Good wood (long)
Bob McGovern
>Howard: At one time, a squirrel could have hopped from Florida to Dakota without touching the ground. The rate of deforestation during the settling of America outstripped anything we are seeing in Brazil, Estonia, or Indonesia. And I wonder if it's ethical to deny peoples of other countries the chance to use their own resources -- even to make their own mistakes. Our trees have somewhat recovered, and a sort of equillibrium is back.
The problem, in timber as in drugs and human trafficking, really belongs on the demand side -- with the affluent countries. It's large transnational timber consortia that dictate to loggers what species to cut and how much they will be paid. National Geographic detailed a deal in Bolivian mahogany that will break your heart. A big foreign timber company contracted with indigines to cut 100k board feet; they actually took 300k, and paid something like $12,000US for the privilege.
Tropicals are cut (or bulldozed) for planting or livestock grazing; some of the wood is used to build local housing, but much is burned to enrich poor soil or just pushed into piles to rot. The real danger to ecosystems can be seen in places like Borneo, where the global hunger for teak has caused loggers to drive paths ever deeper into the highlands. These tracks become roads, the roads simplify mass extraction and pioneer farms. The roads wash out, fouling streams; fires get started and burn millions of acres, good wood lost; and animal species unused to predatory pressures become bush meat, victims of domestic animals or their diseases, or just succumb to habitat loss. Upshot: the First World wants teak for its yachts, so the orangutan dies.
What can we, as woodworkers, do? Well, we can't directly stop many of these practises, but we can monitor our own impact. Some ideas:
1) Buy local. In the US, hardwoods are cut selectively for grade and species. Clearcutting is for softwoods or development, not lumber. Choose an abundant wood like maple or oak, and you can feel pretty safe.
2) If purchasing exotics, choose Lesser-Known Species. These tend to be less heavily logged; with fewer loggers, fewer importers, and fewer wholesalers, you get a shortened supply chain. For example, I've done much work in chechen -- a lovely tropical from Mexico and Central America. It has not traditionally been thought of as a timber tree, so it is quite common. My wholesaler *can tell me the name of the guy that cut those trees,* and how much he got paid for them. Logging has a social cost as well as an ecological one; big timber exporters don't CARE if mahogany has blood on it, because there is a huge existing global market for mahogany and somebody will always buy it. Purchasers of LKSs can be more picky.
3) Limit yourself to wood labeled FSC or SmartWood -- two of the better guarantors of sustainable practices. Not perfect, but they have more inspectors on the ground than some of the other certifiers. Several wholesalers specialize in certified lumber; I've worked with these folks quite a bit:
http://earthsourcewood.com/
We are lucky we work in a material that is both precious and infinitely renewable. We can, with a bit of thought and effort, ensure a future that includes both teak AND orangutans. (Buy Brazilian teak -- 100% true plantation-grown!) Thanks for caring about this stuff.