Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

ELECTRICAL QUESTION

Posts

ELECTRICAL QUESTION

#1

ELECTRICAL QUESTION

Scott S.

>Last night we had a decent storm with alot of lightning. In the middle of the night. Keep this in mind.

About 4 months ago we moved into a new house here in town. The 3 bedrooms did not have light swithes just lamps on a dresser. We had a local electrician come and wire 2 swithces in each room, one for lights and one for the fan, they are nice to have. He also put in a new 200 amp box. All of a sudden the breaker popped for the new ceiling fans that we put in, when it was lightning so much. Just that breaker, no other ones. So I went to flip it, and about 1 minute later. POP!!! One more time. Then after that everything was fine. It has done this once before, but I just thought, coincedence. Well now I am wondering what is going on. Not gonna call him today. He needs to enjoy the holiday.

Scott

Re: ELECTRICAL QUESTION

#2

Re: ELECTRICAL QUESTION

Barry Irby

>Are these ordinary breaders or AFCI (Arc Fault Current Interrupters)?

Not sure it really matters but maybe it does. Maybe there was arcing.

Re: ELECTRICAL QUESTION

#3

Re: ELECTRICAL QUESTION

Ronald Walls

>You could of had a surge of electric from the storm that knock out the breaker. You may have to replace it. This is just a guess. You should get a hold of that electrian and let him check it out.

Re: ELECTRICAL QUESTION

#4

Was the wind blowing hard?

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>It's possible that when the wiring job was done a box clamp got screwed just a little too tight and cut into the insulation on the wire. There could also be a burr on a clamp that would do the same thing. A really good wind gust might shake the house just enough to cause a quick short that would trip the breaker. It would also make the "wound" a tad more severe and when you reset the breaker the resulting short melted away a little bit more metal clearing up the problem before you reset the breaker the second time.

This is only one of many possibilites but it is one I've seen a few times over the years.

Someday when I have time I'll post about the strangest electrical troubleshooting job I ever went on. I was able to identify where the problem was coming from and correct it but I have never had anyone from journeyman electricians to EEs explain HOW it was happening.

Re: ELECTRICAL QUESTION

#5

Re: Was the wind blowing hard?

Loftguy

>Hi,

Please do post the info on this electrical problem; I always find the solutions fascinating.

Bob

Re: ELECTRICAL QUESTION

#6

Re: ELECTRICAL QUESTION

Jim Pugh, Elyria, OH

>I had an intermittant outage on one circuit and chased it all over the house, checking junction boxes as I went. Finally mentioned it to a brother in law and he said it sounded like a weak breaker. I replaced it and the problem went away. So, something to look at.

Re: ELECTRICAL QUESTION

#7

Re: ELECTRICAL QUESTION

Bill Howatt

>Since you had a new 200 panel installed it could be that you have a new set of breakers and one is marginal from the factory. Other possibility is that the lightning surge damaged it. As another poster wondered, it might be a new arc-fault breaker that are required in bedrooms (some places, everywhere, ???) so it could be detecting an arc or is was just more sensitive to the lightning surge.

Lot of possibilities. One way of seeing if it is the breaker is to swap it out, or swap it with another one on a similar circuit and see if the problem moves with it.

My limited experience with weak breakers has been they would carry maybe 80% or more of the rating and for a bedroom circuit like yours it doesn't seem likely the loading would be that heavy unless you have a dehumidifier/AC or other hefty defice plugged into the same circuit - did you check to see what the loading is on that breaker?

Bill