech firms that specialize in accident investigation and reconstruction. They will be most familiar with a case development such as you describe. Look up a PI law firm in your area and ask for a referral. It's not my field, but I've spoken with such people who propose to be able to tell, from the vehicles involved and the damage sustained, just how fast each was going at the point of contact. In the end, however, the judge was right. Your son got a ticket for the turn which had nothing to do with the other car or the accident. The other guy could have been ticketed for no lights, speed, etc., and you son's being in the intersection would have made no difference to that charge either.

mm

Re: OT: Finding a Legal Case Question

#4

Re: Finding a Legal Case

Barry Irby

>Mark, I am mostly just hacked. Colonial Heights has a well deserved reputation as a speed trap.

All they had to do to prevent this was change the timing of the lights. They very well know the intersection is dangerous and poorly constructed. I think they like the revenue.

I live about ten miles up the road and have gotten a variety of tickets there over the last thirty years. I conclude they have no interest in public safety. God help us if there is a terrorist cell in town. They could operate with impunity unless they unless they park in a handicapped space.

I could go on for hours, but I won't. I have answer though. I don't shop in Colonial Heights anymore.

Re: OT: Finding a Legal Case Question

#5

Re: Finding a Legal Case

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>It's been maybe 40 years ago, I got a traffic ticket. I don't remember what for. The fine was maybe worth 3 or 4 hours of what I made at a part time afterschool job. My father had the best advice for me that he could offer. 'Bite your tongue. Pay the lady. Don't do that again. You got off easy.'

The purpose of the court system, in the US at least, is to change behavior. The purpose of the fine is to get your son's attention. There is all sorts of extenuating circumstance in peoples' lives, but the rules are pretty clear. So don't break the rules, if at all possible. That's what the bobbleheaded judge is trying to say.

And that may be the thing you need to tell your son. Doesn't matter who is 'more wrong'. Good news is that both walked away, even if the cars are bent. Learn the lesson, son. Don't do that again.

And Dad, someone has to be the parent here. You're elected. ;-)

Re: OT: Finding a Legal Case Question

#6

Your son 100% at fault

Atwerz

>Universally a person who intends to make a left turn must stop and remained stopped until all oncoming traffic that is so close as to constitute a hazard, has cleared the intersection. Foremost and period. Other guy has the right of way. Your son failed to yield to his right of way. No other factor takes away from that duty, drunk, speeding etc.. The ticket is a criminal case and son is guilty. Injecting negligence and fault words into the discussion, you are talking civil as opposed to criminal rules. Son is clearly negligent. Other driver may also be negligent if speeding, drunk etc. In civil case each drivers damages are reduced by their own % of negligence. Its called comparative negligence. Easy to solve this one. Hey I had 3 teenage girl drivers.

Re: OT: Finding a Legal Case Question

#7

Re: OT: Finding a Legal Case Question

DB

>Sometimes it does not take very much to total a vehicle. Depends on age of vehicle, cost of replacement of parts, and labor.

My father-in-law went off the road and sideswipped the gaurdrail at about 20 MPH, in his 5 year old car. The only parts that had to be replaced were the front bumper, front fender, and front and rear bumper cap. The rest could be pounded out easily. Of course it would need to be repainted. The insurance totaled the vehicle. If the bumper did not need replaceing then it would not have been totaled.

I bought the car from him for the scrap value and put on $500 worth of new parts from the dealer and my wife is still driving it. Still needs a new paint job.

Re: OT: Finding a Legal Case Question

#8

Re: Your son 100% at fault

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>A few years ago I was at an intersection where the road I was on had to stop for traffic on a state highway. On the other side of the highway sat a police car. I was going straight across the intersection, he had his left turn signal on to turn in front of me. As soon as it was clear to go across I started to do so and had to jam on the brakes because the "other" driver pulled across my path. Had I done the same to him I would rightfully gotten a ticket. The rules of the road are not as universal as you might think. BTW, in recounting this story since, you would be surprised at the number of people who don't know which of us had the right of way.

Re: OT: Finding a Legal Case Question

#9

I like your solution!!

Chad Pearson

>I received a speeding ticket in South Carolina some years back. It was on a little used highway that feeds into Hilton Head Island. I was between two local concrete trucks. As the road goes from a 55 to a 40 MPH zone I get a ticket. Keep in mind that I'm in the process of slowing down (from 55) and I am bracketed by the two trucks front and rear. The local constable had found himself a nice little speed trap and was only interested in getting tourist dollars. If he was interested in public safety he would have ticketed the multi-ton trucks going the exact same speed as I was.

My solution was the same as yours...I don't spend my tourist dollars in South Carolina anymore. On my spring vacation I take my family elsewhere.

Re: OT: Finding a Legal Case Question

#10

My area too......

Michael Stadulis, in Gloucester County, NJ

>God help us if there is a terrorist cell in town. They could operate with impunity unless they unless they park in a handicapped space.

-Mike

The local police used to sit on the interstate and have a speed trap. Obviously not in the interest of public safety as we have state police for that.........

Re: OT: Finding a Legal Case Question

#11

Since we're comparing speed traps...

John in New Mexico

>I've seen the police in Albuquerque station a couple of cops on a pedestrian overpass on the freeway with radar guns and radios, with about 5 motorcycle cops just on the other side to pull over people who were speeding. Lucky for me, my horrible old vehicles can barely amble up to the speed limit on the interstate.

John

Re: OT: Finding a Legal Case Question

#12

Re: OT: Finding a Legal Case Question

Barry Irby

>Thanks for letting me vent.

I don't know about comparative negligence, not sure we use the concept in VA.

I do know that my son was wrong, he did make the left turn, on a green light. I'm sure he got the message. Not sure the $60 fine is what delivered the message though. Might have been the totaled vehicle, or the air bag slapping him around, or perhaps the cracked rib. Just not sure the court system did itself proud here.

Colonial Heights has been a speed trap so long that it got written up in the Readers Digest. It WAS a poor little town. Then they built the mall. 600 stores and growing. Lots of revenue. Twenty years and they have not outgrown the speed trap mentality. They somehow decided the traffic in the mall should flow "the other way" so they set it up with "left of way" rather than right of way. They don't seem to understand or care that they created hundreds of accidents, they just collect the revenue. If you park in a handicapped spot they will ticket you and collect $200. If you get robbed in the parking lot they tell you, you are on private property and you need to take it up with Mall Security.

They have a side street that leads to a neighboring community that I use occasionally. The main street has a speed limit of 35, but the side street is marked at 25 for about a quarter mile, then goes back to 35. There is a tree next to the 25MPH sign and the local cops carry a bungee cord to pull a limb down in front of the sign and set up radar. They did it so much that there was a ring around the limb. The locals hate it but are afraid to object. I stopped there one day and asked the owner if he minded if I pruned his tree. He gave me permission and, with the cop watching, I cut the limb off. I cleaned up my mess, walked over to the cop and tried to give him his bungee back. He would not admit it was his. Left it dangling from the limb. It will be years before the limb will block the sign again.

Re: OT: Finding a Legal Case Question

#13

Re: Taint so

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>In Indiana the traffic that arrives at a 4 way stop is required to move in the order in which they arrived. If I come to the stop first I have the right-away even if I turn left in front of the other traffic. There is also a law in Indiana called the "last clear chance" that holds you at fault if you hit another vehicle (or person etc.) if it was obvious you could have avoided the accident by stopping or swerving. It is normally considered the other persons fault if you get hit in the rear, but I personally have seen a friend cited and the accident attributed to him when he pulled out right in front of another vehicle. He was in his lane when struck, but the cop ticketed him.

Re: OT: Finding a Legal Case Question

#14

Re: OT: Finding a Legal Case Question

s.mackay@worldnet.att.net

>I can only reference my own case. I did the same thing but the Dude on the motor cycle WAS screaming along at 80 AND DWI. He covered that one block when I spotted him in about two seconds! Still did'nt change the fact I pulled the turn. Considering what COULD have happened I paid the $ 60.00 and called myself lucky. I thought if I'd gotten huffy about it the judge could have spanked me a lot harder.

Re: OT: Finding a Legal Case Question

#15

Great response!

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>Although I couldn't have articulated it nearly as well, I completely agree with that sentiment.

In the Kane County, Illinois, courthouse, where I had to go to once years ago to pay a ticket, they had a sign on the wall that said something on the order of:

Don't be upset.
Think of the times you didn't get caught.

Rod

Re: OT: Finding a Legal Case Question

#16

Speed Traps.

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>Or as I've always called them, revenue enhancement opportunities. AAA used to keep a list of known revenue enhancement locations, details of pertinent ones they included in the Trip Tik you used to get years ago.

Probably the most famous one was Ludowici, Georgia. It was on US 301, a major artery for Florida bound tourists. The highway makes a 90° turn in the middle of town and there is a traffic light there. Rumor has it that an officer with a control for the light would sit in a second floor room of the building directly in front of the "T" intersection and switch the light when a non-local was approaching with such timing that they couldn't stop in time. The accomplice in the black & white was waiting (eagerly) to write up another collection notice.

More recently the perhaps #1 speed trap has been the legendary town of Waldo, Florida, also, coincidentally, on US 301. I don't know all of the details but there was a note in our local paper the other day that the Waldo police chief had just retired, the newsworthiness of which was his long time speed trap operations. It is unknown whether that function will continue.

Whoever mentioned the locals on the interstate reminds me of at least three areas in particular in Florida where that happens: Suwannee County deputies patrol I-75 near Jasper regularly. I'm very happy that crime in Suwannee County is so low that they have time for that.

Brevard County does I-95 a lot around Cocoa, too. Not Titusville or Melbourne—just Cocoa. Makes you wonder, doesn't it?

And if anyone remembers that case five or six years ago where a Dade County police officer was pulled over on the Turnpike (supposedly the domain of the Florida Highway Patrol—they even have a special Troop for it, "K") and in which all sorts of stupidity including rampant racism came into play, that stop was conducted by an Orange County deputy. Must be Orlando PD has all the rest of the city under control. But guess where Troop K headquarters is? Yep. Orlando. You'd think they wouldn't need any local help on the Turnpike.

With the internet, there are a number of sites that list known perpetrators of revenue enhancement—a simple search will yield hours of good reading. Which reminds me, I haven't looked at any of them since I moved up here. I'd better get cracking.

Rod

Re: OT: Finding a Legal Case Question

#17

Re: Speed Traps.

Stuart Hough

>I used to live in Fla, and when travelling up I-75 there was another little town, Landover I believe, that had annexed a piece of land that crossed the interstate, sort of a little triangle that crossed approximately 1/4 mile of I-75. There was no entrance or exit to that section. The Landover city coffers were filled to the brim with revenue from the mandatory court visits, most of which were held within 2 hours of your citation. The Police would be parked at the very beginning of their 1/4 mile, and would pull anywhere from 50-100 cars a day for "speeding", as their section was a 55mph area(due to the close proximity of a town....the old law). There was no warning that the speed limit was being reduced, as occurred everywhere else. The speed trap was featured on an old "60 Minutes" program about 15 years ago. What finally stopped the activity was the ruling ofthe State Legislature that the town had ZERO jurisdiction due to the fact there were no on/off ramps on that stretch of interstate.

Re: OT: Finding a Legal Case Question

#18

Re: Taint so

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>What you say is true of a 4 way stop.

But it is my understanding that where there are stop signs on opposite sides of a road, such as side streets or county roads crossing a highway, the person going straight has the right of way once it is clear to cross.

It's the same at a stop light. Driver A may have arrived at the intersection just as the turned red, and driver B may have arrived seconds before it turned green. But if driver B is going straight he has the right of way over driver A wanting to turn left. Driver A doesn't get to cut off driver B just because he was at the intersection first.

As far 4 way stops are concerned, the concept seems to be WAY over the head of an awful lot of drivers.

Re: OT: Finding a Legal Case Question

#19

4-way stops

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>I agree. I tend to be really polite at 4-way stops, but my patience has limits. When I see two or three in sequence mess it up, my attitude changes from first come, first served to he who hesitates is last.

I also use the principle of blocking to my advantage. I think I must be in the 99th percentile on that because I rarely see anyone else do it. If the person opposite me is first, and someone crossing is second, with me third, I'll go when the first guy does because the second guy can't go while he's in the intersection anyway. Out of sequence technically, but no one loses a turn, and it's far more efficient.

Rod

Re: OT: Finding a Legal Case Question

#20

Right of way

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>Although there's supposed to be a uniform traffic code, there may be some differences between states on some things. That said, I've always been of the belief that (4-ways excepted—discussed below) traffic turning left must always yield the right of way to oncoming traffic. I've believed that for 45 years but I'll change if I have to…I guess.

Rod

Re: OT: Finding a Legal Case Question

#21

Hey Barry

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Barry,

Having raised seven sons, I am familiar with your situation, as several of them have acted similarly. I kicked them in the ass a few times, used the "wire brush" liberally, and enjoined them to use their brains every time they got into a car. I also made them pay for damages, most of the time. To be sure, there are always some extenuating circumstances, but failure to think isn't one of them. It may seem harsh. So be it.

George

Re: OT: Finding a Legal Case Question

#22

Re: No kidding there

Dave Arbuckle, Plano, TX

>If the person opposite me is first, and someone crossing is second, with me third, I'll go when the first guy does because the second guy can't go while he's in the intersection anyway.

That technique only makes sense, moves traffic roughly twice as fast and no one loses due to it. You'd think it was rocket surgery considering how few you see doing it.

Re: OT: Finding a Legal Case Question

#23

You mean it's not...

Jason Roehl in Mulberry, IN

>...rocket science? Huh.

I USED to be really polite at 4-way stops...until I was an experienced enough driver to figure out that most people on the road didn't know the rules for 4-ways. As it was once explained to me, "First come, first served, ties go to the right." But when I figured out that people didn't know that, and everyone was just trying to be polite and let the other guy go first...I decided I would get there sooner if I was "the other guy"--every time. I was tired of being in polite contests...I would be right in letting the other person go first, but they were trying to be polite and let me go first. So now I just let people be wrong, because I can go first!

Jason (big-time user of the "blocking" method).

Re: OT: Finding a Legal Case Question

#24

Re: OT: Rant -Engineering mags had a series

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>on the police use of speed traps. Apparently one of the editors or vips of one of the mags was "got". The mag (can't remember if it was Machine Design or one of the others I got at work) did a study of what the police was doing. They went through several cities and states and dug up many statistics. It would appear that our "Public Servants", as they like to refer to themselves would issue a lot of tickets in areas where accidents occur and fatalities and property damage is high. "Taint so", as the study developed, - it was published in several issues - the high accident areas appeared to be virtually ignored. The bulk of the tickets were issued in area's that were quite safe, usually in an area where speed limits changed and the limits often were far lower than needed for safe driving. As I said, this study covered a vast area and it appeared the bulk of the tickets were just revenue based. So much for the slogan "serve and protect". Don't know how this can be changed - sure needs to be as we are paying people to protect us and in many cases they are robbing us themselves, with official approval. Many other countries - including France - have removed many automobiles and put officers back on a walking beat. From the results, it appears this lowers crime, prevents assaults and murders and protects property. Sure would like to see it put in effect in the USA. I live in a small city of about 18,000. Our police officers all have high speed pursuit vehicles (same as the state police), these get lousy gas mileage and are needed like a hole in the head. The entire city is less than 5 miles - corner to corner. It is one of my major rants that they drive a high priced, high maintenance, low mileage vehicle to patrol the town. Anyone breaking into a residence or conducting an illegal act at night can see the car coming for a 1/4 mile - Never heard of one of the patrols catching a crook. Rant off

Re: OT: Finding a Legal Case Question

#25

Re: OT: Finding a Legal Case Question

Thomas Williams Columbus, Ohio

>Barry,

ask an attorney. Sent you an email.