Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Honey says get a jointer, which one?

Posts

Honey says get a jointer, which one?

#1

Honey says get a jointer, which one?

Brian in Brghton

>LOML has been sneaking money away and told me that she has $1500 for me spend on a new jointer for my birthday last month. So my question is simple.

Which 8 inch jointer would you buy and why?

I am leery about Grizzly quality and wonder if the spiral cutterhead is an insert or not.

Let me know your opinion please.

Brian in Brighton.

Re: Honey says get a jointer, which one?

#2

Re: Honey says get a jointer, which one?

Brian in Brghton

>Of note is that I use mostly rough hardwoods, not much clean purchased.

Re: Honey says get a jointer, which one?

#3

Though I favor old machines...

John in New Mexico

>I did use a friend's Grizzly quite a bit before I found my old rusty Delta, and it seemed like a fine machine to me. No telling how long the castings are aged or anything like that, but he's still using it and not complaining. Alternatively you should be able to find a used American machine for under $800 or even under $500 if you're patient. That leaves you $1000 to buy lumber!

John

Re: Honey says get a jointer, which one?

#4

JL

Re: Honey says get a jointer, which one?

JL

>How about a Steel City Industrial 8" (or their Deluxe 8") jointer. That's if you want to buy new. Steel City is a "hungry" company, not complacent like certain others.

Re: Honey says get a jointer, which one?

#5

Re: Honey says get a jointer, which one?

Ted Wong

>I've heard alot of good things about the spiral cutterhead found on Grizzly. Indexed knives, super quiet and best of all virtually no tearout in even the most difficult woods are some of the positive comments I've heard

Re: Honey says get a jointer, which one?

#6

Steel City is a no, 3 blades

Brian in Brghton

>I found the Steel City to be lacking one thing the others have. A 4th blade. I would rather have 4 blades for the price.

Shop Fox is looking real good.

Re: Honey says get a jointer, which one?

#7

Re: Honey says get a jointer, which one?

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

>I have the Grizzly G0490 8". No complaints what so ever. Mine is from the original shipment to the states and there were some shipping issues but Grizzly got those resolved and it has been fine since.

Howard

Re: Honey says get a jointer, which one?

#8

Re: Amen!

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>A friend from the woodworkers' club, who is an old iron guy at owwm.com, rebuilt a Delta Milwaukee 8" gem a couple of years back, and offered it for sale, so he could do a bigger one.

Freshly redone, new knives, and a 1 year full money back guarantee, and I spent under $800. Not the cheapest, but it runs a lot nicer than anything else I could get at such a price, and so easily.

Now this thing is ALMOST as old as I am, and my fourth grandchild is due before Labor Day. Works really well.

Re: Honey says get a jointer, which one?

#9

Jim in Burlington Ont.

I'd scrape up more for the new 12"

Jim in Burlington On

>http://www.grizzly.com/products/G0609

Re: Honey says get a jointer, which one?

#10

Not an issue for most people

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>I don't see any advantage of 4 blades unless one is doing production work where a speedier feed rate would be valuable. I see a disadvantage as it is one more blade to buy and adjust with changing knives for no benefit (for most people). I have pushed thousands of feet across my 3 blade delta and never saw a need for more blades.

Buy the longest widest jointer you can afford.

Re: Honey says get a jointer, which one?

#11

Re: Honey says get a jointer, which one?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I have the Grizzly 8" with the carbide inserted cutter head. I believe the number is G0593. I also have a Yorkcraft 20" planer with the Byrd cutterhead. The cutters and cutter heads are very - very similar although the Byrd says theirs is angled, I cannot tell the difference in planing figured wood. I had a straight knife 6" Grizzly before and had no problems, but the performance with figured hardwood is tremendous with the carbide spiral heads. I would buy the Grizzly again. I have looked at the Delta, Jet, Powermatic and others and would not trade mine for any in its class.

Re: Honey says get a jointer, which one?

#12

Re: Honey says get a jointer, which one?

Patrick Schupbach

>I have the GO490 and am quite pleased. It was dead on out of the crate. Im sure the Byrd cutterhead would be an awesome upgrade. Enjoy your birhday bucks!!

Re: Honey says get a jointer, which one?

#13

What kind of planer do you have?

Rob Sandow

>The reason I ask is that as a hobbyist, I found dubious value in shelling out well over $1000 for an 8" jointer when you would match it up with a 15" or larger planer. If you can't face joint boards as wide as your planer can handle, then you are basically buing a machint to edge joint, and an 8" machine is only 33% bigger than a 6" machine, but well over twice the price.

My solution was to buy a 12" Robland Jointer/Planer, on the used market, for $1500, and sell my 12.5" benchtop planer and 6" jointer to offset the purchase price. While I sacrifice some planer capacity, a planer is only as good as the jointer it is matched with. If you already have a 15" planer, I would consider selling it, adding the cash to your $1500, and buying a combo machine. The Robland is the low end, and one day I am going to upgrade to a better machine like a Hammer, Felder, etc. But in the mean time, I find that the ability to face joint boards as wide as you can plane them is key.

Rob

Re: Honey says get a jointer, which one?

#14

I could not agree more, but....

Brian in Brghton

>I have two portable planers. The reason I want the 8 inch is because of size constraints of a 12 inch. I also have about 1000 bd feet of wood that is 70% between 6-8 inches wide and rough. I only have a few wider than 8. I sure would like a larger machine, but I have a 2 car shop and it is just too crowded with a machine of that size. I also do not have 3 phase and do not want to buy a phase convertor to get it. Someday I will have it, but not now. For now the 8 inch will do me well. I have no other jointer, so this will be my first. I have always just worked around the boards and made planer jigs to try to get flat boards. I am just sick of that and want to simplify my woodworking with a nice gift.

I am looking at new because, well, I have the fundage to do it and I do not like buying machines without any sort of warantee. I can do a lot of leg work to look for a used machine, but with used ones around here going for 80% of new, why bother. Besides with some of the sales prices being in the used price range, why not?

Re: Honey says get a jointer, which one?

#15

Re: Somewhat disagree.

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Rob, I slightly disagree with you. I do understand your thinking but there are some other advantages to purchasing an 8" jointer with the carbide inserted head. I have a 20" thickness planer with Byrd head (Yes I would love to have a 20" joiner). I have found I can use it to face plane about 40% of the rough lumber I have without using the jointer at all. Those boards that are not "bowed" or "twisted" but only cupped will, if thick enough to start with, come out perfectly flat with some TLC. I intend to build a planer sled to see if I can straighten most of my lumber without the face jointing. In reality most (80%) of my final usage requires boards less than 8" wide so I can rip those before planing. My 8" (Grizzly G0593) jointer with the segmented spiral cutter head has far less tear out than my old straight knife planer. It also has a much longer bed, which I find makes it far easier for me to straighten (both surface and edge) longer boards. I know you can straighten long boards on a short bed, (I have) but it takes a lot more care and effort. I have, on my old 6" short bed jointer, made a few unwanted canoe or rocking chair parts.

Re: Honey says get a jointer, which one?

#16

Re: Somewhat disagree.

Bill Pfahl in Virginia

>Tis my considered opine that the one is General with a Byrd head.

Re: Honey says get a jointer, which one?

#17

Disagree too...

John in New Mexico

>I flatten boards up to about 13" with my 8" jointer, so its a pretty good match for a 12" planer. You can probably do up to 15" or so, but I tend to be conservative and rarely have boards that wide anyhow.

John

Re: Honey says get a jointer, which one?

#18

Completely different view.

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>I use a planer for doing faces and a joiner for doing edges. I use a planer sled for flattening, and find I have better control over the process. For me a long bed joiner is more important than width, and, given that 8" generally have longer beds than 6" ones that is what I would look at. But then that's just me.

Ray

Re: Honey says get a jointer, which one?

#19

Re: I could not agree more, but....

wilbur

>I have a jointer/planer combo, but it's a 10", not a 12". But I do agree that there are a log of advantages to be able to have your jointing capacity match your planing capacity. In fact, my bandsaw resaw capacity is just under 10", so all the stars seem to align in my shop. :@)

If you're looking for new, there's the new Grizzly 12" jointer planer combo machine for $1795, which is a little out of your price range, but then you won't need your two portable planers, which you can hen sell.

The table is 60" long, so it's a compact unit, considering the 12" capacity. Personally, I've found that long jointer table length is not useful except in extreme situations. With a 60" table you should be able to easily joint 8 foot long boards, which should be enough for most projects.

But, if you're set on an 8" jointer, for $1500 Delta, General, Powermatic, or Steel City would all be good choices.

Re: Honey says get a jointer, which one?

#20

Agree with the disagreement somewhat

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>When it comes to woodworking, I'm pretty sure that the rule, or at least the saying, is:

"The one with the most tools wins"

So replacing a jointer AND planer with one combo unit goes against that all important rule. And for those of you who will argue that a combo jointer/planer should count for more that just one tool, let me remind you that the saying:

"The one with the biggest tool wins"

only applies to picking up women in a bar

Geezer, did I just say that? Shame on me.

;)

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Honey says get a jointer, which one?

#22

Hmmmmm

Brian in Brghton

>Dave, thanks for the thought. My concrete floor in the garage is only 4 inches thick. I think this would need it's own pad.