Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Minimum Turn Radius for BS blades

Posts

Minimum Turn Radius for BS blades

#1

Minimum Turn Radius for BS blades

Falberg saw Co

>Not sure about resolution here but if you can't see it, that's a dime on top and a quarter below. This was done with a re-set TW 1/2" blade in 10" of Cedar yesterday. We're done testing; the results are in. Minimum Turn Radius is determined by Set Angle, not blade width. There's a minimal "blade width (X) factor" involved but we haven't determined its exact mathematical value yet. It's negligible, however.


img

Re: Minimum Turn Radius for BS blades

#2

Re: Minimum Turn Radius for BS blades

john lucas

>That's interesting. you will certainly get the woodturners attention with this article. I think most of us have tried to cut a smaller blank than we should using our 1/2" blade. I always thought set had a lot to do with it but assumed blade size was more of the culprit since that's what all the articles on Bandsaws say.

Re: Minimum Turn Radius for BS blades

#3

Re: Minimum Turn Radius for BS blades

Paul Waddle

>Thats a very good report. I'm sure there's a range in which set and width change as being the most dominant. I would surmise 1/2'' or less band width, as per your testing,the set is predominate. Who makes the best resaw blade agoin'?

Re: Minimum Turn Radius for BS blades

#4

Now I'm really confused........

Michael Stadulis, in Gloucester County, NJ

>"Minimum Turn Radius is determined by Set Angle, not blade width. There's a minimal "blade width (X) factor" involved"

I must be missing your point, since certainly you're not cutting that cylinder w/ a 1.25" blade......... so the blade width factor has to be a big deal. Although I don't own a blade like the Timberwolf for wet wood, which reportedly has lots of set, it would seem that "any" blade........especially narrower widths..... with a significant degree of set can turn a much tighter radius than that same blade w/ less set. Have I missed your point entirely?

Thanks, Mike

Re: Minimum Turn Radius for BS blades

#5

Re: Minimum Turn Radius for BS blades

Ron in Drums PA

>Neat.

This gives me hope for a few ideas that I've had dancing in my head for a long time.

Will your company be selling any blades soon?

Re: Minimum Turn Radius for BS blades

#6

Meant to post under the Falberg post...sorry

Michael Stadulis, in Gloucester County, NJ

>

Re: Minimum Turn Radius for BS blades

#7

Re: Minimum Turn Radius for BS blades

Falberg saw Co

>Most of the articles written about bandsaws ARE wrong. That's why, after years of writing and several well-intentioned books, we are all still mystified by the complexity of the simple band saw. It has a lot to do with economics. There's just not enough money in the saw mfg. business to make it worthwhile for the big tool companies to invest in research. True. They've told me that when I tried to license my patent. The blade mfg. co.'s have a vested interest in keeping your blade choices to a minimum so they can avoid the expense of additional product lines. Most of them don't even publish complete specs for their blades. I wonder if they've ever USED their own blades. It's easier to sell the "sizzle". And we buy them because we have no other option. Same with the saws themselves. They can do much better; but they won't as long as you're satisfied with the status quo. Find a truly American tool company anymore. You can't afford American tools because Americans won't invest in technology anymore. They look at next year's bottom line and no further. Sound like a rant coming on? Don't get me started.

Re: Minimum Turn Radius for BS blades

#8

Re: Now I'm really confused........

Falberg saw Co

>certainly you're not cutting that cylinder w/ a 1.25" blade.........

No. You're quite right. And thanks for putting it in that context for me. I've been focused on the 3/8" - 3/4" widths because that's what my saws run and those are the sizes my blade setter is scaled to. The reason I'm getting such tight MTR's with 1/2" and 3/4" blades is the depth of the gullet and the degree to which you can set them. If the 1-1/4" blade had proportionally deep gullets, however, we could probably turn it around in an inch and a quarter. We used to have a 3/8" 2TPI that was awesome to turn, but somewhat fragile and prone to breakage, so the factory discontinued them. I "lobbied" strenuously for a 1/2" 2 TPI blade and to our friends at Suffolk's credit they delivered. For that they are truly great Americans. I can re-set a 3/8" - 3TPI blade to turn tight but I don't see the corresponding smoothness with the finer pitch at it's extremes, so more research is needed there. There is a use for them - we just haven't found it yet. With a blade setter like this at our disposal we have an almost infinite number of blades designs to play with and we're just starting to discover our favorites. One thing I learned just recently is that the 3/4" 2TPI blade have more "grit" than our 3/4HP motors can really use. We get no additional feed speed from them because we're blowing fuses everytime we "push it". To that end I started building a dedicated 2HP "Resaw Monster" with feed rails and adjustable fence to be used strictly as a precision veneer slicer. That's where the 3/4" blades will shine. Until then............

Re: Minimum Turn Radius for BS blades

#9

Re: Minimum Turn Radius for BS blades

Barry Irby

>I believe you are correct on a number of points. Instead of having a gradual refinement to the tools we buy, we get the same fifty or seventy five year old designs reproduced. On one hand, this is good because replacement parts are easy and readily available. OTOH, improvements and upgrades are stymied.

And I suspect you are right about them not using what they produce. I wrote to the company that produced my lathe, over and over. Pointed out errors in there documentation, down to the level of spelling errors. (They corrected some of those because they were embarrassing. And it does not require retooling)

But I had suggested they change the position of a "indexing" pin. They had the pin under the knob and the holes in the top of the head stock. One hole is shallow and does not penetrate the metal, but the other opens into the head stock. So the shallow one packs full of crud and becomes useless and the other one allows crud to fall into the head stock. The answer was to put the pin in the head stock and the holes under the knob. No more crud in the hole or the headstock.

The problem I had was that sending suggestions to them was like writing to Santa Claus. I never got an answer and they never made any improvements to the lathe from my suggestions, even thought they came out with a new and "improved" version. I wondered why they did not send me an e-mail and ask what I thought they should do. I suspect they did not send a similar e-mail to any of the other owners either.

Re: Minimum Turn Radius for BS blades

#10

Re: Minimum Turn Radius for BS blades

Falberg saw Co

>Who makes the best resaw blade agoin'?

You do. You're the only one who can judge the amount of set you'll need to cut straight and flat through 16" of rosewood burl. Your saw will decide how much tension it can deliver before you snap the blade or bog the motor down to a stop. I won't get into brand loyalties with anyone because they all (blades) have their uses. The best resaw blade is the one that works for you, in your machine. I 'm sending brochures out to my customers next week with a partial listing of the most common blades used in our trade - timber framing. It shows the actual specs for each blade, including Set Angle. It also contains specs for the custom-set blades we are now offering them for sale. I listed them in ascending order of SA so they can choose accordingly. If the lower SA drifted, they can go to a higher set. If the higher set left too rough a finish, they can step down a degree or two in SA. The ideal cutting solution is one degree up from BAD (bowing and drifting). In that way you can "dial in" the best blade for your particular cutting solution. My customers spent $4600 on a saw. It's not a hobby for them. Nor me. If we ever get big enough (Rich enough) to buy a blade welder we might get into custom blades for the two wheeler club. Until then...........

Re: Minimum Turn Radius for BS blades

#11

Re: Minimum Turn Radius for BS blades

Falberg saw Co

>I feel your pain, Barry. I think the basic problem comes down to the fact that tool companies are now so big they forgot what is was they set out to do. We've been experiencing THEIR "senior moment" for thirty years now. They're not going to get any younger and they're not going to change. Your bandsaw was designed by a college graduate in the accounting dept. Big companies hire CAD mechanics and graphic designers to research tools - not woodworkers. They work in offices and have their phones surgically implanted in their ears; but you can never reach them because they're in some sort of perpetual "conference" with each other. Contact with the outside world seems to leave them disoriented and confused. Do you see a consumer revolution coming? On internet forums like this I see the seeds of a future where you'll once again buy your drill from a drill company and your jig saw from a jig saw company, both of whom specialize in their field, use their own products, and kiss their customers' behinds. It may cost more "but you'll never need another.." . Remember that slogan? That's when American tools ruled. If my boys are any indication of the next generation, we'll see that day again. In the meantime there's those curved fences........................ya gotta just love it!!!!!CURVED FENCE!!! ROFL

Re: Minimum Turn Radius for BS blades

#12

Re: Minimum Turn Radius for BS blades

Falberg saw Co

>We're selling blades to our own saw customers right now. We'll have to "grow" the blade business before we'll have enough capital to expand into the consumer market. My sons will be running the blade business.It's coming though. Be patient. I'd rather play with my prototypes. It's a new-found passion and I always liked Rube Goldberg.

Re: Minimum Turn Radius for BS blades

#13

Re: Minimum Turn Radius for BS blades

George (Oxford, NC)

>No. You're quite right. And thanks for putting it in that context for me. I've been focused on the 3/8" - 3/4" widths because that's what my saws run and those are the sizes my blade setter is scaled to. The reason I'm getting such tight MTR's with 1/2" and 3/4" blades is the depth of the gullet and the degree to which you can set them. If the 1-1/4" blade had proportionally deep gullets, however, we could probably turn it around in an inch and a quarter. We used to have a 3/8" 2TPI that was awesome to turn, but somewhat fragile and prone to breakage, so the factory discontinued them. I "lobbied" strenuously for a 1/2" 2 TPI blade and to our friends at Suffolk's credit they delivered. For that they are truly great Americans. I can re-set a 3/8" - 3TPI blade to turn tight but I don't see the corresponding smoothness with the finer pitch at it's extremes, so more research is needed there. There is a use for them - we just haven't found it yet. With a blade setter like this at our disposal we have an almost infinite number of blades designs to play with and we're just starting to discover our favorites. One thing I learned just recently is that the 3/4" 2TPI blade have more "grit" than our 3/4HP motors can really use. We get no additional feed speed from them because we're blowing fuses everytime we "push it". To that end I started building a dedicated 2HP "Resaw Monster" with feed rails and adjustable fence to be used strictly as a precision veneer slicer. That's where the 3/4" blades will shine. Until then............

I think that your comment "proportionally deep gullets" is the crux of the situation (if I understand the situation at all). If I take a 1" blade and make the gullets 3/4" deep and put an aggressive set on the teeth, I could, with some small amount of force I think, make the blade cut about the same radius as �" blade. The key, once again in my mind, is that with a wide blade with small gullets cannot bend on the vertical and thus cannot cut small radii. But if you only have �" of solid blade and agressive teeth than you can make it cut like a �' blade. About the same idea of cutting circles on a table saw, the teeth will chisel out what is needed. I think that one would only have to look at the 'kerf width' after the cut is complete and see that the width is much greater than cutting the same curve with a standard �" blade.

George

Re: Minimum Turn Radius for BS blades

#14

Re: Minimum Turn Radius for BS blades

Ron in Drums PA

>Well if you ever need a consumer to beta test your blades, I'm your man! Until then I'll have to be patient.

Thanks for the report.

Re: Minimum Turn Radius for BS blades

#15

Ellis Walentine

To an extent...

Ellis Walentine

>... I can "pick up what you're layin' down." To another extent, I think that customer feedback does influence tool design and manufacture and documentation.

I think it is important for concerned woodworkers to pass their feedback up the chain to the decision makers, but it is also worthwhile knowing that your feedback isn't falling on deaf ears, even if it doesn't get a direct human response. I've known enough of these companies to know that they take their customers very seriously.

Ellis