Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Finishing Quandry...

Posts

Finishing Quandry...

#1

Finishing Quandry...

Rob Hix - King George, VA

>Hey all,

A quick question. I am building some bookcases on commission and I want the finish to turn out really good. I am afraid that using polyurethane in the shop (garage) that gets opened up nearly every day will result in a finish full of junk.

Although not totally out of the question yet, I am considering using either shellac or a quick drying varnish thinned out with Naphtha (a technique used by Jeff Jewitt Quick Drying Finish ). Just not sure which of the three topcoats I want to use.

I need something that will dry really quick to minimize dust problems. Wipe on or brush on does not matter although I prefer wipe on for its ease of application and cleanup.

Thanks in advance,

Rob Hix

Re: Finishing Quandry...

#2

Re: Finishing Quandry...

john lucas

>I had the same problem with a table. I used brush on Poly because it drys fast and keeps the dust to a minimum. I waited 2 weeks and then rubbed it out with pumice and rhotenstone. That took care of any dust nibs and brightened up the finish.

Re: Finishing Quandry...

#3

Re: Finishing Quandry...

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I've used both of what you mentioned, shellac and wiping varnish, and they both work. I found that I liked the wiping varnish for large projects better, because the 'set' seemed to fit my needs better. The warmth of the varnish also helped with the woods I worked, too.

But it's up to you. Either one is fine. I quit after three or four coats of varnish. Shellac, generally more, though.

McCloskey's Gloss, cut 25% to 33% with VMP Naptha...

Re: Finishing Quandry...

#4

Re: Finishing Quandry...

Paul Dwight

>I've never had any luck brushing or wiping shellac on large surfaces. It sets up so fast that I can't maintain a wet edge, which inevitably means I end up with bad brush marks. Adding alcohol helps maintain a wet edge but then it becomes difficult to finish vertical surfaces without getting runs and sags.

I used to use Varathane fast-dry polyurethane thinned to brushable (or sprayable) consistency with acetone. It was a pretty decent compromise, although it still took a little while to set up to the point that it wouldn't get dust nibs. The acetone flashes off so fast that blushing can be a problem in humid conditions. Thinning with naptha instead of acetone might help, I guess, but I haven't tried it.

Honestly, though, this seems like a job that cries out for a waterborne varnish. Most of the ones I have used set up very quickly, especially in summer. A varnish like General Finishes High Performance Polyurethane looks good, brushes well and is much more durable than shellac.

Good luck with your project! -- Paul

Re: Finishing Quandry...

#5

u will love wipe on poly

robert davis

>

Re: Finishing Quandry...

#6

QUANDARY, not quandry.

English teacher

>

Re: Finishing Quandry...

#7

Lee Grindinger

"QUANDARY, not quandry." is not a sentence.

Lee Grindinger

>Your period is misplaced.

Re: Finishing Quandry...

#8

Pop The Grain First With Tung Oil

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: Finishing Quandry...

#9

Re: Finishing Quandry...

BilWil

>I received this formula from a man in Australia. It has workeed well for me. I don't have a finishing room so it is essential that I have a finish that will dry quickly. This has been my finish of choice.

25% pure tung oil, Lee Valley is a good source

25% high quality gloss varnish, I use marine varnish because it dries with some flexibility and has a very high solids content. Others will tell you never to use marine varnish on furnitue.

50% turps, paint thinner or Naphtha will work, I like turps.

A small quantity of Japan Drier, I use one ounce to a quart, so that it dries quickly. I suggest you expeniment with japan Drier as it is easy to put so much in that it dries too quickly; therefore, making it difficult to maintain a wet edge, so you end up with drag marks.

Re: Finishing Quandry...

#10

Re: Finishing Quandry...

Dave in Haverford PA

>My favorite for something like this is Barley's gel varnish - wipe it on, wipe off and it dries fast. Takes 3-4 coats. You can also color it by adding Bartlet's gel stains. Goo luck!

Re: Finishing Quandry...

#11

lets hope there's no quandary at the foundry

John in New Mexico

>

Re: Finishing Quandry...

#12

Ellis Walentine

:-)

Ellis Walentine

>