>Need some advice - I'm making a queen size bed for my son and his wife. They do not want to use a foundation/box spring-just the mattress. I have two ideas to support the mattress; plywood sheets (3 @ 60 x 26.5) or narrow slats (I have a bunch of 4/4 poplar I could use). I'm leaning towards the poplar slats, my main question is how wide do I cut them and what spacing should I use?. Do you think 3" slats with 2 in spaces would work?
>When I had the identical problem I chose to go the plywood route. My setup used 3 plywood pieces that span the width of the bed. On the bottom of each piece is a rib cut from 3/4" poplar, shaped as an arc tapering to nothing at each end and about 4" thick in the middle. This odd setup originated when I first built the bed and was using a foundation along with the 18" pillow-top mattress resulting in a final height that would induce nosebleed. The tapered ribs kept them out of sight under the bed. I've moved the support cleats to near the top of the bed rails now and the tapered setup is no longer necessary but I see no need to change them after the fact. The plywood platform is dead solid and never shifts or causes a squeak.
>I used ash slats, primarily because ash cost less when I built the beds. They are 7/8" thick and 3" wide, spaced 2". I've made four beds using those dimensions, and have never experienced any problems at all.
>It may have been overkill; however, I used 4" Ash slats with a 1" space on my queen sized bed. It is working great. I used Ash because it was as inexpensive as popular and stronger. The slats have holes drilled on the ends that mate with short dowels in the frame sides.
>A lot of this is probably self-evident, but I'll spout it anyway...
Every project has its unique design challenges, and beds are no different. A box spring (or foundation, to use the formal term) provides a firm, flat, stable foundation for the mattress and bridges the span between the rails with its own rigid beam-like construction, so you only need enough slats to distribute the design weight (mattress, bedclothes and occupants, plus a safety factor) more or less uniformly to the side rails of the bed frame.
When you need to support a mattress without using a box spring, you have a completely different engineering problem. A mattress can flex and sag anywhere it doesn't receive support from a rigid flat surface such as the one provided by a box spring. So, if you're using slats, you need to choose wood of adequate stiffness to span the bed rails without excessive sagging, like the way floor joists work. Here, though, the slats lay flat, so they need to be of sufficient number, thickness and stiffness to resist deflection under the design conditions. The spacing of the slats will determine how much of the lower mattress surface is not directly supported. At some point, depending on the padding and the covering and the springs and other construction features of the mattress, some damage to the mattress could occur as it gets forced into the spaces between slats.
This is why I prefer plywood for mattress foundations: it provides continuous support for your mattress. But plywood isn't stiff enough to resist deflection in the center of the mattress, so I usually build a beam running from the headboard rail to the footboard rail to support the seam where the two pieces of plywood meet in the center. It's actually less work to do it this way and it saves you 40 bf of ash or other stiff hardwood. Normally you do not get noticeable deflection in the smaller (~30") spans between the center beam and the side rails, but you owe it to yourself to either work out the load distribution on paper or by empirical trial.
Sorry for the longwinded reply, but hopefully there is something useful in there.
>I disagree with not having a mattress. I tried it once, when I was young, and most mattress manufacturers will tell you that top mattresses are designed to have a bottom foundation, whether that is a box spring or a firm box.
Ask why they want to not have a box spring. If they want the mattress lower, then just design the rails lower, or even to sit on the ground like many of the low set ups.
I know that years ago, my chiropractor told me to get a good and firm mattress set, and recommended a couple of brand names. Since then, I have not needed those trips to cure an aching back.
>It's a little late to re-design. It is almost done. My daughter in law asked for it without the box spring.
I had previously made a similar bed for my other son and used three pieces of plywood with the seams perpendicular to the side rails. It works fine with no sag. I thought about using slats since I have to transport this one to Florida. That plywood is heavy.
>Here's my $.02. Go for the slats. At our cottage we used a sheet of plywood under the foam mattress of our bed. After one season's use, when we went to flip the mattress end for end, the plywood was somewhat discoloured. My guess is the combination of the heat from our bodies and no air circulation underneath caused a potential mold problem (I say potential because it hadn't yet turned into a problem). Of course, this may not even be an issue with a standard coil mattress; it may only be peculiar to foam mattresses (our trundle bed uses slats and has foam matresses, but no mold problem). Just something to consider.