Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Toola line borer review

Posts

Toola line borer review

#1

Toola line borer review

Bob McGovern

>I just received the Toola BT13 manual line boring machine, purchased off eBay and direct-shipped from the manufacturer in California. Delivered cost was about $1300, plus another $124 for thirteen carbide-tipped bradpoints. I requested 1/4� bradpoints rather than 5mm, because I like that size shelf pin.

Toola is a fairly new name in the line-boring market; I chose their smallest machine over the comparable Conquest and Delta tools. The Conquest has a smaller motor and a single straight lever (which I dislike on my mortiser) and cost a couple hundred dollars more. The Delta uses plastic gears in the spindle head, and the words 'gear' and 'plastic' do not mesh, so to speak. The Toola has steel gears.

It's a pretty little beast, in the main built like a tank. Unfortunately, it seems to have been assembled hastily, and 2.5 hours of fairly intensive work was required to render it usable out of the box. My first gripe is that the bits mount bottomed-out in fixed collets, using two set screws. Two of the collets are shorter than the others, requiring tweaking to get hole depth consistent. I would much prefer quick-release collets like my Grass hinge boring machine has: there are times you don't WANT to drill 13 holes at a pop.

The second, far more serious design/manufacturing flaw is flex in the head. First tests resulted in ovalized holes and the workpiece pushing away from the fence; the screws that hold the spindle beam on were not at all tight. Torquing them required tearing down much of the machine & reassembling it, because one of the allen screws is hidden. Teardown and adjustments would be much simpler if the job did not require about 5 different sizes of allen wrench, some SAE & others metric. Simplify, simplify. Really, it would be very easy to bolt on a diagonal brace that would eliminate all chance of flexing; Toola could even fit one between two existing screws and would not need to retool at all.

Once those bloody screws were very tight, the machine drilled crisp, evenly-spaced holes. Feed pressure is considerable. It is noisy, and I wish it had a momentary-contact switch that would turn it off between plunges. This is a safety issue, not just a convenience one. I'll be installing a trip switch of my own, so I don't perforate my hand when sweeping away shavings between panels. It's a four dollar part: put one on, Toola.

My final complaint is with the fence-adjustment knobs. These are a joke � sharp little plastic caps fitted over allen bolts. The bolt holes are not tapped deeply enough, so the cap screws won't tighten down, even with a big old allen wrench. I'll be swapping in some nice fat knobs from the hardware store. Also, the flip-stops don't clear their tightening lever properly.

Most of these complaints are minor, and easily addressed by anyone likely to require a quasi-production machine like this. But I get paid for building cabinets, not for repairing brand-new tools. I figure tweaking this machine cost me $75 in lost productivity; added that to the cost. It's still a pretty solid tool for less money than the Conquest. I'd probably buy it again. Toola does need to address these wrinkles, though. They do disservice to their product.

Re: Toola line borer review

#2

Picture1

Bob McGovern

>Three pictures.


img

Re: Toola line borer review

#3

Picture2

Bob McGovern

>The loose screws. Needs a gusset.


img

Re: Toola line borer review

#4

One more for the road

Bob McGovern

>The evil little fence-adjustment knobs. Note the front one won't bottom out.


img

Re: Toola line borer review

#5

Ellis Walentine

Excellent write-up, Bob

Ellis Walentine

>I admire your patience. It sounds like you finally ended up with a useful machine. It's unfortunate that new machines should require any tuning up at all.

Thanks for the thoughtful review.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Toola line borer review

#6

JL

Re: Toola line borer review

JL

>Good write-up. I've never used one of these type of machines. Do you ever remove some of the bits so you don't have to drill all the holes?

Re: Toola line borer review

#7

Re: Toola line borer review

Bob McGovern

>JL: Yep. But removing bits requires lots of time and two different allen wrenches. I can have em off the Grass Ecopress in ten seconds, because the collets are removable from the spindles. That would be nifty.

Re: Toola line borer review

#8

Ellis Walentine

I sent a note to the Toola folks

Ellis Walentine

>...now let's see if they have any input for us.

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: Toola line borer review

#9

Re: I sent a note to the Toola folks

Bob McGovern

>Thanks, Ellis -- scooped me. I was planning to do the same. It really is a promising tool -- but it appears they are running on the hairy edge with production schedules. Need to slow down and employ that torque wrench.

This is the kind of tool that can make a big difference in a small cabinet shop's life. Nice to see someone resisting the pressure to offshore it, too. Very much hope they succeed.

Re: Toola line borer review

#10

Re: Toola line borer review

frank shic

>bob, that's a very interesting write-up to me since i purchased a delta 32-325 last year. compared to the delta, there was almost no problem with the assembly and i did not have to alter the tool in any way. the indexing pins are pretty flimsy but i rely on mainly the fence stops which are easily adjusted and locked down. how much noise does your machine make? earmuffs are not absolutely required but do take the bite out of the din on my delta.

BTW which model of the grass hinge boring machine did you purchase? i bought a manual 110 volt version last year and it has revolutionized my cabinetmaking. have you figured out a good way to collect the chips?

Re: Toola line borer review

#11

Re: Toola line borer review

Bob McGovern

>Frank: I looked seriously at the Delta, but I really really hate the idea of plastic gears. One of those places cutting corners just ain't happening. Also has the single handle, which hurts my wrist. But a nice machine.

Heh. I actually didn't *buy* the Ecopress. It rather fell on top of me. A kitchen client mentioned his father bought one at a garage sale -- a sale conducted by an aggrieved wife whose hubby abandoned her and his entire woodworking shop & ran of with a young lass. One suspects prices were deeply discounted -- for spite as well as quick sales.

Anyhoo, my client wound up with it when his dad died, and I took it in trade for work. 0nce I got over switching hinge lines from Blum to Grass, I agree -- really changed how I work. No help on dust collection -- I think a cowling around back might help, but I just whick off the curlies once in a while. Those rubber-bumpers-as-fence at least let the shavings push clear; this new line borer has an extruded aluminum fence and no provision for chip clearance -- could really screw up accuracy.

My plan is to mount the Ecopress and the line borer back to back on a big rolling cart, with a single power cord. Such occasional-use tools, they need to scoot out of the way when you are finished. And that Ecopress is no fun to lift at all!

Hey -- have you tried the new Nexis Line from Grass? Cam adjust like the Blums, better baseplates, and a very good toolless soft-close at about $3 a door. Alas, the Nexis baseplates ain't compatible with the older hinge styles. Cuz I got a bucket of the bloody things.