Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Interior finish durability

Posts

Interior finish durability

#1

Interior finish durability

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi all,

About a year ago, I was starting a remodeling job for my in-laws. I made up a sample board for them to choose which finish they wanted for their oak board paneling. I gave them the choice of 2 coats of danish oil, water-based poly, shellac or oil-based poly. They ended up going with the shellac, which is a finish that I really like for paneling.

Anyway, a year later and I've been using the sample board as a table top for the tile saw to sit on. Consequently, it's been exposed to lots of water and sun, since it is "stored" outside. Not surprisingly, the oil-based poly is in the best shape of any of the finishes. Can anybody guess what the next most durable finish is?

Gary

Re: Interior finish durability

#2

Re: Interior finish durability

Paul Leuba

>My guess is that one or both of the danish oil finishes would be durable, only because of the oil content.

Paul in Hunt Valley

Re: Interior finish durability

#3

Re: Interior finish durability

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Not sure but I'll bet the shellac held up pretty well. I have seen some gourds made into birdhouses that were shellacked and seemed to look pretty good after a year or two. Kind of surprised as no one recommends shellac as outdoor.

Re: Interior finish durability

#4

Shellac

Mike Fitterling

>I spite of all the warnings about getting shellac wet, etc., everywhere on my sawhorses (left outside for 6 months) where there is shellac overspray, the shellac looks new.

Re: Interior finish durability

#5

Re: Interior finish durability

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>You got it, Larry,

The shellac came in second to the oil-base poly. They were the only two which showed any signs at all of still being there after a year out in the weather. The water-base poly and the danish oil were just raw wood. I was surprised because I've read in more than one place about how shellac is not very water-resistant.

Gary

Re: Interior finish durability

#6

Re: Shellac

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>You're right, too, Mike,

I was surprised that the shellac looked as good as it does. Neither of the better finishes look great after a year out in the weather, but you can at least tell that something was on there at one time.

Gary