Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Somewhat OT - House moving

Posts

Somewhat OT - House moving

#1

Somewhat OT - House moving

Jerry Nicholson

>Does anyone here understand the economics of moving a house? The house I had built in 1961 and lived in for 38 years is being moved 40 miles. The chimney has been removed (3 ft x 9 ft x 24 feet of masonry), the brick veneer is being stripped off, and the front porch is being chopped off. The remaining structure, including garage, is 75 feet long and 34 feet wide including the eaves. It will be 15 to 16 feet high plus the height of the moving vehicle. It will be necessary to cross over or under several major highways. This is a well built house (I know, I created the plans and specifications) with 2 x 12 floor joists and oak floors but I just don't understand how it would be cheaper to move the house than it would be to tear it apart stick by stick and build a new house from that good old 1961 lumber. I would think the moving process would cause enough sheet rock problems to make it necessary to tear out the sheet rock and start over again.

Jerry, who is puzzled

Re: Somewhat OT - House moving

#2

Re: Somewhat OT - House moving

Barry Irby

>About twenty years ago, I moved 18 houses. At the time you could not move them over three miles and you could not go over or under a major bridge. It was quite a logistics problem.

They were building a section of interstate through a neighborhood and I bought a number of them. I bought some for as little as $250 and up to $4500. Paying more allowed me to "cherry pick" and get the ones that were easier to move. (Small compact ranchers). I bought brick veneer ranchers and stripped the brick off, Frame ranchers, and even several tri-levels. Turned one rancher into a two story becasue I had a hill side lot.

Paid about $6000 to $8000 to move them, plus maybe $4000 in additional materials.

I owned some lots with-in the striking distance and valued them at about $8000, so I had aobut $25,000 in each one. At that time they were worth about $50,000. I still own two of them and they are now worth closer to $125 to 150,000. Wish I still owned all of them.

The first three I moved, I fixed the sheet rock damage with one gallon of drywall mud between them.

The distance of the move did not matter much once you got the house loaded except for the logistics of moving it past the obstacles.

As a sort of PS, one of the movers that moved them for me was Expert House Movers. I saw them recintly on the MegaMovers show and they have been in the Guiness book of records twice since then. The moved a Lighthouse and an Opera house. I had been wondering if they were still around.

Re: Somewhat OT - House moving

#3

Re: Somewhat OT - House moving

Phil Thien

>Why are you moving it and why so far?

Re: Somewhat OT - House moving

#4

Re: Somewhat OT - House moving

Jerry Nicholson

>We sold the house over six years ago. The area is being cleared (destroyed?) for commercial development and patio homes. The guy we talked to bought our former home, the one next door, and the farm house that the original owner of the quarter section lived in. He is moving our old home and the house next door to his land near a lake and I think his estimate of 40 miles might be a bit optimistic. If it had been me trying to move it that far, I think I would have taken it apart and built a new house from the old lumber.

When we had the house built in 1961, we were 2 miles outside the city limits on a two lane county road. Now the location is several miles inside the city limits and the road has been turned into a 4 lane artery.

Jerry

Re: Somewhat OT - House moving

#5

Prety simple math

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>Tearing a house apart stick by stick would require 2-3 times the labor of putting it together in the first place. Then you would have to reassemble all the pieces back into their original position within the structure, so again you would have at least 1-1/2 times the labor to build the house frame as originally. You would also lose portions of the materials due to the effort to take things apart. All the dry wall and the majority of the wiring would be lost as would flooring and roofing materials. Unless the house were historically significiant I wouldn't see that taking it apart and putting it back together would ever be less than moving it or building a new house with new materials from the old plans.

Lee

Re: Somewhat OT - House moving

#6

I agree, plus…

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>…I'm not nearly as impressed with 1960s lumber as Jerry is. If it was 1900s lumber, maybe. I would think move it as a whole or forget it altogether.

By the way, insofar as material loss is concerned in a complete dismantling, I would be concerned with the loss of integrity of the lumber where it was toenailed (if it was). Pretty hard to take toenailed pieces apart without some destruction.

Rod
who has zero empirical evidence to back up any of the foregoing.

Re: Somewhat OT - House moving

#7

Likely toe-nailed..

Jerry Nicholson

>and I would a lot rather have the 1960s douglas fir dimensional lumber than the garbage they are selling now.

Having the house that I raised all my children in moved away doesn't bother me too much but I am really perturbed about how that entire neighborhood is being destroyed by developers. Hundreds of nice trees have been ripped out from along the creek bank.

Re: Somewhat OT - House moving

#8

Re: 60's Lumber

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I built a home in 1963, I would have to say you would be very hard pressed to find that grade lumber anywhere today. This was a "precut" home, the only really prepared lumber was the hip roof rafters and floor joists. We were allowed to return any lumber we deemed unsuitable. We did not use any lumber with bark inclusions, none that were bowed or warped more than 1/4" in 8 foot, we did not use any with large knots - most (probably 95%) were knot free. The 2X4's were 1 5/8 X 3 5/8. There was plywood furnished for the layer under the inlaid linoleum in the kitchen & bath. This was B/C grade 3/4" (true 3/4). The plywood was at least on a par with todays cabinet grade, other than it being a softwood. The sub-floor and roof sheeting was furnished as random lengths of 1 X 12 spruce or DF, most ranged in length from 12 to 24', this was applied diagonally. The flooring in the entire house was 3/4" thick white oak (unfinished). The only product, as I remember, that I would consider inferior to todays products, was the sheeting for the exterior walls, it was an "insulboard" which I would not use today, although the house still looks very good. The siding was 8" cedar with vertical redwood for the front exposure. I don't believe we returned over a half pickup load of material for all reasons, and the retired pattern maker who helped build the house was very particular.