Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Long sordid tale

Posts

Long sordid tale

#1

Alan Young

Long sordid tale

Alan Young

>I was commissioned to build a couple of tables. The designs were based on photographs of two tables my client found from various printed sources. I was asked to make the tables match an existing table they had. The original table looks like this:


The client was open to my suggestions as to what type of wood to use for the project. The floors in the room were maple but the table it self is not. I have four guesses as to what the table is and I'm not sure of any of them- Oak, Ash, Hickory, Teak?????

Anyway she wasn't concerned about the look of the wood as much as having the resulting tone match the previous table. At one point in our discussions I suggested using anegre for the tables-

There appears to be some disagreement as to what happened next in the processes of choosing the wood. I e-mailed the client a picture of anegre. Admittedly the picture was not compelling This is a photo from Hearns Hardwoods that I sent:


I believe I suggested The Anegre over the Maple. I probably did not emphasize it as a recommendation strongly enough. I recall a phone call with the clients husband in which he indicated the Anegre didn't seem to look good. The client believes she is the one that decided on the maple- in any case-

I was thinking no matter what wood was used the challenge was going to be in getting the stain to match the original table. So I built the tables from the Maple as the floor was maple and introducing a third wood seemed unnecessary.

After many attempts at matching the stains which included purchasing a color wheel, a $40 Mixol pigment matching set, and several staining attempts I ended up with this:


The tea table was no better. The aprons obviously did not accept the stain well so I stripped the entire finish off both tables-(More than once) and finally veneered the aprons in a quarter sawn Anegre veneer for the coffee table and maple veneer for the tea table-the maple veneer came from the exact same lot as what I used on the top:

I then re-stained all surfaces(actually I am leaving out several iterations of staining attempts)and top coated with a Minwax Brushing lacquer: Here's the result:


Below are more pictures of the current results. My client is not too happy claiming the finish is "Blotchy". She said I should have told her maple was hard to stain. Maybe she is correct, on the other hand it seems what I really should have explained is that no wood will totally accept a stain evenly through-out. Even the original table shows tone variations...

I have suggested that It would be good to bring these into her home and let them "sit" in the designated room for a few days.

I'd like you to let them sit in your room for a week and see how

they look. If after a few days you are unhappy with the look, I will re-assess any places of concern and offer options that seem reasonable to accomplish. Please know that your satisfaction is important me....

I am very frustrated at the whole project- I think I could have done a better job of communicating at the beginning the difficulties of staining maple. All though In my mind I recommended the Anegre- which I felt would stain better, I didn't make a strong enough case and probably thought I could get the maple to look good. At this point I really don't know what to expect to be able to do about this. Any comments are welcomed- even if you say- "Alan you blew it big time-" Let me know where you think I've erred or what I might do yet to save the project short of building these over from scratch or just refunding the deposit.

Alan









Re: Long sordid tale

#2

Re: Long sordid tale

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Allan,

First, I think your results are a fine match for the original round table in both color and tone. I think also that your offer to have the new furniture "rest" in place for a week or so is a good way to help resolve the situation. There is a point where you won't make her happy no matter what you do. No sence in approaching that point, so I wouldn't do anything more at present. Let her look at it for awhile.

In the furure, take pains to achieve good communication. In my experience, a good dialog also helped me assess the client, and once or twice I got little red flags, and declined the jobs. Otherwise, a good dialog opens both parties to mutual understanding. Do point out real or potential problems like splotching.

What to do now must be your own call. I'd cheerfully refund their money or consider a slight price adjustment. If they wanted a refund, I'd sell those beautiful tables to someone else. You can only do so much.

At least you have a new color wheel, another TOY to gloat about! :<)

George

Re: Long sordid tale

#3

Re: Long sordid tale

Mike Jurnigan in Suffolk

>Alan,

I don�t envy you. Trying to match an existing stain/color is not an easy task, especially if it is a factory piece. If I was in your shoes I would look at some shading or glazing to even out the tones and the variations. This is what the factories do. Also to get the even look of a factory piece do not use figured wood, use the bland stuff. You may have to strip and start from the beginning if you use glazing and shading.

Mike in Suffolk

Re: Long sordid tale

#4

Long sordid tale, or: part of the curve

nailshooter

>Hi Allen. Let me say first that anything I say is only my opinion, nothing more. But it is based on my experience as a self employed woodworker for almost 30 years.

It is hard to say what is going on from the pictures as they are only pictures. Up close, the pieces may look better, or they may look worse. The designs look nice, though. Having said that, I will go around workmanship/execution issues.

I think what you have here is a really valuale learning experience in dealing with clients and developing your confidence in your product. When you feel uncomfortable about doing something a certain way, don't have any experience doing something a certain way, or just plain don't like to do something a certain way, don't do it. If you were uncomfortable doing the staining to match a wood sample, you shouldn't have done it at all. This is easy to explain to a client; use the truth, and tell them that you haven't had great success in the past matching one species of wood to another by simply coloring it. I tell my clients, "I can get it close, BUT..."

I submit a sample using the exact technique and materials that I would use if they buy the project and have them initial the exact sample. And again, I really hammer home that no process can assure an exact match to different woods, different coloration of each piece of wood, different finishes and techniques, as well as the different aging factors of piece that is to be matched.

I want the folks to have reasonable expectations. High enough that they want to do the project and be happy about it, but reasonable enough to know that their custom work didn't come out of an assembly line factory. In your shop, you don't have a chance at matching a tinted post catalyzed lacquer sprayed by robots to exact thickness that was heat set in an oven. Especially not with wipe on and brush on products.

I think part of what I do to remain successful is to educate my clients as to what to expect. So many want that completely flawless factory look that I tell them it may be best for them to go to IKEA or something along those lines. But this is where more experience is a valuable tool.

When I started out in '77 with my own company, I found out then that doing the work was the easy part. Managing clients and their expectations became the real work. Some are a true pleasure to work with and I choose to remember those. I've had a lot of those. Others, well...

I think if I were you, I would hold tight to what your current position is with those folks, and if they weren't happy, give them a discount and move on. Lesson learned.

Robert

Re: Long sordid tale

#5

Color calibrations on the monitor

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Alan, I think they look great.

Of course, I'll have to agree that communication is key, but let's face it, this is a hectic world and things aren't always what they should be.

One comment I have is about: "...I e-mailed the client a picture of anegre..." In my opinion this can lead to problems quickly. I've found that no matter how accurate the photograph is, you are at the mercy of the viewer's computer monitor. I have a client who sell art reproductions. We've gone to great lengths to get good representaions of what the artwork looks like, but we've had to inlcude a disclamer on the website.

Note: Due to differences in color calibration of different computer monitors, the colors depicted on this website may not be an exact representation of the true product color.

There are so many factors and settings (color, brightness, temperature, contrast) not to mention age and LCD/CRT that will make the same picture look different on two different monitors.

I suggest you offer to give them their deposit back with an apology, and then sell them to someone. They are really beautiful and I don't think your client will ever truly appreciate them because they probably won't get past the color difference. No sense in risking your reputation with a client, even if they say they are satisfied. If they're not 100% it won't be good in the log run. They may learn to appreciate them over time, but chances are they aer more likely to like them less as time goes on. They might never be able to see past the color issue.

Someone else without the color expectations will siply love them as they are.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Long sordid tale

#6

Different Approach

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Alan,

Correcting the appearance to please the client will be hard. Perhaps it would be easier to change the client's minds instead? For a nominal fee we could have Guido and Rocky "pay your clients a little visit". I'm sure a little "persuasion" will get them to see the work in a whole new light. ;-)

Tommy

Re: Long sordid tale

#7

Re: Long sordid tale

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Regardless of your follow-on efforts, this client will always cast aspersions on your work...."He had to do it over twice to get it almost right!" Cut your losses: take the tables and give them back their deposit. They ain't worth it!

Clint

Re: Long sordid tale

#8

Re: Long sordid tale

Dave Mount

>Alan--

Sorry to hear your tale. There is an all too common association in people between having enough money to afford hand-crafted, one-off furniture and an expectation that 1) you can read their mind, and 2) anything less is your failure. I don't mean to indict everyone, there are some great people out there too, but there's more of the former than you'd like to think.

There's no way to know if the communication was enough. One could argue that because there was some form of misunderstanding, there was not enough communication. On the other hand, it may well be that the source of the problem is not really lack of communication but shifting and/or ill-founded expectations.

In terms of the "look", you probably realize that most factory furniture uses coloring other than stain (glazing or toning) which gives a much more even coloration. Particularly with woods like maple, the difference can be dramatic. I think they are fine looking tables -- though I don't usually stain wood, I like the differential coloring you get even with just the amber of untinted oil or film finish on woods like maple, birch, and cherry. Apparently your client does not. Hard to know how to handle things at this point. Having "matching" as a performance criterion is a tough one.

My condolences,

Dave

NE Minnesota

Re: Long sordid tale

#9

“Moose, Rocco…”

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>“…help the judge find his wallet”

Caddyshack, if you don't recognize the quote. Best imagined in Rodney Dangerfield's voice.

Rod

Re: Long sordid tale

#10

YES! And Also An Alternative

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Allan,

Tommy has an indisputably good idea. But there is another one: Offer to match the old furniture to the stuff you just built. Ah, what a sweet suite!

George

Re: Long sordid tale

#11

My first impression…

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>…was that your customer probably isn't going to be satisfied no matter what you do. It's unimportant at this juncture as to what you should have done—you can apply that lesson to future transactions. I think I would make up my mind that the pieces are coming back, and be prepared to refund whatever they have in them. There are some people with whom it's just not worth doing business.

The pieces look good to me. I can't imagine you'd have any trouble disposing of them. I'd be happy to have them myself, although I'll require a significant discount due to them being factory irregulars.

Rod

Re: Long sordid tale

#12

Alan Young

I appreciate the responses..especially Mr. Skaggs

Alan Young

>Thanks Tom. I have no doubt now how to proceed! Ha Ha.

Actually I think I have one more card to play. The long coffee table has a glass top as you can see. The client is having a party this Thursday evening and the 3/8 inch think glass I ordered had not arrived as of last Friday so this weekend I had a temporary piece of 1/8th thick glass cut as a stop gap measure. I just got a call today saying the 3/8 stock is in. So I am thinking get these pieces in the house for the party. Maybe the guests will have a positive response and sort of "influence" my clients opinion....after that I have no more cards to play...

Thanks though to everyone for your responses. If nothing else I have a lesson for the future.. I love being an example :^)

Alan

Re: Long sordid tale

#13

One more option!

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>Maching stain or color of an exisitng piece is extremely hard to do. It never quite comes out the same no matter what you do. Dealing with a piece that is made from an unkonw variety of wood makes it even harder. Maple does sometimes come out blotchy. Your tables look great, but based on the photo of the top of the square table, the wood surface does appear blotchy and the finish appears to be uneven.

What about making a new round table following the same process you used to make the two "matching" tables. That way all three would truly match in color and wood.

I guess if I couldn't convince them to try them in the room, then I would refund their deposit and attempt to sell the tables on ebay or other outlet. In no event would I agree to a significant discount because the customer wasn't satisfied with the final result. If you did your best and they aren't happy and willing to pay the agreed price, then they should find someone else. If you give them a big discount, they will want something else from you and try the same stunt while bragging to their friends that they got a bargain from you.

Lee

Re: Long sordid tale

#14

Plan "C"

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Use Photoshop to make the finish look like they want and e-mail them the photos. Then deliver the tables 5 minutes before their party. They will be way too busy to inspect them then. Then later, when they complain, tell them that their guests must have splashed drinks on the tables. Use the Photoshop pictures as proof of the "before" looks of the tables. Be sure to act really disgusted by the carelessness they and their guests showed your beautiful work.

That's the plan...plain and simple. ;-)

Tom

Re: Long sordid tale

#15

an ass for every saddle and a saddle for every ass

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

>I would have serious reservations about placing the pieces in the home for a party with clients that are less than happy. as the old sying goes 'there is no advertising like word of mouth'. that is probably x10 for unhappy customers. If your clients are cooperative I would renegotiate the contract to be of a stated wood with a clear finish. do a bit of effort to get a closer match and have them sign the back of the acceptable sample. By the way it looks like hickory to me. If this works this client could become a valuable referance rather than someone who tells a house full of guests how unhappy they are with your work. If this is not an option and you sill want to place the work in the home I would likely opt for after the party when they are less likely to tell a room full of people that it is not what the expected and they are not sure if they are happy with it.

Just for the record I had one of these types of customers 20 years ago. the two things I took away from my experiance are that deposits for all custom work are NON REFUNDABLE. Having said that, the second is that, a contract is only worth as much as you are willing to spend to enforce it. I take this to mean that it is easier and cheaper to make sure I understand what my clients want and that my clients understand what I will deliver. And there is nothing that indicates 'understanding' quite like an initialed drawing and an initialed wood/finish sample.

one last thing, I try to have all conversations about a project with the same person. either the couple togeter or one individual but NEVER EVER EVER do I talk to the wife then the husband then the wife... (throw in a decorator for a real nightmare). this may infact have been the only mistake you actually made on this project.

Robin Corell

Re: Long sordid tale

#16

Ellis Walentine

Here's my two cents

Ellis Walentine

>I think you were in over your head with the stain matching, Alan. In those photos, it looks like you "shocked" the wood pretty hard with yellow, while the original table has a faint pinkish tan color. Once you put yellow on wood, it's hard to pull it back to the reddish side of the color wheel by adding more stain.

I agree completely with nailshooter that you need to give the customer an actual sanded, finished sample of the wood you intend to use, just the way you intend to deliver it to them in the finished product. The road to Rome is paved with the hopes of woodworkers who thought their customers could read minds.

After all the frustrating work that went into this piece, I imagine you've really busted the budget wide open, and taking the pieces back might be difficult financially. Maybe not any more than not taking them back. But, here's something I would consider before you give up all hope of salvaging the sale and the customer...

First of all, you don't need any stain at all to match the color of the original table. A slight pinkish tan toner in a pot of lacquer would have given you a very respectable match to the original finish in just a couple quick spray coats. If your lacquer technique is good, you probably wouldn't have even needed to rub out the final finish.

It may not be too late. If you can strip/scrape/sand the tables back to bare wood, you would be all set to try the toner routine I suggested. What you need is some lacquer or alcohol soluble dyes and some lacquer. Play with a few drops or grains of the dye and see what kind of tone it adds to the finish. Use actual samples of your wood and experiment until the color is just right, then mix up a pot of your formula and shoot it on.

I know it probably sounds like I'm making it sound easier than it is, but I'm not. Do the experimenting before you commit to sanding off the current finish, and cut bait if you can't get good results or a close color match.

Ellis

Re: Long sordid tale

#17

Re: Long sordid tale

Jesse in New Mexico

>What a bummer, but at least your post elicited a lot of good advice.

My two cents would be that if at the end of the day, the customer is not delighted with the table, take them back. There are plenty of others willing to pay good money for tables like those. Leaving the tables with an unhappy customer, even at a discount is a situation that will fester and give you an undeserved bad rap for years to come.

Go explain people, huh!

Re: Long sordid tale

#18

Steven Antonucci

Here's a "sales" technique to help qualify

steve antonucci

>your customer's current state of mind:

It's called Stripping Line (flyfishing term). On your next conversation, suggest to the customer that there is probably not much you could do to "salvage the pieces", and that you are willing to refund their deposit. You will undertake the process of selling them to another person, but you do not want them to be unhappy with your work.

If they jump at the idea, it's time to cut the line. Someone will like them as is, and you'll be "done".

More than likely, they will recoil in horror at the idea of you selling "their tables" to someone else and leaving with nothing. If they do, then you should try to figure out something amicable to resolve this. If they don't, then you can't save the sale and you'll save yourself a bunch of refinishing.

Steve

Plays a semi-professional sales guy on TV...

Re: Long sordid tale

#19

Re: Long sordid tale

Thomas S Stockton

>Alan

been there done that. A couple of things, e-mail doesn't work to show people the color and tone of wood, I always use a real sample when a sample is needed. It will cost more but it should be covered in the bid. another thing is to get everything in writing, e mail is great for this it leaves a real nice record of what has transpired between the craftsman and the client, way easier than trying to remeber phone conversations

Robin gives good advice about having it there for the party, it is something that might work but could backfire especially if one of their friends has watched to much do it yourself shows on TV. Think this one through and trust your judgement.

Ellis' advice is sound also it would be cheaper in the long run to strip sand and refinsh the tables, if you're not comfortable with toner find a good finisher that can do the work.

unfourtnatly your losing money at this point but it is important to bite the bullet and make

the client happy. If you think you'll never make them happy refund their money.

The other thing to look at and decide is was this just a simple misunderstanding and these are potenialy good clients or is every project for them going to be like this, if it is the later there is nothing ever wrong with firing the client, you don't need to be rude about you can tell them you're not interested in their next project when it comes up. This is a pretty hard concept to learn especially if your early in your career or times are slow.

Good luck and remember that it will be over soon and you and your wife will be sitting around one day talking sbout what happened to that one phsyco client.

Tom

Re: Long sordid tale

#20

Second Ellis

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>In my limited experience toner coats go a long way towards matching an existing finish. TransTint dyes in either shellac or alchool are easy to deal with, and you can adjust the tone a drop at a time.

I did match a set of kitchen cabinets to the customers' old hardwood floor with plain diluted orange shellac (dewaxed). TransTints are dyes so they don't obscure the grain as much as pigment stains.

First seal the wood with a coat of SealCoat, then spray the toner. Go light on the stain, you can always add another coat if not dark enough. No blotchiness is the result.

No affiliation, just a happy customer.

DC

Re: Long sordid tale

#21

Re: It's not furniture, but similar experience

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>A long, long time ago, I was in business as a software consultant. Business wasn't always really brisk, but I'd learned that lesson of preferential pricing. When there was a client I wasn't wild about working for, I priced the project up to a point where I could get some enthusiasm for it, and gave them a delivery date with which I could live. In other words, I made it worth MY while.

Some of those folks became some of my better clients. Some of them became other folks' problem children.

Professional sales guys understand that you can't sell to everyone. And you really don't want to. You want to do a job with which you can point with pride, refer potential clients, and pay your bills. Otherwise, walk away cleanly.

Re: Long sordid tale

#22

Alan Young

To Everyone

Alan Young

>WOW. What a great set of responses to my post. There are a few details I left out and I wish I had the ability to correctly list the entire correspondences and conversations I have had with my client and that I could also accurately relay the exact order of my finishing attempts. But I think the essence of the sequence of events has been displayed well enough. I will be re-reading all the comments including the procedural suggestions regarding toning etc and decide whether or not to give it another go or return the deposit and call it a lesson. What ever happens I am grateful for the responses here. I can assure you that they have probably prevented me from wondering aimlessly further off on my own journey through the dark forest of exploratory wood finishing....

One thing for sure. I will not brings these into the home-certainly not before the party. I have some time to re-evaluate my options.

Sincere thanks again to everyone who responded.

Alan

Re: Long sordid tale

#23

Re: emphasis

paul womack

> And there is nothing that indicates 'understanding' quite like an initialed drawing and an initialed wood/finish sample.

Words to live by - this forum allows us all to benefit from OTHER PEOPLE'S hindsight, which has to be a serious saving...

BugBear

Re: Long sordid tale

#24

Re: Long sordid tale

Joe Burke

>Allan

You've been given a ton of great responses, and I won't even attempt to add any more technical info. I will add one thing though, as I think I can empathize with you in one way.

I'd been teaching and woodworking for 20 years, I guess, when I tried doing it as a job. I found out very quickly that the finishing side of the job would be my biggest challenge. I'd bet that in the last 12 years I've spent more time and money on finishing than anything else. Time on task experimenting on countless samples. Money on products and equipment.

It ain't easy. The experts in the books and videos make it seem that way, but it isn't. Particularly when you're alone. Alone with more options than you can easily count as to products and sequence.

I think the first thing I noted was that you'd used brushing lacquer. That told me, I'd guess, that you don't have a spray set up. Unfortunately, not having a spray set up just complicates matters. I didn't achieve many results I found satisfactory until I put a lot of time, effort and money into my spray set up. That allowed me to use the same products and techniques industry uses and thereby come close to duplicating what industry does.

Now someone might surely chime in and say that spray equipment isn't a must, and it may not be. Neither is an automobile. We could walk everywhere we need to go if it came down to it. But we don't.

You may have spray equipment, and if you do, I apologize for being off base. If you don't, I'd explore the option. In my opinion, without it, trying to duplicate factory finishes with quality results in a timely fashion (read profitably) is tough at best.

Good Luck

Re: Long sordid tale

#25

I agree with Ellis Also - I've done it twice

Derek

>I have matched color for other folks twice. I used toner on top of the wood, but underneath a top protective coat.

One time is was a small job - a large mirror frame. In that case, I did as Ellis said - I made samples of the actual wood and mixed Transtint liquid dyes (from Homestead finishing) into shellac as a toner and made multiple color tests until the customer (a friend) was happy. They are still happy. We are still friends.

Another time I refinished a whole kitchen for some friends. I stripped everything (WHAT A CHORE!). I used transtint in shellac for this as well and made the color a very close match to what they wanted. They were and still are friends. They were and still are happy.

Both times I had to mix several colors together to get the match I wanted. Making it lighter in color and using more than one toner coat (adjusting the thickness) helped the match. Too many coats is a problem also, though, since you do not want the finish to be too thick.