Long sordid tale
Alan Young
>I was commissioned to build a couple of tables. The designs were based on photographs of two tables my client found from various printed sources. I was asked to make the tables match an existing table they had. The original table looks like this:
The client was open to my suggestions as to what type of wood to use for the project. The floors in the room were maple but the table it self is not. I have four guesses as to what the table is and I'm not sure of any of them- Oak, Ash, Hickory, Teak?????
Anyway she wasn't concerned about the look of the wood as much as having the resulting tone match the previous table. At one point in our discussions I suggested using anegre for the tables-
There appears to be some disagreement as to what happened next in the processes of choosing the wood. I e-mailed the client a picture of anegre. Admittedly the picture was not compelling This is a photo from Hearns Hardwoods that I sent:

I believe I suggested The Anegre over the Maple. I probably did not emphasize it as a recommendation strongly enough. I recall a phone call with the clients husband in which he indicated the Anegre didn't seem to look good. The client believes she is the one that decided on the maple- in any case-
I was thinking no matter what wood was used the challenge was going to be in getting the stain to match the original table. So I built the tables from the Maple as the floor was maple and introducing a third wood seemed unnecessary.
After many attempts at matching the stains which included purchasing a color wheel, a $40 Mixol pigment matching set, and several staining attempts I ended up with this:
The tea table was no better. The aprons obviously did not accept the stain well so I stripped the entire finish off both tables-(More than once) and finally veneered the aprons in a quarter sawn Anegre veneer for the coffee table and maple veneer for the tea table-the maple veneer came from the exact same lot as what I used on the top:
I then re-stained all surfaces(actually I am leaving out several iterations of staining attempts)and top coated with a Minwax Brushing lacquer: Here's the result:
Below are more pictures of the current results. My client is not too happy claiming the finish is "Blotchy". She said I should have told her maple was hard to stain. Maybe she is correct, on the other hand it seems what I really should have explained is that no wood will totally accept a stain evenly through-out. Even the original table shows tone variations...
I have suggested that It would be good to bring these into her home and let them "sit" in the designated room for a few days.
I'd like you to let them sit in your room for a week and see how
they look. If after a few days you are unhappy with the look, I will re-assess any places of concern and offer options that seem reasonable to accomplish. Please know that your satisfaction is important me....
I am very frustrated at the whole project- I think I could have done a better job of communicating at the beginning the difficulties of staining maple. All though In my mind I recommended the Anegre- which I felt would stain better, I didn't make a strong enough case and probably thought I could get the maple to look good. At this point I really don't know what to expect to be able to do about this. Any comments are welcomed- even if you say- "Alan you blew it big time-" Let me know where you think I've erred or what I might do yet to save the project short of building these over from scratch or just refunding the deposit.
Alan



