Re: Aluminum failure - causes - long
Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana
>I kind of disagree, aluminum is used extensively by power companies for their drops from transformers to the meter base - but, I have had issues even with the aluminum drop outside my house. It became intermittent in one splice and I was losing half my house circuits (and all 220V). I did electrical work professionally for several years (over 30), so found the problem myself. It wasn't too hard as fire was flying out of the splice when I was tracing the problem. They replaced it, but I sure wouldn't have wanted it INSIDE my home. I have seen many failures of "properly" installed aluminum wiring. These include many mobile homes manufactured during the 1970 - 1980 era. I absolutely refused to work on any such home as I feared another problem wire would cause a fire and I would be blamed. I subcontracted all the HVAC and electrical work from a local Sears store for about 20 years (as a side job). During the Hunt brothers attempt to capture the copper market, prices of copper skyrocketed and Sears started to install Central air units using Aluminum (Corporate suggestion). I refused as I had seen too many failures in supposedly correct installations (Aluminum rated connectors, anti-oxidant coating applied, proper sized wire etc.). The store manager tried to convince me to use it, I told him to find someone else to install. He relented and I used copper. About 6 months later, corporate Sears issued a memo stating that no aluminum should be used and warranties would not be honored if any installed after that date. This was due to several lawsuits involving fires and - not sure - I believe at least one death. Needless to say the local manager was quite relieved and thanked me for my foresight and stubbornness. The major issues with aluminum are threefold. These are the expansion ratio, the softness, and the fact the oxides are not conductive. First the expansion rate is many times that of copper, therefore as the wire warms as it carries an electrical load it expands tremendously, as it expands - due to its softness, the connectors embed into the aluminum causing dents etc. When the load is taken off the aluminum contracts and the connector is now "looser". As this cycle continues the aluminum oxides in those areas where a gap occurs and more heat builds up - the aluminum becomes even more loose in the connector. This "loose connection" in conjunction with the non-conductive oxide causes high resistance in the joint. As this occurs, there is arcing and very high heating at the connector, eventually causing catastrophic failure. In most cases the circuit just opens up (if the connection is in a properly installed main etc.), but in a few, the excess heat and arcing will start a fire. In some ways I am frugal, but I can't see saving a few dollars and taking that chance. Many people store gasoline in unapproved containers in the shop or garage and get away with it, but I store mine in an outside shed. I do store flammable solvents in my shop, but they are in the original containers and in a metal storage cabinet with closed doors. I like to choose the chances I take, some things just aren't worth the risk.