Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Jointing an Edge - Convex or Concave edge first?

Posts

Jointing an Edge - Convex or Concave edge first?

#1

Jointing an Edge - Convex or Concave edge first?

awh

>I�m suffering from a moment of brain lock and can�t get my mind around this; Concave edge down will result in snipe at the ends of the boards (at least initially).... Convex edge down will allow it to rock back and forth.

I�m sure one way is preferred but I can�t remember which.

Tony Haukap

Home Page - http://www.cyberspace.org/~awh/

--

Re: Jointing an Edge - Convex or Concave edge first?

#2

Re: Jointing an Edge - Convex or Concave edge firs

Rob Sandow

>Here's a graphic I put together a few years ago. It depicts my real world experience with jointing very long boards (those about twice as long as the jointer tables) and why I break with the conventional wisdom on the subject.

Rob


img

Re: Jointing an Edge - Convex or Concave edge first?

#3

Re: Jointing an Edge - Convex or Concave edge firs

David Hay @ Denver

>I've usually read that it's best to do concave side down if possible. If you do the convex side down, there's the risk of rocking the board back towards the infeed table as you go across the cutter head, resulting in a board that is just as curved as it was before. With the concave side down, this is reduced.

Incidentally, I've seen similar advice when hand planing. Many articles I've seen suggest dishing out the center of the board first to make it concave before taking full length strokes.

David

Re: Jointing an Edge - Convex or Concave edge first?

#4

Re: Jointing an Edge - Convex or Concave edge firs

Jesse in New Mexico

>We were taught in school that concave down is safer...

Re: Jointing an Edge - Convex or Concave edge first?

#5

Re: Jointing an Edge - Convex or Concave edge firs

John McGaw

>I say do whichever you are more comfortable with on your equipment. Once you get one edge straight you should be ripping the other edge straight and parallel on the TS anyway (aren't you?) and then taking of maybe 1/32" to get the saw edge perfect.

Re: Jointing an Edge - Convex or Concave edge first?

#6

the choice is clear

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>concave down. I have jointed thousands of edges and I still find it very difficult to joint a convex edge and get it straight; the tendency is for the cut to follow the curve.

When one has to do a convex edge then it is best to start with the technique used for cutting tapers as I describe in the Articles. This technique cuts the middle out of the convexity (new word) and starts the edge on its way to straightness. This will most times get a convex edge straight, in my hands.

Re: Jointing an Edge - Convex or Concave edge first?

#7

Convex side down

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>IME when jointing a severely concave edge the leading corner hangs up on the edge of the outfeed table. I back the board out but I think the possibility of kickback is great here.

Usually when jointing an edge I'm attempting to make the edge straight and also at a right angle to the board face which has already been jointed and which is registered against the fence. So, I apply significant side pressure to keep the face against the fence. If the board edge is severely convex I don't push down hard. Maybe its the side pressure that helps keep the board from rocking on its edge.

If I'm jointing a convex face I use my paddles to push down and forward on the middle of the board as it goes over the cutter. This minimizes rocking on the first pass and creates a flat. Continue with the paddles in the middle of the board until the flat has developed enough length to place paddles in line front to back, both supported by the flat.

Ed

Re: Jointing an Edge - Convex or Concave edge first?

#8

Ellis Walentine

Concave down

Ellis Walentine

>I eyeball the edges of the board, then I joint the concave edge, beginning with the ends. If the board is very concave, you need to take material off one end at a time. Start in the middle and joint to the end. Do a few passes and then reverse the board and joint the other end. Check the edge at each stage of the process. When it is approaching flatness, orient the board for it's best "downhill grain" direction, and take a final pass or two.

My 2¢,

Ellis

Re: Jointing an Edge - Convex or Concave edge first?

#9

Exactly

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>What I do, with one addition.

I lay a straight edge on the side to be jointed and then measure the maximum width I'll be able to get with the concave edge jointed flat. That way I can see if it will actually produce the piece I need for the length.

I will always try to minimize the jointing operation by cutting closer to finished length and eliminating as much of the "concavity" as I can that way. This will also reduce the amount of board in the DC bag.

In an extreme case, I'll cross-cut the board in the middle of the bow to yield shorter but wider finished stock.

mm

Re: Jointing an Edge - Convex or Concave edge first?

#10

Re: Exactly

Barry Irby

>I aggree with Ellis and Mark. I also try to leave the board about four or five inches longer than necessary if stock is not too scarce because I find my lunchbox planer leaves about two inches of snipe on the ends and my last roughing operation is to square the ends and cut off the snipe. If the stock is nice and straight and flat, I leave it in long lengths untill it is planed to elimanate sniping all the ends of all the shorter pieces. The long ends on the stock are also handy as I bounce the stock around the shop. The dings and damage are on the ends that get cut off with the snipe. If stock is scarce (Normally it is) I run the wood through my Performax and sand the snipe off.

Re: Jointing an Edge - Convex or Concave edge first?

#11

Rick L

Re: Ellis has the best answer.

Rick L

>The idea of trimming off one end then flipping it around and doing the same the other end to bring the board close to flat is the key to jointing long stock. As someone stated the long board will just follow the curve if Ellis's approach isn't used. Overall the jointer can only straighten out boards the length of the table unless you know the techniques to maximize jointer potential.