Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Serious Discussion Please-Tropical Woods

Posts

Serious Discussion Please-Tropical Woods

#1

Serious Discussion Please-Tropical Woods

Howard

>We and our clients all love the look of the exotic woods. I've used mostly local hardwoods, but have used exotic veneers and a very little bit of hardwood. I just read that if action isn't taken, the rainforest in Indonesia will be gone. Here's the question and I can't seem to get comfortable on this - don't we have a perhaps even larger responsibility to protect our wood resources? I asked my local hardwood supplier if he knew how the exotics he was selling were harvested(legally or not). His answer was simple, he had no idea. Some have had various rationalizations that we should buy it since it's already been cut, using veneer is more responsible, blah blah blah. What do you all think.

Re: Serious Discussion Please-Tropical Woods

#2

Re: Serious Discussion Please-Tropical Woods

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>Actual use of wood products from the rain forest is not really contributing to the loss of the rain forest. In other words the rain forest would benefit from sustainable harvest. The problem is that the wood is being cut down and pushed into piles and burned to clear farmland because the wood has such small value. I think exotic wood like rosewood and ebony should be used with care because they do take such a long time to grow and does contribute in a small way to forest depletion. Some people are trying to get woodworkers to use more exotic wood so the forest has enough value that it won't be destroyed.

Re: Serious Discussion Please-Tropical Woods

#3

Quick use it up before it is Gone!

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: Serious Discussion Please-Tropical Woods

#4

Stats were...

HC Sakman

>as far as I can recall;

Rainforest used as fuel: 45%

destroyed for farmland: 40%

Glabally, 50%+ of all the trees used as fuel, 30%+ paper production and the rest for lumber, crates etc.

Give it a +/- 5% error for my memory.

Chico...

Re: Serious Discussion Please-Tropical Woods

#5

Re: Serious Discussion Please-Tropical Woods

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Whether or not we use it will have imperceptable impact on the certain destruction of the world's rain forests. It's a simple matter of imposed evolution.

Clint

Re: Serious Discussion Please-Tropical Woods

#6

Screwed either way.

Virgil johnson

>If we don't use the wood it has no value and the land will be cleared to graze cattle or grow veggies. If we use the wood they have to cut the trees. Its gonna take someone with more brains than me to figure this dilemma out.

Re: Serious Discussion Please-Tropical Woods

#7

Re: Serious Discussion Please-Tropical Woods

Keith Newton

>Howard, there was a time when almost everything that I made was from exotics. I am not so sure that was such a bad thing. In this time of disposable everything, I thing objects that are well designed and executed, and have lasting value is a good use for lumber from trees no matter where they originate.

I bought myself a little sawmill about seven years ago, and now am sawing and using urban trees for most of my work, except for veneers.

I am not so worried about the Indonesians and their timber. I am more worried about the American woodworking industry. When I see furniture made in Indonesia, for sale in the USA, it is often priced lower than I can go buy the same quantity of that species for as rough lumber. There is no way to manufacture anything here to compete with their prices. I think there may be a bigger issue with fair trade, and value of currencies.

Re: Serious Discussion Please-Tropical Woods

#8

Re: Serious Discussion Please-Tropical Woods

Jim Dillon

>Howard,

There was an excellent, comprehensive undercover investigation of the hardwood industry in the far east and eastern Russia in the Washington Post on April 1, 2007. The picture is very bleak. It is estimated that ALL hardwood forests in that region of the world will be GONE in 10-20 years if current practices continue. The basic problem is that millions of low-income (by our standards) people in those regions of the world depend on harvesting those forests (even in protected parkland) for their income. And the rest of the world requires more and more wood for its needs, regardless of where it comes from. Yet the big domestic chains, although they try to purchase sustainable wood, cannot meet the demand of their customers for more wood. So the exotic hardwood future, from those area of the world, do not appear to be very bright. And I suspect that the same thing is happening in the rest of the world, although I have no evidence of that. Not a happy thought.

Jim

Re: Serious Discussion Please-Tropical Woods

#9

Good wood (long)

Bob McGovern

>Howard: At one time, a squirrel could have hopped from Florida to Dakota without touching the ground. The rate of deforestation during the settling of America outstripped anything we are seeing in Brazil, Estonia, or Indonesia. And I wonder if it's ethical to deny peoples of other countries the chance to use their own resources -- even to make their own mistakes. Our trees have somewhat recovered, and a sort of equillibrium is back.

The problem, in timber as in drugs and human trafficking, really belongs on the demand side -- with the affluent countries. It's large transnational timber consortia that dictate to loggers what species to cut and how much they will be paid. National Geographic detailed a deal in Bolivian mahogany that will break your heart. A big foreign timber company contracted with indigines to cut 100k board feet; they actually took 300k, and paid something like $12,000US for the privilege.

Tropicals are cut (or bulldozed) for planting or livestock grazing; some of the wood is used to build local housing, but much is burned to enrich poor soil or just pushed into piles to rot. The real danger to ecosystems can be seen in places like Borneo, where the global hunger for teak has caused loggers to drive paths ever deeper into the highlands. These tracks become roads, the roads simplify mass extraction and pioneer farms. The roads wash out, fouling streams; fires get started and burn millions of acres, good wood lost; and animal species unused to predatory pressures become bush meat, victims of domestic animals or their diseases, or just succumb to habitat loss. Upshot: the First World wants teak for its yachts, so the orangutan dies.

What can we, as woodworkers, do? Well, we can't directly stop many of these practises, but we can monitor our own impact. Some ideas:

1) Buy local. In the US, hardwoods are cut selectively for grade and species. Clearcutting is for softwoods or development, not lumber. Choose an abundant wood like maple or oak, and you can feel pretty safe.

2) If purchasing exotics, choose Lesser-Known Species. These tend to be less heavily logged; with fewer loggers, fewer importers, and fewer wholesalers, you get a shortened supply chain. For example, I've done much work in chechen -- a lovely tropical from Mexico and Central America. It has not traditionally been thought of as a timber tree, so it is quite common. My wholesaler *can tell me the name of the guy that cut those trees,* and how much he got paid for them. Logging has a social cost as well as an ecological one; big timber exporters don't CARE if mahogany has blood on it, because there is a huge existing global market for mahogany and somebody will always buy it. Purchasers of LKSs can be more picky.

3) Limit yourself to wood labeled FSC or SmartWood -- two of the better guarantors of sustainable practices. Not perfect, but they have more inspectors on the ground than some of the other certifiers. Several wholesalers specialize in certified lumber; I've worked with these folks quite a bit:

http://earthsourcewood.com/

We are lucky we work in a material that is both precious and infinitely renewable. We can, with a bit of thought and effort, ensure a future that includes both teak AND orangutans. (Buy Brazilian teak -- 100% true plantation-grown!) Thanks for caring about this stuff.

Re: Serious Discussion Please-Tropical Woods

#10

What about bamboo? *LINK*

Joe Dusel (Vista, CA)

>I know that technically it's not wood (it's a grass), but it does seem to be an environmentally responsible alternative. It's nice looking, comes in two flavors - natural and amber, and since it comes in 4' x 8' sheets it is easy to work with and versatile. The vertical solid variety that Smith & Fong sells of PlyBoo looks a lot like an exotic solid wood.

Joe


Using Bamboo Plywood

Re: Serious Discussion Please-Tropical Woods

#11

Re: more Good wood (and also long)

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

>100% agreement here but I would also add to search out local sawyers who specialize in urban salvage. Urban salvage is a term used to describe the wood milled from our urban forests. Many of these trees, while not certified sustainable are removed for building projects within our cities or removed because they simply got too big for the small yard where they were growing. Some are even trees that blew over or were removed because they were near the end of their natural life cycle. Most of our urban forest ends up being made into mulch, but some is burned as fire wood or buried in land fills.

Urban salvage is not limited to the usual domestic hardwoods but can also include exotics which have been planted as decorative trees. A partial list of exotics I have encountered as urban salvage includes carob, camphor, zalcovia, english brown oak, and lacewood. And some of our lesser known domestics will look exotic to most because they have never seen them at their local supplier. This would include woods like olive, blue oak, locust, and acacia. I have left off many but you can see the picture I am trying to paint. This is a wonderful source of wood and often better quality than some of the over cut common domestic species.

This is also a way to get some great prices, especially if you are willing to buy green and take the entire log as it comes off the mill.

My customers often know the exact location where the tree was growing that their furniture was made from. For some reason in today�s mass produces culture this is a very satisfying thing and I often here them repeating to friends where the tree came from. It has an added value to the furniture that is difficult to describe or quantify but it is a way that distinguishes my work from the guy down the street that uses all exotics.

Robin Corell

Re: Serious Discussion Please-Tropical Woods

#12

Re: more Good wood (and also long)

Bob McGovern

>Excellent thoughts, Robin. Nothing adds value to woodworking better than a *narrative.* People don't just want furniture or cabinets, they want a story they can feel part of.

As for Joe's bamboo comment, I have it for flooring in three rooms of my house. Its rapid regrowth lends itself to bulk applications like floors and panels (see PlyBoo). All kinds of new recycled panel products are coming out, many w/out formaldehyde.

Re: Serious Discussion Please-Tropical Woods

#13

hiding details

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>Overall statistics like these are useful for grasping the larger forces at work, but they hide species-specific details like what is going on with mahogany or ebony. Sure, lots of timber is wasted, but that does not fully explain unsustainable harvesting rates of prized species.

Re: Serious Discussion Please-Tropical Woods

#14

excellent summary Bob

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>

Re: Serious Discussion Please-Tropical Woods

#15

lesser known domestics

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>Nice writeup Robin. You have pretty much explained how and why I got into urban logging myself. One of the best surprises I have had in these past four years is the wonders and richness of our lesser known domestic species.

One of the joys of some exotics is their hardness, rot resistance and interesting or unique colorations. Look no further than osage orange for a winner in all three categories. Black locust scores high on these points and can be quite beautiful in a furniture piece. QS sycamore or sweetgum have been most welcome discoveries. Take a rasp to some persimmon with a little heartwood coloration and it will be love at first stroke. Try some sassafras or honey locust or smaller fruitwoods for a fresh treat.

If any woodworker lives where these things grow, they ought to be able to find a supplier. Try calling the 800 number for Woodmizer or Timberking for starters; they can give you the names of mill owners near you.

Tom

who just cut up some gingko