Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Oil Stone Advice Requested -

Posts

Oil Stone Advice Requested -

#1

Oil Stone Advice Requested -

Ron, Eugene, OR

>Hello all - Now I realize that I may be in the minority with respect to still using an oil stone to sharpen plane blades. However, I know there are still a few of us using oil stones. My problem is that I discoved that a old double grit stone that I have has a slight semi-circular dip down the center. What I would like to know is, should I toss the stone and buy a new one - or should I try to flatten the stone and keep on using it? If the latter, how should I go about doing it?

As always, thanks in advance for your advise.

Re: Oil Stone Advice Requested -

#2

Re: Oil Stone Advice Requested -

john lucas

>Ron I flatten mine with 80 grit sandpaper on glass. I've been using it for years although not for plane blades. it would work I just prefer the scary sharp method for my plane blades.

Re: Oil Stone Advice Requested -

#3

Re: Oil Stone Advice Requested -

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>How deep is the dip? If it is more than 1/16" or so and it is a good hard stone I think you will run through more sandpaper trying to flatten it than a new stone would cost. I switched to water stones because they are very easy to flatten with sandpaper on glass. I flatten my water stones each time before using it, so it never has much of a dish in it; just a few swipes before a sharpening session will flatten them easily so I know I'm working on a flat surface. I have a collection of oil stones that are waiting for perhaps a milling machine (?) to flatten them.

Re: Oil Stone Advice Requested -

#4

easy solution

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>buy a diamond stone as this will flatten the oil stone. But don't waste the diamond stone on the oil stone. Throw the oil stone out and instead use the diamond which will cut many times faster.

I marvel that anyone still has the patience to use oil stones for sharpening.

Re: Oil Stone Advice Requested -

#5

Re: Oil Stone Advice Requested -

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I use 100 grit silicon carbide powder to flatten stones. I use about a teaspoon at a time with a little water on glass, adding more as necessary. My guess is that 6 or 8 minutes of hard labor would straighten you out. Oilstones require flattening quite a bit less often than waterstones. If you are careful to use the whole stone, flattening will be a rare occurence. I use the grit for waterstones as well.

I have never bought a flea market stone. They are hard to identify and could be of poor quality. Best to get a stone that you can replace if you need to.

I got my grit from a sandpaper factory about 30 years ago. The boss told me he could not sell me less than 100 lbs., but when I said why I wanted it he got a dustpan and scooped up about two pounds off the floor and gave it to me. I have used about half.

Re: Oil Stone Advice Requested -

#6

Jim in Burlington Ont.

40 grit

Jim in Burlington On

>I'd find a super coarse 40 grit belt for a belt sander. Split the belt and lay it out on something flat and go to town.

Re: Oil Stone Advice Requested -

#7

60 grit

Ron Bauman

>I get a small rect. or sq. pan from the local St. Vinnie's, a local glass man will cut me a piece of plate glass to fit, water to cover by 1/8", and 60 grit abrasive. I bought a pound or so from a local provider about 25 years ago and still have a good bit left. I true my Hard Arkansas every couple of years and the others a bit sooner. I prefer oil stones, maybe just out of habit.