Re: finishing question
Paul Dwight
>Will this piece get the same kind of use and abuse that kitchen cabinets normally see? If so, a finish like tung oil or Danish oil probably would not provide enough protection from oil, grease, food stains, water, etc.
You could start with the tung oil and, after it's fully cured, apply a topcoat for durability. Substituting a coat of dewaxed shellac in place of the tung oil would give you a similar look without the long cure time of the oil.
For the topcoat, many good products are available. If you're set up to spray finishes, NC lacquer or one of the Target waterborne products would be a good choice. My current favorite topcoat is General Finishes High Performance Polyurethane, a waterbased poly that does very well whether brushed or sprayed. The Satin version of this product is pretty low-luster and might be just what you're looking for -- not too far from an "in the wood" oil finish.
For the butcher block counter top, I'm not clear whether you expect knives to be used on it. If it's going to be used as a cutting board, you will want to avoid any type of film-forming finish. No clear film-forming finish will survive being used on a cutting board without becoming scratched and cut, and once the film is broken and water gets to the wood, the film will break away from the wood and you'll end up with bits of finish in your food. Probably not a health risk, but certainly not appetizing -- and the counter top would look awful, to boot. If it's going to be used as a cutting surface, then it should see an oil finish, only. Lot of folks use mineral oil on cutting boards. Pure tung oil would probably be fine, too, but I would avoid anything that contains metallic driers.
If the countertop isn't going to have knives used on it, then I guess you'd be looking for a film-forming finish similar to what you'd use on a kitchen table. For high-wear surfaces like this, I think you really need a cross-linking finish. Two-part conversion varnish would be great, if you can find it and if you're set up to spray. The best of the modern waterborne finishes are nearly as durable, though, and are much safer and easier to use. Examples would be Fuhr 255 (though this stuff can take weeks to fully cross-link) or one of the Target Emtech products.
Good luck! -- Paul